(written from a Production point of view)
|"The Menagerie, Part I"|
|TOS, Episode 1x15|
Production number: 6149-16A
First aired: 17 November 1966
Remastered version aired: 25 November 2006
|←||16th of 80 produced in TOS||→|
|←||11th of 80 released in TOS||→|
|←||12th of 80 released in TOS Remastered||→|
|←||11th of 728 released in all||→|
| Written By|
Marc Daniels, Robert Butler ("The Cage" footage, uncredited)
|←||Arc: The Talosians (2 of 3)||→|
Mr. Spock fakes a message from the Enterprise's former commander, Christopher Pike, steals the vessel and sets it on a locked course for the forbidden planet Talos IV.
The USS Enterprise arrives at Starbase 11 after a subspace message asks it to divert there. When Captain Kirk, Spock and Dr. McCoy beam down, they are puzzled when the base commander, Commodore Mendez, tells Kirk the base sent no such message.
Kirk insists that Spock received the urgent request from the former commander of the Enterprise, Fleet Captain Pike. Mendez is surprised that Kirk does not know the news about Captain Pike and leads them to the medical section, explaining that, during an inspection tour of a cadet vessel, one of the baffle plates ruptured. Pike removed the cadets who were still alive, severely exposing himself to delta rays.
Now, confined to a wheelchair, Pike is disfigured and cannot speak, though his mind is unimpaired. His sole means of communication is a flashing light with an accompanying beep: once for yes, twice for no. Spock requests a moment alone with his former commander, and says cryptically to him, "You know why I have come.... I know it is treachery and it is mutiny, but I must do this." Pike can do nothing but repeatedly beep "No."
In Mendez's office, Kirk continues to defend Spock's claim that the starbase summoned the Enterprise. Mendez shows Kirk the record tapes, which show no such transmissions, and emphasizes that the paralyzed Pike could not have made the call – which was heard only by Spock. Kirk says that if Spock wanted to see Pike, Kirk would have granted him shore leave; moreover, there is no trouble in that sector of space that would have induced aliens to divert the starship as a ruse. Mendez calls the computer center, where Chief Humbolt confirms he has rechecked the data tapes, and the starbase could have sent no message without his knowledge. Humbolt leaves the lab and Spock slips in and begins operating a computer to create a voice transmission to the Enterprise.
Mendez's aide, Miss Piper, enters his office with a report that again denies summoning the starship. She mentions Spock's years of service under Pike, and indications of Spock's extreme loyalty to Pike. Kirk defends Spock, telling Piper that a Vulcan is incapable of disloyalty. But Piper and Mendez insist that Pike, under constant observation, could not have even asked for that message to be sent.
On board the Enterprise, Lieutenant Uhura receives a message from starbase operations with new orders – secret, scrambled, and to be fed directly into the ship's computers. Lieutenant Hansen orders Uhura to request confirmation.
Back on the starbase, as Uhura calls for confirmation, Humbolt walks in on Spock and notices Spock's alterations to the computer. Humbolt tries to wrestle and punch Spock away, but Spock nerve-pinches Humbolt into unconsciousness. Uhura then tries to call Kirk, but Spock has now prepared a tape of Kirk's voice, confirming the new orders and directing any questions to Spock. Spock then activates an intercom and tells Hansen the ship's computers will handle the helm, and forbids Hansen from discussing the orders with ship or starbase personnel.
Later, Kirk and McCoy watch Pike on a monitor, still blinking "no" to an unknown question. Kirk and McCoy discuss Pike's condition, the frustrating limitations on the art of medicine, the futility of solving the mystery through Pike, and the unimaginable possibility that Spock is lying.
Mendez shows Kirk a report on the planet Talos IV marked, "for eyes of Starfleet Command only." The report is the basis of the well-known General Order 7: "No vessel under any condition, emergency or otherwise, is to visit Talos IV," the only capital offense left on the books, for reasons known only to top fleet command. But the report does mention that the Enterprise was the only Starfleet vessel to have visited Talos IV – while commanded by Captain Christopher Pike with a science officer named Spock.
While discussing the situation, Miss Piper notices that Captain Pike has disappeared from his room on a monitor. Mendez contacts Starbase Operations and is told that the Enterprise is leaving orbit and refuses to acknowledge their signal.
The Enterprise departs from Starbase 11, completely under computer control. Uhura receives a communication signal but Spock tells her not to reply. He announces to the crew that Captain Kirk has been given medical rest leave and that he is assuming command. McCoy hears this upon entering the bridge and asks who made the diagnosis and who called a medical emergency. Spock takes McCoy to a guest quarters, containing Captain Pike, and plays a tape with the voice of Kirk, telling McCoy not to disturb Pike with questions but to follow Spock's instructions to the letter. During the recording, Pike again blinks "no" continually. When Spock returns to the bridge, Hansen tells him that a shuttlecraft is approaching, but Spock says they will not make contact.
Aboard the shuttlecraft Picasso, Kirk and Mendez try to raise the ship and Kirk gets angry when the Enterprise doesn't respond, as the shuttle has already traveled too far to return to Starbase 11. The shuttle's fuel runs out and it continues coasting forward. Kirk and Mendez contemplate the consequences for Spock and the inexplicability of his actions.
Aboard the Enterprise, Spock directs the library computer to execute pre-loaded instructions. The ship reverses engine power and comes to a full stop. Spock summons an armed security team to the bridge, orders the transporter room to beam Captain Kirk aboard, and places Lieutenant Hansen in command. Spock presents himself to McCoy (as senior officer present) for arrest on a charge of mutiny – the orders for Spock to take command of the Enterprise were false. The security team arrives and McCoy reluctantly confines Spock to quarters.
Kirk and Mendez beam aboard, and Hansen transfers command of the Enterprise to Kirk and explains the situation. The engines restart, but the computer retains control and defies Kirk's direct order to disengage. The computer controls are tied in to the ship's life support systems and cannot be disengaged until the ship reaches Talos IV.
As the Enterprise continues toward Talos IV, arrangements are made for a hearing. But Spock waives his right to the hearing and requests an immediate court martial. Kirk denies his request because, of the three required command-grade officers, there are only Kirk and Mendez on board. But Spock points out that Captain Pike is still on the active duty list. Mendez confirms this:
"We didn't have the heart to retire him, Jim. He's got you; whatever he's up to, he's planned it well."
The court martial convenes, with Mendez presiding. He reminds Spock that, if the Enterprise enters the Talos star group, a further charge involving the death penalty will be held against him, a fact of which Spock confirms he is aware. Mendez asks Spock what purpose it serves to go to Talos, and with Captain Pike, given the severity of the penalty. Spock asks if Mendez's comments are part of the record. Mendez says they are, and Spock then says he can only explain with the use of the viewscreen in the briefing room. Mendez's query has opened the door for any evidence Spock wishes to present, which Kirk believes is what Spock had in mind. Scott activates the viewscreen.
On the screen, the panel views the voyage of the Enterprise to Talos IV under the command of Pike, thirteen years prior. (These events are the episode "The Cage".)
The astonishing video record is much more detailed than were log entries in those days. Questioned by Kirk, Pike signals "yes," that it is he in the video, but "no," that such records were not made during the voyage. Spock will not explain how the video was produced, but reminds Mendez that viewing the video is necessary to answer the question Mendez asked him. Mendez says the court isn't obliged to view evidence without knowing the source, but Kirk insists on seeing more of it.
Later, Mendez interrupts the presentation again to remind Spock they are in a court of space law and not a theater. Spock asks Pike if they are witnessing the actual events of thirteen years previous. Pike beeps "yes." Spock then offers to release control of the ship if, after watching the complete transmission, the court still wishes to turn back. Mendez calls the situation ridiculous and says it has gone far enough. Kirk votes instead to continue and hear the full story. Mendez votes not to continue and declares a deadlock, but Kirk points out that there is still one member of the trial board to hear from. With that, Mendez asks Pike if the trial should continue. Pike beeps "yes."
On the viewscreen, the visit of Captain Pike and the Enterprise to Talos IV continues. Uhura interrupts the trial with a message from Starfleet informing Commodore Mendez that Starfleet's subspace monitors show the Enterprise has been receiving transmissions from Talos IV in violation of Starfleet general orders. Spock confirms that the video presentation is coming from Talos IV. Starfleet relieves Kirk of command, and orders Mendez to assume command of the Enterprise, disabling it if necessary to prevent further contact.
Mendez tells Spock that his contact with Talos IV has invited the death penalty: Spock has not only doomed himself but ended Captain Kirk's career as well. Spock protests that Kirk knew nothing about what was happening, but Mendez reminds Spock that a captain is responsible for everything that happens aboard his ship. Mendez then orders Spock to release the ship to manual control, and Spock respectfully declines. Mendez declares the court in recess. As everyone leaves, Kirk confronts Spock, asking him if he has lost his mind. Spock pleads with Kirk that, for his career and Captain Pike's life, he must see the rest of the transmission. Kirk orders the security guard to lock Spock up, and remains in the briefing room alone to contemplate the situation.
- Captain's log, stardate 3012.4. Despite our best efforts to disengage computers, the Enterprise is still locked on a heading for the mysterious planet Talos IV. Meanwhile, as required by Starfleet General Orders, a preliminary hearing on Lieutenant Commander Spock is being convened and in all the years of my service this is the most painful moment I've ever faced.
- Captain's log, stardate 3012.6. General court martial convened. Mr. Spock has again waived counsel and has entered a plea of guilty.
- Captain's log, supplemental. Mr. Spock on trial for mutiny has forced the court to accept unusual evidence. On our monitor screen, the voyage of Captain Pike and the Enterprise to the one forbidden world in all the galaxy.
"A Vulcan can no sooner be disloyal than he can exist without breathing."
- - Kirk, on Spock
"We've learned to tie into every Human organ in the body except one. The brain. And the brain is what life is all about. Now, that man can think anything we can, and love, hope, dream as much as we can. But he can't reach out and no one can reach in!"
- - McCoy, on Pike's paralysis
"...To question Spock of all people! Me, yes. I could run off half-cocked given a good reason, so could you! But not Spock. It's impossible!"
- - McCoy, considering and dismissing the possibility of rogue action by Spock
"Probably somebody discovered a hangnail."
- - McCoy, trying to explain the unexplained emergency order for him to beam aboard the Enterprise
"Rank hath its privileges."
- - Mendez, on why he joined Kirk in the shuttlecraft
"Spock would have some logical reason for going there."
"Maybe. Maybe he's just gone mad."
- - Kirk and Mendez, speculating on why Spock would hijack the Enterprise and take it to Talos IV
"I vote we continue."
"And I vote we do not! Deadlocked!"
"Not deadlocked, Commodore. There's still one member of the trial board we haven't heard from."
"Very well. Captain Pike, it's up to you. Do we continue under these conditions?"
(Pike's wheelchair beeps once)
- - Kirk and Mendez voting whether to continue watching the depiction of the Enterprise's mission to Talos IV
"Receiving transmissions from Talos IV? Then the images we've been seeing..."
"...are coming from Talos IV, sir."
- - Kirk and Spock, realizing the source of the video records that comprise Spock's evidence.
"Don't stop me. Don't let him stop me. It's your career and Captain Pike's life. You must see the rest of the transmission."
"Lock him up."
- - Spock and Kirk, after Mendez declares a court recess
Sets, props, and costumesEdit
- A matte painting was created for the Starbase 11 exterior. Large cranes can be seen in the background, representing construction on the starbase or perhaps assembly of starship components. The wall used in this scene was recycled for "A Taste of Armageddon", "Wolf in the Fold", "Plato's Stepchildren", and "Wink of an Eye". The round dais in front of the wall was later used by Tharn and his council in "Mirror, Mirror".
- The Starbase Operations set is a redress of the engineering room set. An opaque blue wall has been placed behind the grid to hide the forced perspective set. The panel in this room from which Spock issues orders to the Enterprise is a re-use of the neural neutralizer control panel from "Dagger of the Mind". The computer banks in the room will later be seen in "A Taste of Armageddon" and aboard the shuttlecraft in "The Immunity Syndrome".
- The structures seen outside Mendez's windows are cut-outs of buildings. In the first scene in Mendez's office, behind Kirk is a clear view of a corner of the set behind one of the pieces.
- Commodore Mendez's desk features one of the goose-neck video screens seen on the early Enterprise bridge in "The Cage".
- In this episode, "Court Martial" and "The Conscience of the King", we see 23rd century doors that are opened with handles.
- During the indoor scenes on Starbase 11, if you look outside the windows at the night sky and cityscape, you can occasionally see white objects passing by. These may have been intended to be shuttles or shooting stars. The most clear and undisputed scene in which to see one of these objects is in the beginning. After Commodore Mendez approaches Captain Pike in regard to his visitors, you can see a small white dot slowly flying in the lower left of the window.
- Scotty does not wear a dress uniform during Spock's court-martial, possibly due to budget constraints. He would finally get a dress tunic in "Space Seed".
- The door to Pike's quarters, in the Intensive Care area of Starbase 11, opens on hinges, rather than sliding into the wall. The courtroom door in "Court Martial" is similarly hinged.
- This is the final appearance of the tan phaser/communicator belts.
- Sean Kenney's make-up as the injured Captain Pike took five hours to apply. Also, his hair had to be dyed white, which then turned out to be too bright for the cameras, and had to be softened with powder. 
Story and productionEdit
- The footage used from the original pilot "The Cage" was directed by Robert Butler. He is not credited for it here although he is credited as the sole director of "The Menagerie, Part II" despite that episode also containing material shot by Marc Daniels.
- Butler was approached by Roddenberry to direct the episode, but he refused because he disliked the series. After Marc Daniels was assigned to direct the new footage, it was decided that he and Butler would share credit for the two episodes, Daniels for the first part and Butler for the second. 
- Robert Justman convinced Roddenberry to write a two-part episode utilizing the first pilot because they ran out of scripts in the middle of the first season, and had to shut down production otherwise. Roddenberry called it "the envelope" and wrote the episode in three or four days.  Director Robert Butler claimed it was Roddenberry's entrepreneur talent which managed to find a way using the failed pilot as a money saving device for the show. 
- The original "envelope" script was written by John D.F. Black, however Roddenberry was very unsatisfied with it, and rewrote it completely, finally taking sole writing credit. The insulted Black filed a Writers' Guild grievance over payment and screen credit, but his claims were denied. (Inside Star Trek: The Real Story, p. 251)
- According to James Doohan, Roddenberry originally wanted to sell the failed pilot as a theatrical film. However, it needed to be expanded with additional material to reach the feature length. Roddenberry planned to film the crash of the Columbia on Talos IV, because it didn't require Jeffrey Hunter, who was neither available or affordable to reprise his role as Captain Pike. However, plans for the feature release were soon abandoned.  Roddenberry's plans for a feature release are verified by Herb Solow and Robert Justman in Inside Star Trek: The Real Story (p. 251).
- When Spock orders the Enterprise back to retrieve the shuttlecraft, he tells the transporter room to "prepare to beam Captain Kirk aboard." He doesn't mention Mendez, who was seen on the shuttlecraft with Kirk. We find out in "The Menagerie, Part II" that by this point Mendez was a Talosian illusion, suggesting that Spock already knew that, or the Enterprise's sensors simply didn't detect anyone other than Kirk.
- Footage of the shuttlecraft is reused from "The Galileo Seven". But because it was aired before that episode, "The Menagerie, Part I" is technically the first episode featuring the shuttlecraft in The Original Series.
- A scene which shows crewman listening to the intercom in a corridor is reused from "The Corbomite Maneuver".
- This is the first time that the trio of Kirk, Spock, and McCoy beam down unaccompanied by any security guards or other personnel. Other episodes in which this occurred are "The Devil in the Dark", "Catspaw", "Amok Time", "Bread and Circuses", "A Private Little War", "A Piece of the Action", "The Paradise Syndrome", "And the Children Shall Lead", "The Empath", "For the World is Hollow and I Have Touched the Sky", "Plato's Stepchildren", "Requiem for Methuselah", "All Our Yesterdays", and "Turnabout Intruder".
- This is the same starbase seen in "Court Martial". It is not made clear why there is now a different commodore in charge of the base. Perhaps Mendez and Stone had different responsibilities. Stone had been referred to as the base's commanding officer in the previous episode, named in the credits as the "portmaster."
- The Star Trek Compendium compared Spock's risking his career and life to return Pike to Talos IV for a chance at a better life to what Kirk would later do for Spock in Star Trek III: The Search for Spock. (pp. 164-165)
- The preview trailer for this episode has the stardate as 1512.2.
- The first winner of the Strange New Worlds contest, "A Private Anecdote", depicted Pike reminiscing during his convalescence at Starbase 11.
Significance and legacyEdit
- This episode won the 1967 Hugo Award for "Best Dramatic Presentation". Combined with "Part II," it's the first of four Star Trek episodes to win the award. The others are "The City on the Edge of Forever", "The Inner Light", and "All Good Things...".
- "The Menagerie, Part I" and "The Menagerie, Part II" constitute the only two-parter in the run of the original Star Trek.
- Chris Pike's wheelchair has become ensconced in popular culture, and has been seen in Futurama and South Park.
- "The Menagerie, Part I" was the twelfth remastered episode of the Original Series to air. It premiered in syndication the weekend of 25 November 2006 and took about two months of work by the CBS Digital team.  The remastered version of this episode featured new footage of the shuttlecraft (here called the Picasso, SB11-1201/1), replacing the stock footage produced for "The Galileo Seven". A new digital matte painting of Starbase 11 was created as well, for establishing shots as well as for views outside windows. Live actors were also digitally inserted into the base, giving it a far more active appearance.
- A limited-time-only theatrical presentation with "The Menagerie, Part II" occurred on 13 November 2007 and 15 November 2007. It included a message from Gene "Rod" Roddenberry Jr., a twenty-minute "making of" documentary about the restoration process, and a trailer for Season Two of the remastered series. 
Alternate home video releaseEdit
In 1980, Paramount Home Video released this episode as the first of five volumes of classic series episodes on VHS as Television Classics on VHS and Betamax videocassette. This version however, is slightly edited to present the episode in one part, rather than two parts. The credits at the end of the episode and the closing credits are removed from part I and the opening teaser recounting the events from Part I and the regular opening sequence are removed, instead doing a quick fade-out and cut into the first act of Part II. All other video releases present the episode in its proper two-part version.
- First draft teleplay "From the First Day to the Last" by John D.F. Black: 12 August 1966
- First draft teleplay "The Menagerie" by Gene Roddenberry: 21 September 1966
- Second draft teleplay: 3 October 1966
- Final draft teleplay: 7 October 1966
- Revised final draft teleplay by Gene L. Coon: 10 October 1966
- Additional revisions: 13 October 1966, 14 October 1966, 17 October 1966
- Filmed: 11 October 1966 – 18 October 1966
- Original airdate: 17 November 1966
- Rerun airdate: 18 May 1967
- First UK airdate: 23 August 1969 (Part 1), 30 August 1969 (Part 2)
- Hugo Award: 1967
- Remastered airdate: 25 November 2006
- Limited-time-only theatrical presentation (remastered edition with "The Menagerie, Part II"): 13 November 2007 and 15 November 2007
Video and DVD releasesEdit
- US CED VideoDisc release: 22 March 1981
- US LaserDisc release: 1 October 1984 (ASIN B001BFX97Y)
- Original US Betamax release: 1985
- UK VHS release (two-episode tapes, CIC Video): Volume 9, catalog number VHR 2274, release date unknown
- Japan LaserDisc release: 10 November 1992
- US VHS release: 15 April 1994 (ASIN B000AMHQO6, ASIN B000JFFIY4)
- UK re-release (three-episode tapes, CIC Video): Volume 1.6, 7 October 1996
- Original US DVD release (single-disc): Volume 8, 22 February 2000 (ISBN 6305744890)
- As part of the TOS Season 1 DVD collection
- As part of the TOS Season 1 HD DVD collection
- As part of the TOS Season 1 Blu-ray collection
Links and referencesEdit
Special guest starEdit
- Malachi Throne as José I. Mendez
- M. Leigh Hudec as Number One (archived footage)
- Peter Duryea as José Tyler (archived footage)
- John Hoyt as Philip Boyce (archived footage)
- Adam Roarke as Garison (archived footage)
- DeForest Kelley as Dr. McCoy
- James Doohan as Scott
- Nichelle Nichols as Uhura
- Majel Barrett as the computer voice
- William Blackburn as Hadley and an Orderly at Starbase 11
- Frank da Vinci as Vinci and a Patient at Starbase 11
- Brett Dunham as a Security lieutenant
- Laurel Goodwin as J.M. Colt (archived footage)
- Clegg Hoyt as Pitcairn (archived footage)
- Anthony Jochim as a Columbia survivor #3 (archived footage)
- Jon Lormer as Theodore Haskins (archived footage)
- Tom Lupo as a Security guard
- Edward Madden as an Enterprise geologist (archived footage)
- Jan Reddin as an Enterprise court recorder
- Leonard Mudie as a Columbia survivor #2 (archived footage)
- Eddie Paskey as an Leslie and an assistant at Starbase 11
- Serena Sande as the Second Talosian (archived footage)
- George Sawaya as Humbolt
- Georgia Schmidt as the First Talosian (archived footage)
- Meg Wyllie as The Keeper (archived footage)
- Tom Curtis as Starbase 11 Starbase Operations com voice
- Unknown performers as:
- Enterprise bridge crewman #1 (archived footage)
- Enterprise bridge crewman #2 (archived footage)
- Enterprise bridge crewwoman (archived footage)
- Enterprise transporter assistant (archived footage)
- Enterprise transporter technician
- Computer technician at Starbase 11
- Doctor at Starbase 11
- Officer on Starbase 11 mall
- Mendez' secretary at Starbase 11
- Starbase 11 Starfleet personnel:
- Richard Barnett (on the mall)
- Jimmy Berndt (on the mall)
- Toni Pace Carstensen (on the mall)
- James Holt (in an office window)
- Nicki Kreitzman (in an office window)
- David LaFountaine as Federation administrator (in an office window)
- Denise Okuda as an operations division officer (on the mall)
- Michael Okuda as a science division officer (on the mall)
- Dave Rossi as a command division officer (on the mall)
- Wendy Ruiz (in an office window)
- Cliff Welsh (in an office window and on the mall)
- Niel Wray as a science division officer (on the mall)
2236; 2254; 2265; baffle plate; battery; "Bones"; brain; chief; class F shuttlecraft; class M; Columbia, SS; coma; computer center; Comsol, Robert L.; commodore; delta radiation; death penalty; duranium; Earth; fleet captain; General Order 7; Class J starship; hangar deck; Johansson, Helen; logic; Milky Way Galaxy; monitor screen; nitrogen; Orion colony; oxygen; patrol; Picasso; radio silence; Regulus; Rigel VII; space sector; Starbase 11; Starbase 11 planet; Starbase Operations; Talos IV; Talos star group; Talosian system; Talosians; tape; Vega colony; Vulcan; Vulcan nerve pinch
Library Computer ReferencesEdit
- The Menagerie, Part I at Memory Beta, the wiki for licensed Star Trek works
- The Menagerie, Part I (episode) at StarTrek.com, the official Star Trek website
| Previous episode produced:|
| Star Trek: The Original Series|
| Next episode produced:|
"The Menagerie, Part II"
| Previous episode aired:|
"The Corbomite Maneuver"
| Next episode aired:|
"The Menagerie, Part II"
| Previous remastered episode aired:|
|TOS Remastered|| Next remastered episode aired:|
"The Menagerie, Part II"