Changes: The Arsenal of Freedom (episode)

Revision as of 18:14, 2 September 2011

Template:Realworld

On a planet famous for its munitions industry, the crew of the Enterprise is threatened by a deadly automatic weapons system.

Summary

Arriving at Minos in the Lorenze Cluster to investigate the disappearance of the USS Drake, the USS Enterprise-D enters orbit. Discovering no life signs on the planet's surface, they are surprised by a hail from a peddler, which is actually an automated message from the time of the Erselrope Wars. Commander Riker, Natasha Yar and Data transport down to the planet's surface to investigate. Yar finds a piece of melted tritanium and Data finds a high-tech mounted weapon in a ruined structure. Riker comments on the finds, and Yar mentions that the weapon is beyond current Federation technology.

Suddenly, Captain Paul Rice, the commanding officer of the USS Drake, appears from behind the bushes and engages Riker in conversation. Back on Enterprise, they confirm that there are still no other lifeforms other than the away team, but there is an energy build-up close to the commander. Captain Rice asks Riker about the abilities of the Enterprise, which raises suspicions in Riker's mind, and soon realizes that he's not speaking to the real Captain Rice. Rather than give away any information, Riker gives Rice false information about the USS Lollipop rather than Enterprise, calling it "a good ship." Riker then reveals to the fake captain that he knows he's fake, and Rice is quickly replaced by a weapon device.

Before the away team can respond, the weapon fires on Riker, encasing him in a bubble of energy. Yar quickly fires back, and destroys the weapon. Data and Yar examine the bubble holding Riker in stasis, and contact the captain to tell him that Riker has been trapped by a force field. Unable to transport Riker to the ship, the captain and Doctor Crusher transport down to the planet's surface to help, leaving Geordi La Forge in charge on the bridge.

On the planet's surface, Picard and the others theorize about the reason why the weapon put Riker in stasis rather than kill him. Data is instructed to try and use his phaser to cut away the bubble, but just as he starts, the Enterprise hails the away team, informing them that another energy reading has appeared, and that it is moving towards them. Yar takes up position next to Data, and the second weapon arrives, knocking Doctor Crusher over. The captain goes to help her, as the weapon begins firing.

Suddenly, the ground under the captain and the doctor gives way, and they both fall down into an underground cavern. Picard lands well, but the doctor is almost buried in loose sand and rocks. Meanwhile, Data and Yar battle with the second weapon, discovering that it has learned and adapted from its previous encounter, and is now evasive and much more difficult to destroy. However, the combined effort of the two is enough to destroy it. Finally noticing the disappearance of the captain and the doctor, Yar and Data try and contact them with their communicators, but they're no longer working. Yar decides to go off and try and find them, leaving Data with the still immobile Riker.

Back in the cavern, Crusher is nearly unconscious, with a broken arm and heavy bleeding. Picard also discovers that their communicators are malfunctioning. Yar returns to Data, after failing to find the captain, and discovers that Data has figured out the precise setting to use to dissolve the bubble around Riker. He fires his phaser, and Riker is released, almost unharmed.

Back on Enterprise, La Forge receives a report that they can now beam up the entire away team, but suddenly the deflector shields raise automatically, as one of the weapons starts firing at the ship from almost point-blank range. The blast rocks the ship, but the shields hold. Just before their weapons can target the device and destroy it, it vanishes from the sensors, appearing moments later behind the ship, and firing again. Realizing that the ship won't be able to stand up to this much punishment indefinitely, and that the away team can't be beamed up with the shields up, La Forge is left to ponder his options.

Chief Engineer Logan arrives on the bridge, and, hearing La Forge's plan of staying in orbit to try and rescue the away team, he demands that La Forge relinquish his command to him, a higher-ranking officer. However, La Forge is more interested in trying to destroy the weapon, so he ignores Logan, and tells Worf to compute the predicted attack path of the weapon, firing in the dark. Logan continues to interfere, and La Forge sends him back to engineering, saying he's in command until relieved by either Commander Riker or Captain Picard.

Back on the planet, a third weapon has been released, and this time it is equipped with its own deflector shield. Data comments that the weapon continues to upgrade itself after every encounter. But, still, now with the combined fire-power of three phasers, they just about manage to destroy the weapon. Data tells Riker that the weapons appear every twelve minutes, which gives them all the incentive they need to be off the planet by that time.

In the cavern, Picard continues to make sure Crusher doesn't fall unconscious. He discovers that she's got another, more serious, wound on her leg, which is bleeding heavily. The captain manages to stop the bleeding, and although Crusher is still in shock, he tries to do his best for her.

Back on the ship, La Forge and the bridge crew are just about ready for their first test shot. The phasers and photon torpedos are fired simultaneously, but they miss totally. This is reinforced by the weapon firing on the shields once again. As La Forge sits back in his chair, disappointed, the weapon fires again, further damaging the shields. Everyone on the bridge is now looking to him for orders, as the weapon fires once more. La Forge then calls for Logan to come to the bridge. As soon as he arrives, La Forge calls for the Enterprise to go to warp and leave the orbit of the planet, surprising everyone on the bridge.

La Forge then orders Lieutenant Logan to take command of the saucer section of the Enterprise, ensuring the safety of the majority of the crew, while La Forge takes the stardrive section back to the planet. When La Forge and the bridge crew have relocated to the battle bridge, the ship separates, leaving the saucer section behind.

Meanwhile back in the cavern, Picard uncovers an alien viewscreen. A holographic projection of the same salesman as they'd seen before appears and begins extolling the virtues of the "Echo Papa 607," the Minosians' ultimate achievement. Picard is shocked to be told that the attacks on the away team and the Enterprise have simply been part of an automated "demonstration" of the weapon. Picard tells the salesman to abort the demonstration, but the salesman says they have to see what the weapon can do. Beverly volunteers that the salesman program doesn't understand anything other than what it's been programmed to sell - it has no idea that its parent civilization was wiped out.

The salesman continues to explain the weapon: after each encounter with the enemy, the central unit learns and adapts its weapons to combat them. Once it is activated, the Echo Papa 607 is unstoppable. The captain realizes that this is all too true: it was the Minosians' own weapon system that destroyed their civilization. The unit then signals that the final weapon device is about to be launched.

Commander Riker and the others locate the hole the captain and the doctor fell through, but there is no way for them to reach each other. Then Data states that he can safely jump down the eleven meter drop without damage. This surprises everyone, but without hesitation, the android officer jumps down the hole, and easily survives the impact. Riker and Yar take up defensive positions in an attempt to prepare for the final weapon.

Minosian — The peddler sells the weapon to Picard

As the star drive section of the Enterprise returns to Minos, La Forge tries to give the two young officers (Solis and Lian T'Su) some encouragement. Back in the cavern, the final weapon is launched, and Data attempts to reprogram the targeting settings. Finding no alternate targets for the weapon to lock onto, however, Data draws a blank. Crusher suggests that they simply turn the machine off. The idea is so simple, Picard hadn't even considered it. He demands to the peddler to turn off the machine. Again, the peddler seems not to understand, insisting that they have to see everything the machine can do. Picard says they've seen enough, and quickly agrees to "buy" the weapon system. Satisfied, the peddler congratulates Picard on his decision, and disappears. The effect is instant – the display screen goes blank, the final weapon deactivates, and the dampening field blocking communications is released.

USS Enterprise-D firing on the Echo Papa 607 drone — The *Enterprise* firing on the drone

However, things are not so good on Enterprise. The weapon system is still functional in orbit of the planet, and is chasing the ship. La Forge orders the ship into the planet's atmosphere, where the atmospheric interaction with the weapon's cloak will reveal its presence. As the Enterprise descends, the shields begin to fail, but, just in time, T'Su detects a disturbance to starboard. Worf instantly locks phasers on the weapon and destroys it easily. Celebrating their victory, the bridge crew quickly returns the Enterprise to standard orbit and T'Su reports the away team being transported aboard.

When Captain Picard and Riker arrive on the battle bridge La Forge rises from the captain's chair to relinquish command but Picard refuses. At first La Forge doesn't understand but Picard tells La Forge that when he left, the Enterprise was still in one piece and that he would appreciate it being returned to him in that same condition. So La Forge, delighted that he will remain in command for a bit longer, orders Solis to lay in a course for a rendezvous with the saucer section while Picard and Riker watch on and T'Su reports that sickbay says Dr. Crusher will be fine.

Memorable quotes

"Who sent you here to look for me?"
"Your mother. She's worried about you."

- Rice's hologram and Riker

"Tell me about your ship, Riker. It's the Enterprise, isn't it?"
"No... the name of my ship is the... Lollipop."
"I have no knowledge of that ship."
"It's just been commissioned. It's a good ship."

- Rice's hologram and Riker

"What's the armament on your ship?"
"Ten."
"Ten? I don't understand, ten what?"
"Six."
"Commander Riker, your answers make no sense."
"You haven't used my first name once, Paul. You remember it, don't you?"

- Rice's hologram and Riker, who is becoming suspicious

"Mr. Logan, you will take command... of the saucer section."

- Geordi La Forge

"We MISSED!"

- Worf

"Peace through superior firepower."

- The Peddler, in the automated message played to Enterprise

"Where are the people of Minos?"
"Once unleashed, the unit is...invincible - the perfect killing system."
"Too perfect...You poor fools - your own creation destroyed you!"

- Picard, realizing the truth about Minos, and The Peddler

"Captain, Data's going to join you down there."
(Data jumps 11.75m down into the cavern, landing on his feet, unaffected)
"Data?"
"At your service, captain."

- Riker, Picard and Data

"Relinquishing command, captain."
"As you were, Lieutenant."
"Sir?"
"Mr. La Forge, when I left this ship, it was in one piece. I would appreciate your returning it to me in the same condition. Do you concur, Number One?"
"Absolutely, sir."

- La Forge, Picard, and Riker, just as Picard and Riker arrive on the battle bridge

Background Information

Production history

Robert Lewin had originally meant "The Arsenal of Freedom" to develop the implied romantic relationship between Picard and Crusher. Roddenberry, however, nixed the idea, and Lewin cited Roddenberry's lack of interest in character development as his reason for leaving the show. Other sources have suggested that Lewin's departure may also have been stimulated by friction with Maurice Hurley, who adapted Lewin's story and wrote the episode's teleplay.

The big emotional scene, with Picard and Crusher trapped in a cavern, was conveniently interrupted by a handy plot development before it could go beyond anything but the vaguest of hints. Originally, Crusher was going to reveal her true feelings to the gravely wounded Picard, but matters were switched so that Crusher was the injured party.

This change worked, but the failure of the scene to make its intended point was frustrating not only to Lewin but to director Les Landau and to most viewers. The scene was further marred by a fact not readily discernible to viewers watching at home; it seems that the sand in the cavern was infested with fleas, which made the shoot an utterly miserable experience for Patrick Stewart and Gates McFadden, who were under constant attack by the minute bloodthirsty creatures. (Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion; Captains' Logs: The Unauthorized Complete Trek Voyages; Trek: The Unauthorized Behind-The-Scenes Story of The Next Generation)

The closed captioning for this episode replaces the term "Erselrope wars" with "Romulan wars."

Continuity

Echo papa 607 model — Dan Curry's son holding the original Echo Papa 607

This episode marks the third appearance of one of the Enterprise's chief engineers, after Sarah MacDougal (TNG: "The Naked Now") and Argyle (TNG: "Where No One Has Gone Before", "Datalore"); in this case, it's Lieutenant Logan.
The saucer separation was created completely by using stock footage from "Encounter at Farpoint".
Footage of Jonathan Frakes (William T. Riker) from the scene with Rice was later used in the series finale "All Good Things..." so he could appear younger and beardless.
This is the last episode in Season 1 to have red alert sounded and is also the last appearance of the old style red alert flashing lights. The old style red alert lights only flash on and off at the top and bottom, however, the next episode to have red alert sounded which will be "Where Silence Has Lease" will feature the regular lights that entirely flash on and off and will be used for the rest of the show's run.
An Echo Papa 607 drone, holographically masquerading as Paul Rice, stated the USS Drake had a max. speed of Warp 3, which would make it the slowest starship in Starfleet in the 24th century.
The miniature of the Echo Papa 607 was built by visual effects supervisor Dan Curry, using an old L'Eggs pantyhose container and a discarded shampoo bottle. (Star Trek Encyclopedia, TNG Season 1 DVD special feature "Memorable Missions")}}
This is the second and last episode to show La Forge in command.
Wesley does not appear in this episode.

Production timeline

Revised final draft script: 22 January 1988
Second revised final draft script: 25 January 1988
Premiere airdate: 11 April 1988

Video and DVD releases

Original UK VHS release (two-episode tapes, CIC Video): Volume 11, catalog number VHR 2440, 8 April 1991
UK re-release (three-episode tapes, Paramount Home Entertainment): Volume 1.7, catalog number VHR 4648, 7 September 1998
As part of the TNG Season 1 DVD collection

Links and references

Starring

Also starring

LeVar Burton as Lt. Geordi La Forge
Denise Crosby as Lt. Tasha Yar
Michael Dorn as Lt. Worf
Gates McFadden as Doctor Beverly Crusher
Marina Sirtis as Counselor Deanna Troi
Brent Spiner as Lt. Commander Data

Guest stars

Vincent Schiavelli as Minosian peddler
Marco Rodriguez as Captain Paul Rice
Vyto Ruginis as Lieutenant Logan
Julia Nickson as Ensign Lian T'Su
George De La Peña as Lieutenant junior grade Orfil Solis

Uncredited co-stars

Log entries

External links

Previous episode:
"Heart of Glory"

Star Trek: The Next Generation
Season 1

Next episode:
"Symbiosis"

@@ Line 60: / Line 60: @@
 La Forge then orders Lieutenant Logan to take command of the [[saucer section]] of the ''Enterprise'', ensuring the safety of the majority of the crew, while La Forge takes the [[stardrive]] section back to the planet.  When La Forge and the bridge crew have relocated to the [[battle bridge]], the ship separates, leaving the saucer section behind.
-Meanwhile back in the cavern, Picard uncovers an [[alien]] viewscreen.  A [[hologram|holographic]] projection of the same salesman as they'd seen before appears and begins reciting his speech about the weapon system.  The captain realizes that it was the Minosians' own weapon system that destroyed their civilization.  The peddler then continues his speech and declares that the final weapon device is about to be launched.
+Meanwhile back in the cavern, Picard uncovers an [[alien]] viewscreen.  A [[hologram|holographic]] projection of the same salesman as they'd seen before appears and begins extolling the virtues of the "[[Echo Papa 607]]," the Minosians' ultimate achievement.  Picard is shocked to be told that the attacks on the away team and the ''Enterprise'' have simply been part of an automated "demonstration" of the weapon.  Picard tells the salesman to abort the demonstration, but the salesman says they have to see what the weapon can do.  Beverly volunteers that the salesman program doesn't understand anything other than what it's been programmed to sell - it has no idea that its parent civilization was wiped out.
+The salesman continues to explain the weapon: after each encounter with the enemy, the central unit learns and adapts its weapons to combat them.  Once it is activated, the Echo Papa 607 is unstoppable.  The captain realizes that this is all too true: it was the Minosians' own weapon system that destroyed their civilization.  The unit then signals that the final weapon device is about to be launched.
 Commander Riker and the others locate the hole the captain and the doctor fell through, but there is no way for them to reach each other.  Then Data states that he can safely jump down the eleven [[meter]] drop without damage.  This surprises everyone, but without hesitation, the [[android]] officer jumps down the hole, and easily survives the impact.  Riker and Yar take up defensive positions in an attempt to prepare for the final weapon.
 [[File:Minosian.jpg|thumb|left|The peddler sells the weapon to Picard]]
-As the star drive section of the ''Enterprise'' returns to Minos, La Forge tries to give the two young officers ([[Orfil Solis|Solis]] and [[Lian T'Su]]) some encouragement.  Back in the cavern, the final weapon is launched, and Data attempts to reprogram the targeting settings.  Finding no alternate targets for the weapon to lock onto, however, Data draws a blank.  Crusher suggests that they simply turn the machine off.  The idea is so simple, Picard hadn't even considered it.  He demands to the peddler that the machine is turned off, and, after agreeing to buy the weapon system, the peddler agrees.  The effect is instant &ndash; the display screen goes blank, the final weapon deactivates, and the dampening field blocking communications is released.
+As the star drive section of the ''Enterprise'' returns to Minos, La Forge tries to give the two young officers ([[Orfil Solis|Solis]] and [[Lian T'Su]]) some encouragement.  Back in the cavern, the final weapon is launched, and Data attempts to reprogram the targeting settings.  Finding no alternate targets for the weapon to lock onto, however, Data draws a blank.  Crusher suggests that they simply turn the machine off.  The idea is so simple, Picard hadn't even considered it.  He demands to the peddler to turn off the machine.  Again, the peddler seems not to understand, insisting that they have to see everything the machine can do.  Picard says they've seen enough, and quickly agrees to "buy" the weapon system.  Satisfied, the peddler congratulates Picard on his decision, and disappears.  The effect is instant &ndash; the display screen goes blank, the final weapon deactivates, and the dampening field blocking communications is released.
 [[File:USS Enterprise-D firing on the Echo Papa 607 drone.jpg|thumb|The ''Enterprise'' firing on the drone]]