Wikia

Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Featured article reviews

View source

Back to page

(Shinzon: support FA removal)
(Archived Shinzon Vfar > 7 Days)
Line 2: Line 2:
   
 
==Articles nominated for removal==
 
==Articles nominated for removal==
===[[Shinzon]]===
 
Put simply, I don't feel this is good enough to be a featured article. It lacks the clear sectioning used in other featured articles (see [[William T. Riker]]), and there is a mix of canon and apocryphal (sic?) data in contrast to the MA practice of including non-canon data at the bottom of a page. Clearly a page on a one movie villain who was only briefly expanded upon cannot be as in depth or elongated as the provided example above, but even featured pages about subjects such as the [[Cardassian Rebellion]] - an event which only lasted a few episodes and was never really covered directly (Kira & Damar's shown actions being largely tunnelled), we get a much more convincing layout than what's shown here. And if you think that a subject such as Shinzon simply cannot be detailed as much as this because there is simply less data, it seems clear that the article cannot be considered to be on the same level of quality. - [[User:Hayter|Hayter]] 13:40, 3 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 
 
:I '''agree''' with you, Hayter, it looks like this one slipped through the net when it was put up for featured status. It needs a total overhaul, and probably a peer review before it gets re-assessed for FA status. [[{{ns:user}}:Zsingaya|<span style="color:#00FF00;">Zsingaya</span>]] <sup> [[User talk:Zsingaya|''Talk'']]</sup> 14:21, 3 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 
 
:I '''support''' its removal as a featured article. This page has been incorrectly labeled as such since July 26th, 2004, and it was apparently never nominated. And it certainly could use some work before becoming a featured article. --[[User:Shran|From Andoria with Love]] 05:05, 4 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 
 
:'''Support''' removal, definetly. --[[User:Starchild|Starchild]] 05:44, 4 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 
 
:'''Support'''; if for no other reason then because it wasn't voted on prior to featuring it. (I haven't seen the movie so can't judge its accuracy and such.) [[User:Sloan|Sloan]] 05:53, 4 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 
 
:'''Support''' FA removal. Seems not to have been discussed before, and was edited considerably after. -- [[User:Cid Highwind|Cid Highwind]] 12:31, 4 Dec 2005 (UTC)
 

Revision as of 10:07, December 18, 2005

Template:Farc

Articles nominated for removal

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki