Wikia

Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Featured article reviews

View source

Back to page

m (damn, never mind for now)
(rm Shran (success) and Babel One (failed), + SS uniforms)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{FARecons}}[[Category:Memory Alpha maintenance|{{PAGENAME}}]]
 
{{FARecons}}[[Category:Memory Alpha maintenance|{{PAGENAME}}]]
 
==Reconfirmations without objections==
 
==Reconfirmations without objections==
=== [[Thy'lek Shran]] ===
+
=== [[Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia‎]] ===
{{FA/Thy'lek Shran}}
+
{{FA/Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia}}
 
----
 
----
This article was nominated back in June 2004. I did some formatting to bring it up to modern conventions (such as sub-headings, behaviour of the appearance list etc.) and added some background information from actor [[Jeffery Combs]] which I think gives some interesting insight into the character. All in all, I think the article stands up well, and deserves to retain its featured status.&ndash;[[User:Cleanse|Cleanse]] <small><sup>( [[User talk:Cleanse|talk]] | [[Special:Contributions/Cleanse|contribs]] )</sup></small> 05:49, January 17, 2012 (UTC)
+
Originally nominated in January 2008, this article failed and was renominated four days later, leading to it being considered "problomatic". We have a blurb template for this article located [[Template:FA/Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia|here]]. I personally don't have any opinion on this currently, though I've added some basic formatting updates after preliminary skimming the article. - {{User:Archduk3/Sig/nature}} 07:21, January 30, 2012 (UTC)
* '''Support'''&ndash;[[User:Cleanse|Cleanse]] <small><sup>( [[User talk:Cleanse|talk]] | [[Special:Contributions/Cleanse|contribs]] )</sup></small> 05:49, January 17, 2012 (UTC)
 
* '''Support'''. Also, here's a link to the blurb template: {{tl|FA/Thy'lek Shran}}. - {{User:Archduk3/Sig/nature}} 16:00, January 17, 2012 (UTC)
 
* '''Support''', One minor thing, I seem to remember Shran telling Jhamel something about his early life in one of the "Aenar" episodes. If that is so, it might be added to the a bit short "Early life" section at some time by somebody who has access to the episode. Otherwise fine...--[[User:Sennim|Sennim]] 13:29, January 20, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
 
==Reconfirmations with objections==
 
==Reconfirmations with objections==
=== [[Babel One (episode)]] ===
 
[[File:Gral archer.jpg|thumb|Ambassador Gral and Captain Archer]]
 
{{e|Babel One}} was the 12th episode of the fourth season of ''Star Trek: Enterprise''.
 
 
On the bridge of the Andorian warship ''Kumari'', Commander Shran crawls out from under the wreckage of his damaged ship which has been attacked by a Tellarite vessel. He attempts to contact Imperial Command, but communications are down. The computer announces a warp containment breach in two minutes, leaving Shran no other choice but to order the crew to abandon ship, vowing to make the Tellarites pay for the loss of ''Kumari''.
 
 
In Captain Archer's quarters aboard ''Enterprise'', Archer and Hoshi Sato roleplay that Sato is a Tellarite ambassador, in preparation for the real ambassador's arrival. They discuss the Tellarites' frequent arguing and Sato tells the captain to keep Porthos out of sight during their stay, as they consider canine a delicacy.
 
----
 
One of the "problematic" featured articles that was nominated, withdrawn, and renominated all within a week in February 2005. The nomination can be seen [[Talk:Babel One (episode)#FA status|here]]. I don't currently have any opinion on the article as it is now, since I haven't had time to completely read it. - {{User:Archduk3/Sig/nature}} 16:25, January 17, 2012 (UTC)
 
 
* '''Oppose''' - I just looked through the background info, and had to remove half of it as speculation or irrelevant commentary. What's left is severely lacking in content, and has citation deficiencies.&ndash;[[User:Cleanse|Cleanse]] <small><sup>( [[User talk:Cleanse|talk]] | [[Special:Contributions/Cleanse|contribs]] )</sup></small> 03:50, January 18, 2012 (UTC)
 
* '''Oppose''' &ndash; a very old FA, it badly needs updated (either to current FA standards or even just generally). --[[User:Defiant|Defiant]] 04:23, January 18, 2012 (UTC)
 
* '''Oppose''' - I tend to agree having now read the article. I find the summary to be fine overall, but the rest is sorely lacking. - {{User:Archduk3/Sig/nature}} 15:40, January 18, 2012 (UTC)
 
* '''Oppose''' - As above, the writing could do with an overhaul and there are quite a few "micro-paragraphs" that could be integrated with a little bit more imaginative writing..--[[User:Sennim|Sennim]] 13:29, January 20, 2012 (UTC)
 
   
 
== Early reconfirmations ==
 
== Early reconfirmations ==

Revision as of 11:20, February 3, 2012

Template:FARecons

Reconfirmations without objections

Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia‎

Template:FA/Schutzstaffel uniforms and insignia


Originally nominated in January 2008, this article failed and was renominated four days later, leading to it being considered "problomatic". We have a blurb template for this article located here. I personally don't have any opinion on this currently, though I've added some basic formatting updates after preliminary skimming the article. - Archduk3 07:21, January 30, 2012 (UTC)

Reconfirmations with objections

Early reconfirmations

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki