|
|
| Line 20: |
Line 20: |
| |
** '''Support''' [[User:AmdrBoltz|AmdrBoltz]] 04:50, 22 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
** '''Support''' [[User:AmdrBoltz|AmdrBoltz]] 04:50, 22 May 2005 (UTC) |
| |
** '''Support''' [[User:Jaz|Jaz]] 04:53, 22 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
** '''Support''' [[User:Jaz|Jaz]] 04:53, 22 May 2005 (UTC) |
| − |
|
|
| − |
*[[Leonard H. McCoy]] -- This article seems to have been extensively added to over the last few days by an unregistered contributor. I and some others have done a bit of cleanup and some wiki work. The big question: is it ready for the featured article status? I happen to say yes - anything that can be added would be largely a bonus at this stage, I think -- [[User:Dmsdbo|Dmsdbo]] 01:34, 3 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
**'''Reservations''' - I think this article is already pretty good, but it looks like (from the editing page) that certain sections were ear-marked for expansion, but were never completed. These include more references to [[TOS]]: "[[The Man Trap]]", [[TAS]]: "[[The Ambergris Element]]", "[[Once Upon a Planet]]", and [[Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country]]. The pictures were not arranged near to the specific parts of the text, but I've corrrected this. [[User:Zsingaya|zsingaya]] 16:32, 4 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
**'''Second''' - [[User:Dmsdbo|Dmsdbo]], thank you for the nomination! I appreciate your taking notice of the additions I made over the past few days. I noted your request for bonus additions, and expanded on the "later career" section, as well. I hope this helps. I am not savvy with pictures, however, and would appreciate some help--can anyone add a picture or two of McCoy at work? Operating or healing someone? Having a drink with the captain? Is there a picture depository we can draw from? Thank you! -- [[User:CMO|CMO]] 16:52, 4 May 2005 (EST) |
|
| − |
**'''Opposed'''- I would like to think I got the ball rolling on this article, and it still hasn't fulfilled the expectations I had for it when I introduced the <nowiki><!--NOTES--></nowiki> within the article for what would be nice to have added to it. IMHO, it still needs additions from "[[The Ambergris Element]]", "[[Once Upon a Planet]]", and more on Star Trek VI. --[[User:Gvsualan|Gvsualan]] 14:01, 5 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
***I think that is an unfair assessment of the article. What has already been included puts some other main cast featured articles, such as [[Miles O'Brien]], in a lower tier. There has to be a difference between necessary additions and improvements. -- [[User:Dmsdbo|Dmsdbo]] 14:04, 5 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
***I meant no disrespect to previous contributors, and give them full marks for what they have done before me. We're all working together on this project, and I think we all feel elated when someone takes notice of our work. As for the TAS episodes, I myself have not seen these two and did not wish to contribute something I knew nothing about. Let me put out the call: has anyone seen these episodes enough to make a quick contribution to them? -- [[User:CMO|CMO]] 10:20, 5 May 2005 (EST) |
|
| − |
**Fine, in the interest everyone making a big deal out of this and since this is a community effort...I'll add the TAS stuff ''later'' and give it my '''approval''' now. I'm not trying to be an ass, and yes, we do have lesser articles with featured status. However, those articles were given approval a long time ago and we, as writers, have been able to greatly improve our skills since then and therefore should be expected to have higher overall standards. We shouldnt have the frame of "well this is better than ''that one''?", we should be asking "is it as good as ''this one''?". --[[User:Gvsualan|Gvsualan]] 15:00, 6 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
***Well, I’ve seen those episodes. No problem, I’ve added the information to the article. Gvsualan, despite your retraction, you’re displaying a very bad attitude about this, talking about “getting the ball rolling” and “YOUR expectations” for the article. I think that [[User:Dmsdbo|Dmsdbo]] and [[User:CMO|CMO]] have done some fine work on the article for McCoy! I don’t understand why you didn’t add the TAS information yourself, but that’s no reason to hold it up in the first place. You were right about one thing, this is a free public site where ANYONE can make changes! Please take YOUR expectations to your own site and let us get back to enjoying this site we create together! --User: 24.47.59.222 , 21:32, 6 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
****I did no work on the McCoy article -- most was done by [[User:CMO|CMO]] and [[User:Gvsualan|Gvsualan]]. Unregistered users should not be posting here, and I only left the comment because you contributed information to the article that was desired. If you wish you wish to participate further please register. If this is a registered user, you should remember to sign in! -- [[User:Dmsdbo|Dmsdbo]] 21:45, 6 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
***Some people are taking these objections to heart! There is plenty of information already for the article to be made Featured, IMHO. When it is featured, there's nothing to stop someone adding more stuff later on. [[User:Zsingaya|zsingaya]] 08:40, 7 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| − |
***I agree with [[User:Zsingaya|zsingaya]]. Let's all play nice together, now. :) -- [[User:CMO|CMO]] 13:14, 7 May 2005 (EST) |
|
| − |
***Now the new additions have been made, I'm giving my '''Support''' for this article - there's so much information about McCoy on this page! [[User:Zsingaya|zsingaya]] 16:11, 17 May 2005 (UTC) |
|
| |
|
|
|
| |
==Nominations with objections== |
|
==Nominations with objections== |
