Wikia

Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Featured article nominations

View source

Back to page

(archiving Return to Raimon)
Line 2: Line 2:
   
 
==Nominations without objections==
 
==Nominations without objections==
===[[Return to Raimon]]===
 
*It has been awhile since I have done anything with this. I had opened a [[Talk:Return to Raimon/peerreview|peer review]] on this almost 9 months ago, and have only received comments from a now banned user. I've written what I think to be a fairly complete summary, listed canon/non-canon characters, etc., all the jazz that I think makes our non-canon articles good. We even have that fun behind the scenes info on how the cover was created. --[[User:OuroborosCobra|OuroborosCobra]] <sup>[[User Talk:OuroborosCobra|<span style="color:#00FF00;">talk</span>]]</sup> 15:32, 4 January 2008 (UTC)
 
 
**'''Comment'''. I'm not sure how to put my finger on it, but, aside from the Summary, the text looks sort of bare-bones and formal. Sort of the difference between a telephone book (what I see here) and a travel brochure (making it interesting to the uninitiated). Particularly in the background, I'd like to see what you observed as worthy of mention. Was there anything unusual as far as the way characters or technology were depicted? Were there thematic similarities to any other episodes? How do we arrive at the date we've established for this story? I'm not a big fan of character sections, but it looks like the standard we have for these sort of pages. If it could be made to look more like what was done with "[[Ghosts]]", the only other Featured comic we've had, that would go a long way toward improving the visual appeal of the article. -- [[User:Connor Cabal|Connor Cabal]] 15:53, 4 January 2008 (UTC)
 
***I'll take a look at the comic again, see what I can do to fix that. I of course was hoping to get comments like this in the peer review, but no one seems to look at those (this isn't directed at you Connor Cabal, and in fact I am just as guilty as everyone on that). I probably won't be able to do anything major until Monday, as my schedule probably won't allow me to be on much until then. --[[User:OuroborosCobra|OuroborosCobra]] <sup>[[User Talk:OuroborosCobra|<span style="color:#00FF00;">talk</span>]]</sup> 16:19, 4 January 2008 (UTC)
 
 
**I'm kind of neutral. This goes back to what we define as a 'featured' article. Its quite thourough, but as Connor said, it doesn't really go above and beyond. However, the same could be said about a number of our featured articles. I am uncertain. Though the peer-review is probably a better setting for this, let me just say, the some possible additions (similar to those added to Ghosts during its PR and FA process) include an artwork section and some more thorough analysis of the greater context within Trek. --- [[User:Jaz|Jaz]] 02:19, 11 January 2008 (UTC)
 
 
 
===[[SS uniforms and insignia]]===
 
===[[SS uniforms and insignia]]===
 
*'''Renomination''' after an extensive overhaul and rewrite of the entire article. Article's first nomination can be found [[Talk:SS_uniforms_and_insignia#From_Nominations_for_Feature-article|here]]. As a result, article was worked over with content added, insignia sections expanded, background section greatly expanded, and images touched up and redone thanks to the awesome work of [[User:Cid Highwind]]. With these additions, strongly recommend approval as a Featured Article. -[[User:FleetCaptain|FleetCaptain]] 17:52, 10 January 2008 (UTC)
 
*'''Renomination''' after an extensive overhaul and rewrite of the entire article. Article's first nomination can be found [[Talk:SS_uniforms_and_insignia#From_Nominations_for_Feature-article|here]]. As a result, article was worked over with content added, insignia sections expanded, background section greatly expanded, and images touched up and redone thanks to the awesome work of [[User:Cid Highwind]]. With these additions, strongly recommend approval as a Featured Article. -[[User:FleetCaptain|FleetCaptain]] 17:52, 10 January 2008 (UTC)

Revision as of 12:07, January 19, 2008

Template:FeatNom

Nominations without objections

SS uniforms and insignia

  • Renomination after an extensive overhaul and rewrite of the entire article. Article's first nomination can be found here. As a result, article was worked over with content added, insignia sections expanded, background section greatly expanded, and images touched up and redone thanks to the awesome work of User:Cid Highwind. With these additions, strongly recommend approval as a Featured Article. -FleetCaptain 17:52, 10 January 2008 (UTC)
  • Support. The article has really been improved! -- Rom Ulan 17:54, 10 January 2008 (UTC)
  • Support. Very well done.--31dot 23:04, 10 January 2008 (UTC)
  • Strong Support. The amount of work put into this article is staggering. It epitomizes the best of Memory Alpha. -- Connor Cabal 14:39, 12 January 2008 (UTC)
  • Support - I liked it before but now its even better! – Cleanse 08:57, 14 January 2008 (UTC)

Nominations with objections

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki