Wikia

Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Featured article nominations

View source

Back to page

m (Nominations without objections)
Line 4: Line 4:
   
 
*[[The Aenar]] - Self nominated. Includes multimedia, pictures and extensive Summary, Background Information and Links and References sections. --[[User:Defiant|Defiant]] | [[User talk:Defiant|''Talk'']] 01:47, 6 Mar 2005 (GMT)
 
*[[The Aenar]] - Self nominated. Includes multimedia, pictures and extensive Summary, Background Information and Links and References sections. --[[User:Defiant|Defiant]] | [[User talk:Defiant|''Talk'']] 01:47, 6 Mar 2005 (GMT)
 
*[[Spock]] - has a lot of interesting information with helpful pictures. --[[User:Defiant|Defiant]] | [[User talk:Defiant|''Talk'']] 03:01, 5 Mar 2005 (GMT)
 
   
 
==Nominations with objections==
 
==Nominations with objections==
 
<!--When moving nominations to this section, add to top.-->
 
<!--When moving nominations to this section, add to top.-->
*"[[Equinox, Part I]]" and "[[Equinox, Part II]]". Self-nomination, just added all details to this episode which I can think of. A few dead links at the moment, but I'm working on them -- [[User:MiChaos|MiChaos]] 19:09, 7 Nov 2004 (CET).
+
*[[Spock]] - has a lot of interesting information with helpful pictures. --[[User:Defiant|Defiant]] | [[User talk:Defiant|''Talk'']] 03:01, 5 Mar 2005 (GMT)
**Supported, but like [[Parallels]], needs some pictures... Of course, thats not a reason to seriously object, but a suggestion. [[User:Ottens|Ottens]] 19:20, 8 Nov 2004 (CET)
+
: '''Nay''' -- Unfortunely interesting information and helpful pictures do not make it a complete article. --[[User:Gvsualan|Gvsualan]] 02:41, 6 Mar 2005 (GMT)
**'''Supported''' Is this down here for a reason? [[User:Tyrant|Tyrant]] 19:26, 21 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
 
**'''Nay''' - as the Ottman said 4 months ago, both still need pics! --[[User:Gvsualan|Gvsualan]] 04:40, 25 Feb 2005 (GMT)
 
   
 
* [[Federation-Cardassian War]]. Self-Nominated. Think I've got all references to this conflict. [[User:Tyrant|Tyrant]] 19:19, 21 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
 
* [[Federation-Cardassian War]]. Self-Nominated. Think I've got all references to this conflict. [[User:Tyrant|Tyrant]] 19:19, 21 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant

Revision as of 02:41, March 6, 2005

Template:FeatNom

Nominations without objections

  • The Aenar - Self nominated. Includes multimedia, pictures and extensive Summary, Background Information and Links and References sections. --Defiant | Talk 01:47, 6 Mar 2005 (GMT)

Nominations with objections

  • Spock - has a lot of interesting information with helpful pictures. --Defiant | Talk 03:01, 5 Mar 2005 (GMT)
Nay -- Unfortunely interesting information and helpful pictures do not make it a complete article. --Gvsualan 02:41, 6 Mar 2005 (GMT)
  • Federation-Cardassian War. Self-Nominated. Think I've got all references to this conflict. Tyrant 19:19, 21 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
    • Oppose - I'm sorry, but I really don't think this is good enough to make it as a featured article. Compared with other FAs of the same type, it's of significantly lesser quality. Whilst I recognise that this is because it has only been referred to in dialogue and snippets over half-a-dozen seasons, and may be comprehensive in terms of its coverage of what has been said, it doesn't feel like a Featured Article. In addition, the sectioning of the article is awkward, and indeed, poor. The small size of the article makes such sectioning unnecessary (and an "Overview" section is always frowned upon - such information should just be the initial paragraph, and not starting with a section header). Moreover, the content isn't correct - there has been no explanation as to the cause of the war, the references provided offer no evidence to support the paragraph. -- Michael Warren | Talk 21:15, 21 Feb 2005 (GMT)
      • Can an article of this type be featured? As it cannot have the quality of the other events because the necessary information simply does not exist. The sectioning has been removed, as has the misinformation, which for the record came from Maquis, I trusted it because that article is currently featured. Still maybe lacking feel. Tyrant 19:29, 22 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
        • Any article can be a featured article, as long as it's good enough. The length of an article should not be considered here, it's about the quality of the writing, and of course all available information should be included. Since I don't remember the episodes referred to, Michael could be correst as far as I know in saying these references do not support "facts" written here. That should be checked by those who have seen the episodes. As last remark, I would suggest not using the two symbols of the powers involved in this conflict in such a fashion - IMO it looks rather akward. I don't think there are any images of the actual conflict available, though... For now, opposed, but could make a well FA in the future. Ottens 16:24, 23 Feb 2005 (GMT)
          • Well, I respect your opinions. I will make any changes requested of the community, as I would like to see this article featured. Futher suggestions? Tyrant 20:39, 23 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
  • Cloaking device; Excellently written article, makes good use of images. Makes superb usage of available information, as well as duly noting inconsistancies. | THOR 23:24, 13 Feb 2005 (GMT)
    • I don't seem to miss any information. Good references, nice accompanying pictures, extensive write-up. Ottens 16:27, 15 Feb 2005 (GMT)
    • Supported Tyrant 17:10, 15 Feb 2005 (GMT)Tyrant
    • Supported - All the important points are there. Solid effort! -- Balok 18:36, 15 Feb 2005 (GMT)
    • Support. -- SmokeDetector47 00:53, 16 Feb 2005 (GMT)
    • Needs More. A few things come to mind that are missing, upon further review, such as references about chronitons, and a passing reference to "Past Tense, Part I". Also, "The Die is Cast", "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield", "When the Bough Breaks" and "The Emissary" all contain useful references, or at the least, unexplored references to cloaks.--Gvsualan 17:48, 18 Feb 2005 (EST)
      • What does "Let That Be Your Last Battlefield" say about cloaks? There is an invisible budget-saving ship, but it does not use a cloak. The info on that is already at stealth, where it belongs. As for the others, I either haven't seen them ("Emissary", "Bough Breaks") or don't recall any relevance ("Past Tense" and "Die is Cast"). -- Steve 21:01, 23 Feb 2005 (GMT)
Just because you haven't watched an episode, does not mean it's information is void. For specific reasons, they all possess nuggets, or the seed to other areas or abilities yet unrevealed in said article. All I am saying is that more research is required. --Gvsualan 23:32, 23 Feb 2005 (GMT)

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki