Memory Alpha
Don't have an account?
Register
Register
Memory Alpha
Memory Alpha
57,147
pages
in: TNG episodes
English

Changes: A Matter of Perspective (episode)

Back to page
Sign in to edit
(→‎Reception: + note)
(33 intermediate revisions by 17 users not shown)
Line 10: Line 10:
 
| sAirdateMonth = February
  
| sAirdateMonth = February
 
| nAirdateDay = 12
  
| nAirdateDay = 12
−
| sImage = RikerwithRikerManuaSims.jpg
 +
| sImage = Tanuga IV.jpg
 
| wsWrittenBy = [[Ed Zuckerman]]
  
| wsWrittenBy = [[Ed Zuckerman]]
 
| wsTeleplayBy =
 
| wsTeleplayBy =
Line 34: Line 34:
 
== Summary ==
  
== Summary ==
 
=== Teaser ===
  
=== Teaser ===
−
[[File:Tanuga IV.jpg|thumb|Tanuga IV Research Station]]
 +
[[File:Picard paints.jpg|thumb|''"...interesting."'']]
−
[[Captain]] [[Jean-Luc Picard|Picard]] is attending [[art]] class with two other [[crew]]members, and all three are painting canvasses of an unknown figure – later revealed to be a nude model. [[Lieutenant commander]] [[Data]] enters and informs the captain that the [[USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D)|''Enterprise]]'' has arrived at [[Tanuga IV]], and that the [[away team]] has completed its survey of Dr. [[Nel Apgar]]'s research and is ready to return. Picard acknowledges Data while Data tries to subtly get a better look at the captain's painting. Picard notices and makes a gesture allowing Data to examine his work and that of the other students. Data compliments the work of [[Ensign]] [[Williams (Male Ensign)|Williams]] and [[Lieutenant]] [[Wright (Lieutenant)|Wright]], but he is much more critical of Picard's work, saying that it is disorganized, using too many disparate techniques. Picard grimaces while Data makes his assessment but "thanks" him when he feels that Data has said enough, and the [[android]] leaves.
 +
[[Captain]] [[Jean-Luc Picard|Picard]] is attending [[art]] class with two other [[crew]]members, and all three are painting canvasses of an unknown figure – later revealed to be a nude model. [[Lieutenant Commander]] [[Data]] enters and informs the captain that the [[USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D)|''Enterprise'']] has arrived at [[Tanuga IV]], and that the [[away team]] has completed its survey of Dr. [[Nel Apgar]]'s research and is ready to return. Picard acknowledges Data while Data tries to subtly get a better look at the captain's painting.
  +
  +
Picard notices and makes a gesture allowing Data to examine his work and that of the other students. Data compliments the work of [[Ensign]] {{dis|Williams|Male Ensign}} and [[Lieutenant]] {{dis|Wright|Lieutenant}}, but he is much more critical of Picard's work, saying that it is disorganized, using too many disparate techniques. Picard grimaces while Data makes his assessment but "thanks" him when he feels that Data has said enough, and the [[android]] leaves.
   
 
:"''[[Captain's log]], [[Stardate]] 43610.4. After completing a delivery of [[dicosilium]] to the Tanuga IV research station, our away team has received an update from Doctor Nel Apgar on his efforts to create [[Krieger wave]]s, a potentially valuable new power source.''"
  
:"''[[Captain's log]], [[Stardate]] 43610.4. After completing a delivery of [[dicosilium]] to the Tanuga IV research station, our away team has received an update from Doctor Nel Apgar on his efforts to create [[Krieger wave]]s, a potentially valuable new power source.''"
   
−
Picard enters the [[bridge]], welcoming Lieutenant commander [[Geordi La Forge|La Forge]] back from the station. The captain asks where [[Commander]] [[William T. Riker|Riker]] is. La Forge replies that he is still on the station where Dr. Apgar is working as Apgar wanted to speak to Riker. Although La Forge replies evenly, Picard notices some tension in his speech, and asks if there were any problems.
 +
Picard enters the [[bridge]], welcoming Lieutenant Commander [[Geordi La Forge|La Forge]] back from the station. The captain asks where [[Commander]] [[William T. Riker|Riker]] is. La Forge replies that he is still on the station where Dr. Apgar is working as Apgar wanted to speak to Riker. Although La Forge replies evenly, Picard notices some tension in his speech, and asks if there were any problems.
   
  ⚫
[[File:EnterprisePOV ApgarStationDestroyed.jpg|thumb|left|An unexpected explosion]]
 
The [[chief engineer]] seems unsure of how to reply but says that nothing went wrong with the scientific portion of the mission. Picard becomes even more curious about what happened on the station due to La Forge's explanation, but La Forge is spared when Riker's exasperated voice is heard through the [[communicator]] asking to leave immediately. La Forge tells the captain that Riker will explain when he returns.
  
The [[chief engineer]] seems unsure of how to reply but says that nothing went wrong with the scientific portion of the mission. Picard becomes even more curious about what happened on the station due to La Forge's explanation, but La Forge is spared when Riker's exasperated voice is heard through the [[communicator]] asking to leave immediately. La Forge tells the captain that Riker will explain when he returns.
   
−
Chief [[Miles O'Brien|O'Brien]] engages the [[transporter]] to bring Riker back, but nothing happens, and when he reads the console, he immediately calls [[engineering]], informing them of a power drain. The station suddenly explodes, to the horror of Picard and the bridge crew. O'Brien hasn't beamed Riker back yet as he is having trouble clearing the [[first officer]]'s signal, but eventually Riker is brought aboard. Riker asks why O'Brien is so surprised that he brought him back; O'Brien informs him of what just happened and Riker is visibly shocked.
 +
[[Chief]] [[Miles O'Brien|O'Brien]] engages the [[transporter]] to bring Riker back, but nothing happens, and when he reads the console, he immediately calls [[engineering]], informing them of a power drain. Without warning, the station suddenly explodes, blowing up Dr. Apgar, to the horror of Picard and the bridge crew. O'Brien hasn't beamed Riker back yet as he is having trouble clearing the [[first officer]]'s signal, but eventually Riker is brought aboard. Riker asks why O'Brien is so surprised that he brought him back; O'Brien informs him that the science station just exploded and Riker turns to the transporter, with a visibly shocked look.
   
 
=== Act One ===
  
=== Act One ===
⚫
[[File:EnterprisePOV ApgarStationDestroyed.jpg|thumb|left|The ''Enterprise'' watches on as the Tanugan science station explodes]]
  
 
:"''Captain's log, supplemental: Commander Riker has informed me that Doctor Apgar was the only one aboard the space station when it exploded. We remain in orbit investigating the accident...''"
  
:"''Captain's log, supplemental: Commander Riker has informed me that Doctor Apgar was the only one aboard the space station when it exploded. We remain in orbit investigating the accident...''"
   
  +
[[File:Riker questions O'Brien.jpg|thumb|''"We weren't sure you left the space station in time!"'']]
−
O'Brien tells the captain (over the com) that he has checked throughout the transporter system and hasn't found a malfunction or anything that could have caused an explosion like the one that just destroyed the station. He cannot explain the brief power drain just before the explosion, either. Data informs Picard that the [[radiation]] and debris are consistent with an overload of the station's [[reactor core]] but neither La Forge nor Riker saw any indications of problems with the [[fusion reactor|reactor]] while they were on board the station. Picard turns his attention to Riker and asks him about the mission not going quite so routinely. Riker is slightly dismissive and doubts that it had anything to do with the explosion. [[Worf]] informs the Captain that Chief Investigator [[Krag]] of the [[Tanugan]] security force is requesting permission to beam aboard; Picard grants permission and asks Worf to escort him to the bridge. While Worf is escorting Krag, Picard wants Riker to explain what happened on board the station as best as he can.
 +
O'Brien tells the captain (over the com) that he has checked throughout the transporter system and hasn't found a malfunction or anything that could have caused an explosion like the one that just destroyed the station. He cannot explain the brief power drain just before the explosion, either. Picard tells O'Brien that he will want an explanation and he's sure the Tanugan government will want one as well. Data informs Picard that the [[radiation]] and debris are consistent with an overload of the station's [[reactor core]] but neither La Forge nor Riker saw any indications of problems with the [[fusion reactor|reactor]] while they were on board the station.
   
  +
Picard turns his attention to Riker and asks him about the mission not going quite so routinely. Riker is slightly dismissive and doubts that it had anything to do with the explosion. [[Worf]] informs the captain that Chief Investigator [[Krag]] of the [[Tanugan]] security force is requesting permission to beam aboard; Picard grants permission and asks Worf to escort him to the bridge. While Worf is escorting Krag, Picard wants Riker to explain everything that happened on board the station as best as he can.
⚫
Upon Krag's entry to the bridge Picard introduces himself and Riker. As soon as he hears Riker's name mentioned, Krag dismisses Picard and approaches Riker informing him that he is to take him into custody on suspicion of [[murder]]. Riker responds angrily but Picard interrupts saying that he and the rest of the ''Enterprise'' crew are willing to co-operate. Krag, though, insists on [[Extradition|extraditing]] the "prisoner" and Picard asks Krag to accompany him to the [[ready room]], as the bridge is not the best place to discuss such a delicate topic. Riker walks to join them but Picard dismisses him, telling him that he has the bridge, and the bridge staff cannot help but look at Riker in surprise about the recent accusation against him.
  
   
  +
[[File:Krag comes to arrest Riker.jpg|thumb|left|''"Commander Riker, I am here to take you into custody."'']]
⚫
In the ready room, Picard asks Krag what evidence there is against Commander Riker. Krag says that two witnesses have come forward to describe Riker's threats against Apgar. Picard is surprised, saying that there was only an altercation but Krag claims that it was much more than that. He says that Riker will be given the opportunity to prove his innocence – in the Tanugan jurisprudence, the accused is "guilty until proven innocent," while the [[Federation]]'s own works on the opposite basis. Krag informs Picard that he has consulted Federation regulations and because the alleged incident happened within Tanugan space, they have jurisdiction, but Picard says that the regulations also state that the captain will decide if extradition of an officer is warranted and that if there is sufficient evidence is brought forward, he will release Riker in to Krag's custody.
  
  ⚫
Upon Krag's entry to the bridge Picard introduces himself and Riker. As soon as he hears Riker's name mentioned, Krag dismisses Picard and approaches Riker informing him that he is to take him into custody on suspicion of [[murder]]. Riker responds angrily, but Picard interrupts saying that he and the rest of the ''Enterprise'' crew are willing to co-operate. Krag, though, insists on [[Extradition|extraditing]] the "prisoner" and Picard asks Krag to accompany him to the [[ready room]], as the bridge is not the best place to discuss such a delicate topic. Riker walks to join them but Picard dismisses him, telling him that he has the bridge, and the bridge staff cannot help but look at Riker in surprise about the recent accusation against him.
⚫
[[File:Krag&Picard.jpg|thumb|Krag insists on Riker's extradition]]
  
   
  ⚫
In the ready room, Picard asks Krag what evidence there is against Commander Riker. Krag says that two witnesses have come forward to describe Riker's threats against Apgar. Picard is surprised, saying that there was only an altercation but Krag claims that it was much more than that. He says that Riker will be given the opportunity to prove his innocence – in the Tanugan jurisprudence, the accused is "guilty until proven innocent," while the [[Federation]]'s own works on the opposite basis. Krag informs Picard that he has consulted Federation regulations and because the alleged incident happened within Tanugan space, they have jurisdiction, but Picard says that the regulations also state that the captain will decide if extradition of an officer is warranted and that if there is sufficient evidence is brought forward, he will release Riker into Krag's custody.
⚫
Krag asks about Picard's closeness to Riker but the captain refuses to answer, saying that it is irrelevant in this instance. Krag feels that it ''is'' relevant, though, as he would not expect an impartial decision from Picard, but Picard feels compelled to protect the rights of those who serve with him. Krag appreciates his situation but says that he will do it on the planet as the ''Enterprise'' can leave at any moment; Picard gives his word that, as a Starfleet officer, he will not do so. Krag has little faith in Picard and demands that Riker be turned over for interrogation. Picard says that Krag can interrogate him on the ''Enterprise''. Krag says that interrogation would be impossible on the ship, as great resources would be needed, from witness accounts to computer data. Picard considers a compromise and says that perhaps it won't be impossible, calling Data into the ready room. Upon entering the ready room, Picard introduces Data to Krag and asks if it would be possible to recreate the events that took place on the station based on testimony from both the away team and witnesses. Although it would require extensive resources including design specifications of the equipment used, Data replies that it would be possible to do so. Krag considers what Picard and Data have just said – because the captain has no intention of releasing Riker as of yet, Krag agrees and will make arrangements to provide all of the available information. He will also return with his witnesses and Data escorts Krag to Transporter Room Three.
 
   
  ⚫
[[File:Krag&Picard.jpg|thumb|''"He is guilty until he is proven innocent."'']]
  ⚫
Krag asks about Picard's closeness to Riker but the captain refuses to answer, saying that it is irrelevant in this instance. Krag feels that it ''is'' relevant, though, as he would not expect an impartial decision from Picard, but Picard feels compelled to protect the rights of those who serve with him. Krag appreciates his situation but says that he will do it on the planet as the ''Enterprise'' can leave the Tanugan system at any moment; Picard gives his word that, as a Starfleet officer, he will not do so. Krag has little faith in Picard and demands that Riker be turned over for interrogation. Picard says that Krag can interrogate him on the ''Enterprise''. Krag says that interrogation would be impossible on the ship, as great resources would be needed, from witness accounts to the ground computer data.
  +
  +
Picard considers a compromise and says that perhaps it won't be impossible, calling Data into the ready room. Upon entering the ready room, Picard introduces Data to Krag and asks if it would be possible to recreate the events that took place on the station based on testimony from both the away team and witnesses. Although it would require extensive resources including design specifications of the equipment used, Data replies that it would be possible to do so. Krag considers what Picard and Data have just said – because the captain has no intention of releasing Riker as of yet, Krag agrees and will make arrangements to provide all of the available information. He will also return with his witnesses and Data escorts Krag to Transporter Room Three.
  +
  +
[[File:Picard asks for holodeck reenactment.jpg|thumb|left|''"We are going to recreate the research station here on the holodeck."'']]
 
Picard leaves the ready room, telling La Forge and [[Wesley Crusher]] that they are going to recreate the station in the [[holodeck]]: both La Forge and Riker will give the computer [[deposition]]s with detailed descriptions of what they witnessed on the station, and [[Counselor]] [[Deanna Troi|Troi]] will assist Picard during the inquiry. Picard then considers what he'll say next and firmly (although quietly) tells Riker (and the other staff) that his decision on whether or not to extradite him will be based on the evidence in the holodeck re-creations. Riker asks for a private word with Picard, but the captain refuses as it would be inappropriate under the circumstances and returns to the ready room.
  
Picard leaves the ready room, telling La Forge and [[Wesley Crusher]] that they are going to recreate the station in the [[holodeck]]: both La Forge and Riker will give the computer [[deposition]]s with detailed descriptions of what they witnessed on the station, and [[Counselor]] [[Deanna Troi|Troi]] will assist Picard during the inquiry. Picard then considers what he'll say next and firmly (although quietly) tells Riker (and the other staff) that his decision on whether or not to extradite him will be based on the evidence in the holodeck re-creations. Riker asks for a private word with Picard, but the captain refuses as it would be inappropriate under the circumstances and returns to the ready room.
  +
{{clear}}
   
 
=== Act Two ===
  
=== Act Two ===
−
:"''Second officer's log, Stardate 43611.6. Programming of the holodeck has taken eighteen hours and eleven minutes and is now complete. All participants have entered their depositions. Technical schematics and complete records from the lab's ground computers, as well as Doctor Apgar's personal logs, have been included. The recreation has a nominal eight-point-seven percent margin of error.''"
 +
:"''Second officer's log, Stardate 43611.6. Programming of the holodeck has taken eighteen hours and eleven minutes and is now complete. All participants have entered their depositions. Technical schematics and complete records from the lab's ground computers, as well as Doctor Apgar's personal logs, have been included. The recreations will have a nominal eight-point-seven percent margin of error.''"
  +
  +
[[File:Riker's trial begins.jpg|thumb|''"I'm not a murderer."'']]
  +
Picard, Riker, Krag and Troi enter the holodeck and take their seats in a [[holographic]] facsimile of the laboratory on board the space station. Before the inquiry begins, Riker makes a statement that he was not a murderer but a representative of Starfleet sent to make a progress report on Dr. Apgar's development of the [[Krieger wave converter]], and that he acted accordingly throughout the mission.
  +
  +
Riker then runs a simulation recalling events as he remembers them. [[Hologram]]s of Dr. Apgar and his assistant, [[Tayna]], appear and the holograms of Riker and La Forge beam aboard the station. Throughout Riker's simulation, the hologram of Riker maintains a neutral, business-like demeanor while Apgar is somewhat impatient and far from pleased with Starfleet's arrival, although he makes an effort to be polite. A simulation of Apgar's wife, [[Manua]], enters, apologizing for the doctor's less than accommodating behavior. Throughout the simulation she can't seem to take her eyes off of Riker and treats Apgar like an afterthought.
  +
  +
[[File:Tanuga Station simulation begins.jpg|thumb|left|Riker's simulation begins]]
  +
La Forge accompanies Tayna to one of the stations, talking about the [[Lambda field generator]] while Manua escorts Riker (while Apgar follows) for a welcoming drink. The three share glasses of [[champagne]], but Apgar has little interest in pleasantries and asks Riker why Starfleet came so soon, especially as Apgar wasn't due to update them on his progress for another three months. Riker felt that it was a good time as the ''Enterprise'' was in the sector on another mission studying a [[protostar]] and that Apgar had requested additional [[dicosilium]] for his research.
  +
  +
The [[Federation]] [[flagship]] would be returning the following day and Apgar was less than pleased with hearing this but Riker told him that he and La Forge had already arranged accommodations on the planet, below but Manua insisted that they stay to keep her company and further apologizes for her husband's shortcomings in spite of his scientific prowess. Krag interrupts asking if it was Riker's testimony that it was Manua's idea for Riker and La Forge to stay on the station; Riker confirms this and says that it is also the truth.
  +
  ⚫
The simulation resumes now in the station's guest [[quarters]] with Riker and Manua present. Manua shows Riker around the quarters but does not leave and begins to proposition Riker, partially undressing. Riker insists that she leave but as he redresses her, Apgar walks in, catching the two in an extremely uncomfortable position. The scientist reacts furiously, hitting his wife and taking a swing at Riker but Riker moves out of the way of Apgar's punch and he falls.
   
  ⚫
[[File:RikerMisunderstanding.jpg|thumb|''"Doctor, believe me. This has been a terrible mistake."'']]
−
Picard, Riker, Krag and Troi enter the holodeck and take their seats in a [[holographic]] facsimile of the laboratory on board the space station. Before the inquiry begins, Riker makes a statement that he was not a murderer but a representative of Starfleet sent to make a progress report on Dr. Apgar's development of the [[Krieger wave converter]], and that he acted accordingly throughout the mission. Riker then runs a simulation recalling events as he remembers them. [[Hologram]]s of Dr. Apgar and his assistant, [[Tayna]], appear and the holograms of Riker and La Forge beam aboard the station. Throughout Riker's simulation, the hologram of Riker maintains a neutral, business-like demeanor while Apgar is somewhat impatient and far from pleased with Starfleet's arrival, although he makes an effort to be polite. A simulation of Apgar's wife, [[Manua]], enters, apologizing for the doctor's less than accommodating behavior. Throughout the simulation she can't seem to take her eyes off of Riker and treats Apgar like an afterthought. La Forge accompanies Tayna to one of the stations, talking about the [[Lambda field generator]] while Manua escorts Riker (while Apgar follows) for a welcoming drink. The three share glasses of [[champagne]], but Apgar has little interest in pleasantries and asks Riker why Starfleet came so soon, especially as Apgar wasn't due to update them on his progress for another three months. Riker felt that it was a good time as the ''Enterprise'' was in the sector on another mission studying a [[protostar]] and that Apgar had requested additional [[dicosilium]] for his research. The [[Federation]] [[flagship]] would be returning the following day and Apgar was less than pleased with hearing this but Riker told him that he and La Forge had already arranged accommodations on the planet, below but Manua insisted that they stay to keep her company and further apologizes for her husband's shortcomings in spite of his scientific prowess.
 
  +
Riker insists that what just happened was a terrible misunderstanding but Apgar assures him that he will make a formal complaint to Starfleet. The [[first officer]] interrupts the simulation and says that he didn't see Dr. Apgar until the following morning, when Apgar asked to speak to him alone. La Forge later returned to the ''Enterprise''.
   
  ⚫
The simulation resumes, returning to the laboratory, where Apgar asks if his complaint will result in Riker giving a less-than-favorable report on his work. Riker insists that the complaint will not affect the report in any way and asks that he call Manua in so they can all resolve the misunderstanding, but both she and Tayna have since returned to the planet. Apgar is frustrated with not knowing where he stands with Starfleet and asks Riker if he feels that there is no justification for the additional dicosilium that he ordered. He insists that he can explain why he needs it but Riker doesn't need any explanations – he will not grant Apgar's request. Apgar dismisses him and Riker calls the ''Enterprise'', saying that he's ready to leave. Riker freezes the simulation and says that this was when he left the station.
⚫
[[File:RikerMisunderstanding.jpg|thumb|left|Riker and Manua are caught in an unfortunate position]]
  
⚫
Krag interrupts asking if it was Riker's testimony that it was Manua's idea for Riker and La Forge to stay on the station; Riker confirms this and says that it is also the truth. The simulation resumes now in the station's guest [[quarters]] with Riker and Manua present. Manua shows Riker around the quarters but does not leave and begins to proposition Riker, partially undressing. Riker insists that she leave but as he redresses her, Apgar walks in, catching the two in an extremely uncomfortable position. The scientist reacts furiously, hitting his wife and taking a swing at Riker but Riker moves out of the way of Apgar's punch and he falls. Riker insists that what just happened was a terrible misunderstanding but Apgar assures him that he will make a formal complaint to Starfleet. The [[first officer]] interrupts the simulation and says that he didn't see Dr. Apgar until the following morning, when Apgar asked to speak to him alone. La Forge later returned to the ''Enterprise''.
 
   
  +
[[File:Krag1-RikerMurderer.jpg|thumb|left|''"I never fired a phaser on the science station!"'']]
⚫
The simulation resumes, returning to the laboratory, where Apgar asks if his complaint will result in Riker giving a less-than-favorable report on his work. Riker insists that the complaint will not affect the report in any way and asks that he call Manua in so they can all resolve the misunderstanding, but both she and Tayna have since returned to the planet. Apgar is frustrated with not knowing where he stands with Starfleet and asks Riker if he feels that there is no justification for the additional dicosilium that he ordered. He insists that he can explain why he needs it but Riker doesn't need any explanations – [[File:Krag1-RikerMurderer.jpg|thumb|Krag's simulation portrays Riker as a murderer]]he will not grant Apgar's request. Apgar dismisses him and Riker calls the ''Enterprise'', saying that he's ready to leave. Riker freezes the simulation and says that this was when he left the station. Krag asks if Riker has anything to add, such as firing a [[phaser]]. Riker denies having fired a phaser on the station at all and Krag is somewhat perplexed by Riker's denial because the lab ground computers indicated that a focused energy pulse was fired just as the transporters were engaged. Furthermore, analyses of the trajectory and angle of the pulse were traced back to Riker's exact position. Krag then runs a hypothetical simulation of what he believes Riker did. The simulation returns to the point just before Riker departs. Riker calls the ''Enterprise'' saying that he's ready to leave now and as the materialization effect of the transporter begins, he quickly draws his phaser and fires at the reactor – three seconds later, the station explodes.
  
  +
Krag asks if Riker has anything to add, such as firing a [[phaser]]. Riker denies having fired a phaser on the station at all and Krag is somewhat perplexed by Riker's denial because the lab ground computers indicated that a focused energy pulse was fired just as the ''Enterprise''{{'}}s transporters were engaged. Furthermore, analyses of the trajectory and angle of the pulse were traced back to Riker's exact position. Krag then runs a hypothetical simulation of what he believes Riker did. The simulation returns to the point just before Riker departs. Riker calls the ''Enterprise'' saying that he's ready to leave now and as the materialization effect of the transporter begins, he quickly draws his phaser and fires at the reactor – three seconds later, the station explodes.
   
 
=== Act Three ===
  
=== Act Three ===
  +
[[File:Deck39RadiationBurn.jpg|thumb|''"What kind of radiation could do this?''"]]
−
Data, La Forge and Wesley are all observing the monitors on the first [[science station]] on the bridge where there is a graph displaying the results of a composite radiation traceback analysis. There is an extremely large spike on the far right of the graph that indicates the explosion of the station but there is an anomalous smaller spike just before the larger one. Unfortunately, the energy signature is consistent with that of a phaser and there was nothing else on board the station that La Forge saw that could produce a similar energy signature. Wesley openly says that it couldn't have been Riker who fired the phaser and thinks that there is something else that caused the discharge but, although La Forge agrees, he cannot explain why the discharge came from Riker's exact position. Worf then reports that there is a [[radiation]] burst on Deck 39, just outside of [[cargo bay]] 12. The computer cannot identify either the source or the type of radiation but it soon subsides.
 +
Data, La Forge and Wesley are all observing the monitors on the first [[science station]] on the bridge where there is a graph displaying the results of a composite radiation traceback analysis. There is an extremely large spike on the far right of the graph that indicates the explosion of the station but there is an anomalous smaller spike just before the larger one. Unfortunately, the energy signature is consistent with that of a phaser and there was nothing else on board the station that La Forge saw that could produce a similar energy signature.
   
  +
Wesley openly says that it couldn't have been Riker who fired the phaser and thinks that there is something else that caused the discharge but, although La Forge agrees, he cannot explain why the discharge came from Riker's exact position. Worf then reports that there is a [[radiation]] burst on Deck 39, just outside of [[cargo bay]] 12. The computer cannot identify either the source or the type of radiation but it soon subsides.
−
[[File:Deck39RadiationBurn.jpg|thumb|left|Crusher and La Forge investigate a mysterious type of radiation]]
  
⚫
La Forge and Wesley are now studying the recent burst of radiation, which has melted a section of the wall, but both are baffled as they don't know of any type of radiation that could have done this. Not even the [[deflector]] puts out this much radiation spillage, but what they do know about this radiation is that it is a serious threat to the ship as it can put a hole in [[duranium]].
 
   
  ⚫
La Forge and Wesley are now studying the recent burst of radiation with a [[Starfleet tricorder|tricorder]] which has melted a section of the wall, but both are baffled as they don't know of any type of radiation that could have done this. Not even the ship's [[deflector]] puts out this much radiation spillage, but what they do know about this radiation is that it is a serious threat to the ship as it can put a hole in [[duranium]].
⚫
Returning to the holodeck, Krag escorts (the real) Manua into the room. She is much more modestly dressed and her demeanor is much less sensual than the hologram of her in Riker's simulation. Before the next simulation is shown, she makes no statement – she just "knows" that Commander Riker killed her husband. Krag runs Manua's recollection of events on board the space station. Holograms of Manua and Apgar appear in their quarters and Apgar is extremely anxious about Starfleet arriving and worries that they will stop sponsoring his research because he feels that he hasn't progressed as far as expected. Manua tries to assure him that just a bit of charm would be needed to persuade Starfleet to give him more time.
 
   
  +
[[File:Manua's deposition.jpg|thumb|left|''"I just know he did it. He killed my husband."'']]
⚫
The simulation returns to the lab where Riker introduces himself and La Forge and Manua enter, but throughout this simulation Riker has a much more relaxed, charming, less formal attitude – in some respects much like the ''real'' Riker. In addition, Riker pays more attention to Manua than Apgar's progress and looks at her in a provocative way, making her feel uncomfortable. Tayna shows La Forge the station, describing the field generator while Manua takes Apgar (whom she takes company of this time) and Riker away for a drink. During the drink, Riker again shows little interest in what Apgar has to say, continuously looking at Manua, and asks if he and La Forge can remain on the station; Apgar reluctantly agrees. Manua shows Riker the modestly-sized quarters but Riker says that it has her charm, making her feel more uncomfortable with each move he makes. He then closes the door on her and makes more, stronger advances on her. Since she is smaller and much weaker than Riker, Manua is almost powerless to stop him although she resists as much as she can, pleading for him to stop.
  
  ⚫
Returning to the holodeck, Krag escorts (the real) Manua Apgar into the room. She is much more modestly dressed and her demeanor is much less sensual than the hologram of her in Riker's simulation. Before the next simulation is shown, she makes no statement – she just "knows" that Commander Riker killed her husband. Krag runs Manua's recollection of events on board the space station. Holograms of Manua and Apgar appear in their quarters and Apgar is extremely anxious about Starfleet arriving and worries that they will stop sponsoring his research because he feels that he hasn't progressed as far as expected. Manua tries to assure him that just a bit of charm would be needed to persuade Starfleet to give him more time.
   
  +
The simulation returns to the lab where Riker introduces himself and La Forge and Manua enter, but throughout this simulation Riker has a much more relaxed, charming, less formal attitude – in some respects much like the ''real'' Riker. In addition, Riker pays more attention to Manua than Apgar's progress and looks at her in a provocative way, making her feel uncomfortable. Tayna shows La Forge the station, describing the field generator while Manua takes Apgar (whom she takes company of this time) and Riker away for a drink.
⚫
(The real) Riker interrupts with an angry outburst, leaving his chair, unable to take any more and Picard pauses the simulation. Riker is furious at Manua's accusations and categorically denies having propositioned her or trying to rape her, asking why Manua was doing this, but she said that this was exactly what happened. Deanna calls for Riker to return to his seat to prevent him from doing or saying something that he may regret; he returns to his seat and Krag resumes the simulation. Apgar walks in seeing Manua in Riker's arms and is immediately enraged, taking a swing a Riker but Riker blocks Apgar's punch and lands two jabs in the scientist's stomach, causing Apgar to fall back onto the floor. Manua runs over to try to protect her husband and Apgar promises that this will be Riker's last mission, but Riker threatens him saying that he'll be making a terrible mistake if he lodges his complaint. Krag freezes the simulation and Manua says to Riker that his career in Starfleet was secure despite Apgar's promise – as a scientist, he would have been distracted by some technical trivia and would have forgotten all about his complaint to Starfleet. The memory of her dead husband has become too much for Manua and she leaves the holodeck crying.
 
   
  ⚫
During the drink, Riker again shows little interest in what Apgar has to say, continuously looking at Manua, and asks if he and La Forge can remain on the station; Apgar reluctantly agrees. Manua shows Riker the modestly-sized quarters but Riker says that it has her charm, making her feel more uncomfortable with each move he makes. He then closes the door on her and makes more, stronger advances on her. Since she is smaller and much weaker than Riker, Manua is almost powerless to stop him although she resists as much as she can, pleading for him to stop.
  +
  +
[[File:RikerwithRikerManuaSims.jpg|thumb|''"I didn't proposition her, and I '''certainly''' didn't try to rape her!"'']]
  +
(The real) Riker interrupts with an angry outburst, leaving his chair, unable to take any more and Picard pauses the simulation. Riker is furious at Manua's accusations and categorically denies having propositioned her or trying to rape her, asking why Manua was doing this, but she said that this was exactly what happened. Deanna calls for Riker to return to his seat to prevent him from doing or saying something that he may regret; he returns to his seat and Krag resumes the simulation.
  +
  ⚫
Apgar walks in seeing Manua in Riker's arms and is immediately enraged, taking a swing a Riker but Riker blocks Apgar's punch and lands two jabs in the scientist's stomach, causing Apgar to fall back onto the floor. Manua runs over to try to protect her husband and Apgar promises that this will be Riker's last mission, but Riker threatens him saying that he'll be making a terrible mistake if he lodges his complaint. Krag freezes the simulation and Manua says to Riker that his career in Starfleet was secure despite Apgar's promise – as a scientist, he would have been distracted by some technical trivia and would have forgotten all about his complaint to Starfleet. The memory of her dead husband has become too much for Manua and she leaves the holodeck crying.
  +
  +
[[File:Riker worried at trial.jpg|thumb|left|''"Her version puts a noose around my neck."'']]
 
Picard calls for a recess and reassuringly taps Riker's shoulder as he and Krag exit, knowing that the evidence against Riker is mounting. Riker turns to Deanna and asks why Manua would have lied about what happened but the counselor does not respond. He notices and asks if she thought that he could have done what Manua accused him of. Deanna reassures him that she knows that he couldn't even contemplate such an act, even though she sensed no kind of deception from Manua – they are both telling the truth as they remember it. Unfortunately, Manua's recollection of events would result in Riker's extradition and likely conviction.
  
Picard calls for a recess and reassuringly taps Riker's shoulder as he and Krag exit, knowing that the evidence against Riker is mounting. Riker turns to Deanna and asks why Manua would have lied about what happened but the counselor does not respond. He notices and asks if she thought that he could have done what Manua accused him of. Deanna reassures him that she knows that he couldn't even contemplate such an act, even though she sensed no kind of deception from Manua – they are both telling the truth as they remember it. Unfortunately, Manua's recollection of events would result in Riker's extradition and likely conviction.
   
−
Dr. [[Beverly Crusher|Crusher]] is treating a crewwoman in [[sickbay]] who has recently injured her arm. Beverly feels that the healing of her injury has advanced enough for her to start restoring the strength of her muscles but Worf (on the com) calls for Crusher and those present to evacuate immediately as a radiation burst has been detected in sickbay; part of the wall begins to burn away.
 +
Dr. [[Beverly Crusher|Crusher]] and [[Martinez]] are treating a crewwoman in [[sickbay]] who has recently injured her arm. Crusher feels that the healing of her injury has advanced enough for her to start restoring the strength of her muscles but Worf (on the com) calls for Crusher and those present to evacuate immediately as a radiation burst has been detected in sickbay; part of the wall begins to burn away.
   
 
=== Act Four ===
  
=== Act Four ===
−
La Forge and Wesley are studying the newly-melted spot in the wall. Data confirms that it is the same radiation that had previously penetrated the section of wall on Deck 39 – a highly-focused, powerful emission of radiation but it is of unknown origin. La Forge warns Captain Picard that if this radiation were to form in either the [[warp core]] or the [[antimatter storage pod]]s, they'd be in serious trouble. Picard asks if either of the three have any theories; Data has noticed something that was too strange to be a coincidence – the radiation events aboard the ''Enterprise'' occurred five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds apart while the space station exploded at ''almost'' four times that interval the previous day – there is a 0.0014-second variance that none of them have been able to explain. Although there is no evidence at present to connect the events, it appears that they may be linked, but if they are correct, they would be able to predict the next radiation event occurring – just over five hours from now. Picard orders them to take the necessary precautions to protect the ship's most vital areas and if they cannot find the source of the radiation by the next interval, the ''Enterprise'' is to leave orbit of Tanuga IV.
 +
La Forge and Wesley are studying the newly-melted spot in the wall. Data confirms that it is the same radiation that had previously penetrated the section of wall on Deck 39 – a highly-focused, powerful emission of radiation but it is of unknown origin. La Forge warns Captain Picard that if this radiation were to form in either the [[warp core]] or the [[antimatter storage pod]]s, they'd be in serious trouble.
   
  +
[[File:Investigating sickbay.jpg|thumb|''"Very powerful, but of unknown origin."'']]
−
In the holodeck, the hearing resumes with (the real) Tayna describing what Dr. Apgar told her about the alleged incident between himself, Commander Riker and Manua. She and Krag have made a reconstruction of what happened on the station in the guest quarters based on her deposition but Picard interrupts protesting that Tayna's accounts are nothing more than [[hearsay evidence]] but because Apgar is dead, Tayna's evidence is admissible under Tanugan law and Krag insists that Picard consider it; Picard reluctantly agrees to listen to the "evidence" and Tayna's simulation runs, beginning similarly to where Manua's simulation ended. Apgar walks in catching Riker and Manua sharing a passionate kiss; Riker takes a swing at Apgar but the scientist ducks and strikes Riker, knocking him to the floor, assuring him that he will lodge a complaint to Starfleet but Riker threatens him calling him a "dead man." Tayna's next simulation (set in the lab) with Tayna and Apgar; he wants her to take his wife and return to the planet, but Tayna protests and says that he should come down too because Riker threatened him. Apgar, though, feels compelled to protect their work. She agrees and decides to contact the authorities, but Apgar tells her not to – he will take care of Riker himself. The simulation stops and Tayna recalls hearing about the station exploding, "knowing" that Riker killed Dr. Apgar, then leaves. Krag has now established motive, method and opportunity for to Riker to have murdered Apgar – in any court within the Federation, these are sufficient criteria to warrant the extradition of a suspect and Krag awaits Picard's decision.
  
  +
Picard asks if either of the three have any theories; Data has noticed something that was too strange to be a coincidence – the radiation events aboard the ''Enterprise'' occurred five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds apart while the space station exploded at ''almost'' four times that interval the previous day – there is a 0.0014 second variance that none of them have been able to explain. Although there is no evidence at present to connect the events, it appears that they may be linked, but if they are correct, they would be able to predict the next radiation event occurring – just over five hours from now. Picard orders them to take the necessary precautions to protect the ship's most vital areas and if they cannot find the source of the radiation by the next interval, the ''Enterprise'' is to leave orbit of Tanuga IV.
  +
  +
In the holodeck, the hearing resumes with (the real) Tayna describing what Dr. Apgar told her about the alleged incident between himself, Commander Riker and Manua. She and Krag have made a reconstruction of what happened on the station in the guest quarters based on her deposition but Picard interrupts protesting that Tayna's accounts are nothing more than [[hearsay evidence]] but because Apgar is dead, Tayna's evidence is admissible under Tanugan law and Krag insists that Picard consider it; Picard reluctantly agrees to listen to the "evidence" and Tayna's simulation runs, beginning similarly to where Manua's simulation ended.
  +
  +
[[File:Apgar punchout.jpg|thumb|left|''"I'm not the fool you take me for."'']]
  +
Apgar walks in catching Riker and Manua sharing a passionate kiss; Riker takes a swing at Apgar but the scientist ducks and strikes Riker, knocking him to the floor, assuring him that he will lodge a complaint to Starfleet but Riker threatens him calling him a "dead man." Tayna's next simulation (set in the lab) with Tayna and Apgar; he wants her to take his wife and return to the planet, but Tayna protests and says that he should come down too because Riker threatened him. Apgar, though, feels compelled to protect their work.
  +
  +
She agrees and decides to contact the authorities, but Apgar tells her not to – he will take care of Riker himself. The simulation stops and Tayna recalls hearing about the station exploding, also "knowing" that Riker killed Dr. Apgar, then leaves. Krag has now established motive, method and opportunity for to Riker to have murdered Apgar – in any court within the Federation, these are sufficient criteria to warrant the extradition of a suspect and Krag awaits Picard's decision.
   
 
=== Act Five ===
  
=== Act Five ===
−
[[File:PicardmayloseWill.jpg|thumb|left|Captain Picard may be forced to extradite his friend and first officer to the Tanugans]]
 +
[[File:PicardmayloseWill.jpg|thumb|"''The evidence warrants a trial... I'll have to allow extradition.''"]]
−
Picard and Troi are in the ready room and it seems all but certain that Picard will have little alternative other than to hand Riker over to the Tanugans, as the evidence gathered against Riker warrants a trial. Although both he and Troi know that Riker is innocent, they cannot yield to their feelings and unfortunately, there is little evidence to prove their friend's innocence. They are interrupted when Data calls them over the com, telling them that the source of the radiation has been discovered; they return to the bridge. Data reports that he, La Forge and Wesley have been looking a phenomenon that occurs every five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds and one such phenomenon has been discovered on the planet's surface – the field generator that Apgar used in his research. When it is fully charged it emits an energy pulse then requires the same amount of time to recharge itself – it was left on after the station had exploded. Picard asks why the generator was affecting the ''Enterprise'' as it had been – it should not have done so as it was a harmless generator, but they knew that it was connected to the radiation bursts and they have now determined not only the cause of the radiation bursts and the cause of the explosion that destroyed the space station, but also who killed Dr. Apgar.
 +
Picard and Troi are in the ready room and it seems all but certain that Picard will have little alternative other than to hand Riker over to the Tanugans, as the evidence gathered against Riker warrants a trial. Although both he and Troi know that Riker is innocent, they cannot yield to their feelings and unfortunately, there is little evidence to prove their friend's innocence. They are interrupted when Data calls them over the com, telling them that the source of the radiation has been discovered; they return to the bridge.
  +
  +
Data reports that he, La Forge and Wesley have been looking a phenomenon that occurs every five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds and one such phenomenon has been discovered on the planet's surface – the field generator that Apgar used in his research. When it is fully charged it emits an energy pulse then requires the same amount of time to recharge itself – it was left on after the station had exploded. Picard asks why the generator was affecting the ''Enterprise'' as it had been – it should not have done so as it was a harmless generator, but they knew that it was connected to the radiation bursts and they have now determined not only the cause of the radiation bursts and the cause of the explosion that destroyed the space station, but also who killed Dr. Apgar.
  +
  ⚫
Picard, Riker, La Forge, Troi, Krag, Manua, and Tayna are all present in the holodeck and Picard says that despite all of the evidence and events shown on the station, they haven't seen all of what ''really'' happened. Krag does not understand and Picard enlists La Forge's assistance to prepare their arguments with a few excerpts from their previous recreations:
   
  +
[[File:KriegerWaveConverter.jpg|thumb|left|"''The energy from the field generator down on the planet simply reflects off of elements in the converter.''"]]
⚫
Picard, Riker, La Forge, Troi, Krag, Manua and Tayna are all present in the holodeck and Picard says that despite all of the evidence and events shown on the station, they haven't seen what really happened. Krag does not understand and Picard enlists La Forge's assistance to prepare their arguments with a few excerpts from their previous recreations:
  
  +
First, an excerpt from Manua's testimony, in which Apgar says that he has suffered several setbacks, and was upset at Starfleet's early arrival to check on his progress. Manua acknowledges her testimony, adding that her husband was under extreme pressure to make his breakthrough. Picard then posits that Apgar was lying to Starfleet, and had, in fact, already succeeded in creating Krieger waves. Geordi fills in Krag about the mysterious radiation bursts that have been hitting the ''Enterprise'', which they've identified as Krieger waves. Baffled, Tayna says that is impossible – even if Apgar had succeeded in creating them, there is nothing to generate them after the station was destroyed.
   
−
First, an excerpt from Manua's testimony, in which Apgar says that he has suffered several setbacks, and was upset at Starfleet's early arrival to check on his progress. Manua acknowledges her testimony, adding that her husband was under extreme pressure to make his breakthrough. Picard then posits that Apgar was lying to Starfleet, and had, in fact, already succeeded in creating Krieger waves. Geordi fills in Krag about the mysterious radiation bursts that have been hitting the ''Enterprise'', which they've identified as Krieger waves. Baffled, Tayna says that is impossible - even if Apgar had succeeded in creating them, there is nothing to generate them after the station was destroyed. Geordi says that the waves are being created by the holodeck's facsimile of Apgar's lab, which includes the Krieger wave converter that he falsely claimed didn't work. The field generator on the planet has been sending harmless energy pulses to the ''Enterprise'', which were converted to Krieger waves by the facsimile of the converter. Riker is confused, since the holodeck cannot create anything dangerous unless the safety protocols are disabled. La Forge acknowledges this and says that technically, it didn't do so, since the converter is essentially little more than a complex series of mirrors and reflective coils. The energy pulses from the field generator were reflected off of elements in the converter that changed them into focused Krieger waves, which have been striking different areas of the ship as its angle to the generator changes.
+
Geordi says that the waves are being created by the holodeck's facsimile of Apgar's lab, which includes the Krieger wave converter that he falsely claimed didn't work. The field generator on the planet has been sending harmless energy pulses to the ''Enterprise'', which were converted to Krieger waves by the facsimile of the converter. Riker is confused, since the holodeck cannot create anything dangerous unless the safety protocols are disabled. La Forge acknowledges this and says that technically, it didn't do so, since the converter is essentially little more than a complex series of mirrors and reflective coils. The energy pulses from the field generator were reflected off of elements in the converter that changed them into focused Krieger waves, which have been striking different areas of the ship as its angle to the generator changes.
   
  +
[[File:Apgar reacts to Riker.jpg|thumb|"''I'll take care of that!''"]]
−
Krag asks why Apgar would lie about his progress. Picard runs extracts of two simulations, one in which Apgar promises Manua that his work will yield rich rewards, and another in which Manua references these same rewards as she, Apgar, and Riker are toasting her husband's anticipated breakthrough. Troi explains that Apgar would not have made substantial profits from selling a new power source to Starfleet, but he could have made a much greater profit selling a new weapon to the [[Romulan]]s, the [[Ferengi]], and other species. Dr. Apgar's orders for extra [[dicosilium]] were a good indicator that he was trying to create larger reflective coils, to build a more lethal version of his existing converter.
 +
Krag asks why Apgar would lie about his progress. Picard runs extracts of two simulations, one in which Apgar promises Manua that his work will yield rich rewards, and another in which Manua references these same rewards as she, Apgar, and Riker are [[toast]]ing her husband's anticipated breakthrough. Troi explains that Apgar would not have made substantial profits from selling a new power source to Starfleet, but he could have made a much greater profit selling a new weapon to the [[Romulan]]s, the [[Ferengi]], and other species. Dr. Apgar's orders for extra [[dicosilium]] were a good indicator that he was trying to create larger reflective coils, to build a more lethal version of his existing converter.
   
 
When the ''Enterprise'' arrived early, Picard theorizes, Apgar became worried that Starfleet had become suspicious of him. In all three simulations, Apgar claims that he needs more time for his research. Picard further theorizes that Apgar became convinced Riker was onto him, and decided to kill him to protect himself (finding Riker with his wife did not improve matters, Picard adds).
  
When the ''Enterprise'' arrived early, Picard theorizes, Apgar became worried that Starfleet had become suspicious of him. In all three simulations, Apgar claims that he needs more time for his research. Picard further theorizes that Apgar became convinced Riker was onto him, and decided to kill him to protect himself (finding Riker with his wife did not improve matters, Picard adds).
Line 105: Line 151:
 
Manua finds Picard's submission ridiculous, but Picard replays Tayna's simulation from the lab, when Apgar assures Tayna that he would take care of Riker instead of taking the matter to the authorities. When Apgar sits at a console, Picard freezes the simulation and asks Tayna what Apgar is doing. She says he is activating the generator on the planet but she does not know why. Picard suggests that Apgar was thinking ahead to his next confrontation with Riker.
  
Manua finds Picard's submission ridiculous, but Picard replays Tayna's simulation from the lab, when Apgar assures Tayna that he would take care of Riker instead of taking the matter to the authorities. When Apgar sits at a console, Picard freezes the simulation and asks Tayna what Apgar is doing. She says he is activating the generator on the planet but she does not know why. Picard suggests that Apgar was thinking ahead to his next confrontation with Riker.
   
  +
[[File:RikerDeflection.jpg|thumb|left|"''Doctor Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker.''"]]
 
Picard replays Riker's simulation at the point where Riker and Apgar discuss what Riker would put in his report. After Riker says that he needs no explanation for Apgar's extra orders for dicosilium, Picard freezes the simulation and surmises that Apgar felt that Riker was confirming his worst fears and this was when he decided to kill Riker.
 
Picard replays Riker's simulation at the point where Riker and Apgar discuss what Riker would put in his report. After Riker says that he needs no explanation for Apgar's extra orders for dicosilium, Picard freezes the simulation and surmises that Apgar felt that Riker was confirming his worst fears and this was when he decided to kill Riker.
   
−
Krag reminds Picard that the energy pulse that blew up the reactor (causing the station's destruction) came from Commander Riker's position, not Dr. Apgar's. La Forge picks up the explanation, hypothesizing that at the moment Riker beamed out, Apgar energized the converter to fire an energy pulse at Riker, hoping to make his death look like a transporter accident, but Apgar's plan went awry – the pulse reflected off the transporter beam into the reactor, causing the explosion.
+
Krag reminds Picard that the energy pulse that blew up the reactor (causing the station's destruction) came from Commander Riker's position, not Dr. Apgar's. La Forge picks up the explanation, hypothesizing that at the moment Riker beamed out, Apgar energized the converter to fire an energy pulse at Riker, hoping to make his death look like a transporter accident, but Apgar's plan went awry – the pulse instead reflected off the transporter beam into the reactor, causing the explosion.
   
 
Krag finds the hypothesis interesting, but dismisses it as impossible to prove. La Forge disagrees, as they have already established that the generator has been discharging and recharging at regular intervals except for the 0.0014-second variance between the first discharge and the explosion of the station. The only logical explanation for this variance is the split-second it took for the energy pulse to bounce off the transporter beam back to the reactor.
 
Krag finds the hypothesis interesting, but dismisses it as impossible to prove. La Forge disagrees, as they have already established that the generator has been discharging and recharging at regular intervals except for the 0.0014-second variance between the first discharge and the explosion of the station. The only logical explanation for this variance is the split-second it took for the energy pulse to bounce off the transporter beam back to the reactor.
   
  +
[[File:Krag apologizes.jpg|thumb|"''Commander... my apologies.''"]]
−
Picard and La Forge then deliver their final effect, running a new simulation that has been deliberately synchronized with the next discharge from the generator. [[File:RikerDeflection.jpg|thumb|Geordi's simulation shows what ''really'' happened on the station just before it exploded]]
  
  ⚫
Picard and La Forge then deliver their final effect, running a new simulation that has been deliberately synchronized with the next discharge from the generator. The simulation resumes with Apgar returning to the console that he was working on (as seen also in Tayna's simulation) while Riker calls the ''Enterprise'' saying that he is ready to leave. As the transporter beam engages, a Krieger wave beam fires from the generator at Riker's position, but it reflects off of the transporter beam into the reactor, resulting in an explosion, destroying everything in the simulation.
−  
⚫
The simulation resumes with Apgar returning to the console that he was working on (as seen also in Tayna's simulation) while Riker calls the ''Enterprise'' saying that he is ready to leave. As the transporter beam engages, a Krieger wave beam fires from the generator at Riker's position, but it reflects off of the transporter beam into the reactor, resulting in an explosion, destroying everything in the simulation.
 
   
 
Only the "real" people remain in an empty [[hologrid]], where Picard summarizes that Dr. Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker. After having seen this new evidence, Krag withdraws his request for Riker's extradition and offers Riker his apologies. After Krag, Manua and Tayna return to Tanuga IV, the ''Enterprise'' leaves the system on a course for [[Emila II]].
  
Only the "real" people remain in an empty [[hologrid]], where Picard summarizes that Dr. Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker. After having seen this new evidence, Krag withdraws his request for Riker's extradition and offers Riker his apologies. After Krag, Manua and Tayna return to Tanuga IV, the ''Enterprise'' leaves the system on a course for [[Emila II]].
   
−
== Memorable Quotes ==
 +
== Memorable quotes ==
  +
"''Riker to ''Enterprise'', I'm ready to leave. Now.''"
⚫
(Relieved)"''Transporter room to bridge - he's aboard...''"<br />
  
  +
: - '''Riker''', before beaming over from the station.
  +
  +
  ⚫
(Relieved)"''Transporter room to bridge &ndash; he's aboard...''"<br />
 
"''Why do you sound so surprised, Mr. O'Brien?''"<br />
  
"''Why do you sound so surprised, Mr. O'Brien?''"<br />
 
"''Well, for a moment we weren't sure you left the space station in time...''"<br />
  
"''Well, for a moment we weren't sure you left the space station in time...''"<br />
Line 128: Line 178:
 
"''I must apologize for my husband's lack of social graces. He may be one of the great scientific minds in the galaxy... but he does come up a bit short in other areas.''"
  
"''I must apologize for my husband's lack of social graces. He may be one of the great scientific minds in the galaxy... but he does come up a bit short in other areas.''"
 
: - '''Manua''', on Dr. Nel Apgar
  
: - '''Manua''', on Dr. Nel Apgar
  +
  +
  +
"''Damn it, I should have stayed with him!''"
  +
: - '''La Forge''', during Riker's murder investigation
  +
  +
  +
"''Investigator, in our system of jurisprudence a man is innocent until proved guilty.''"<br />
  +
"''In ours, he is guilty ''until'' he is proved innocent and you are under ''our'' jurisdiction.''"
  +
: - '''Picard''', arguing with '''Krag''' over Tanugan legal procedures
   
   
Line 157: Line 216:
 
"''Is it?''"
  
"''Is it?''"
 
: - '''Picard''' and '''Manua'''
  
: - '''Picard''' and '''Manua'''
  +
  +
  +
"''I never said that!''"<br />
  +
"''Nevertheless, it seems he felt the need to reward you with his work.''"
  +
: - '''Manua''' and '''Picard''', suggesting a possible motivation for the events on the station
   
   
Line 163: Line 227:
   
 
== Background information ==
  
== Background information ==
  +
[[File:Doug Drexler adjusting the makeup on actress Juliana Donald.jpg|thumb|Make-up Artist [[Doug Drexler]] adjusting the make-up on actress [[Juliana Donald]] as Tayna]]
−
[[File:Matter of Perspective remastering.jpg|thumb|Re-editing the remastered episode in [[2012]]]]
 +
[[File:Matter of Perspective remastering.jpg|thumb|Re-editing the remastered episode in 2012]]
 
=== Story and production ===
  
=== Story and production ===
 
* According to [[Ronald D. Moore]], the script of this episode received an uncredited "gang-bang" rewrite by the entire writing staff. This constituted Moore's first assignment after joining the team. {{AOLchat|Ronald D. Moore|ron073|1997}}
  
* According to [[Ronald D. Moore]], the script of this episode received an uncredited "gang-bang" rewrite by the entire writing staff. This constituted Moore's first assignment after joining the team. {{AOLchat|Ronald D. Moore|ron073|1997}}
 
* According to David Krieger, he had included a pseudo-scientific explanation on what the waves actually were ("a field that suppressed the strong nuclear force, making any matter exposed to it fissionable"), but the line was cut from the final episode. As a result, the waves ended up as a {{w|MacGuffin}}. [http://www.davekrieger.net/Waves/]
  
* According to David Krieger, he had included a pseudo-scientific explanation on what the waves actually were ("a field that suppressed the strong nuclear force, making any matter exposed to it fissionable"), but the line was cut from the final episode. As a result, the waves ended up as a {{w|MacGuffin}}. [http://www.davekrieger.net/Waves/]
 
* This episode is considered a [[bottle show]]. (''[[Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion]]'' 2nd ed., p. 115)
  
* This episode is considered a [[bottle show]]. (''[[Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion]]'' 2nd ed., p. 115)
  +
* First UK airdate: 22nd January 1992
   
 
=== Sets and props ===
  
=== Sets and props ===
Line 178: Line 244:
 
=== Reception ===
  
=== Reception ===
 
* [[Michael Piller]] recalled that the episode was "''probably the hardest story to break. It was a technical nightmare for the director. I was very, very, happy with the script and I thought the show was disappointing. I guess it didn't translate properly. It was very ambitious, but the casting was off. If you had put {{w|Lana Turner}} in the role of the woman in that show, you would have understood it all &ndash; but I don't think it played as it was intended. That's about the best murder mystery I've been involved in developing in my career, because every detail falls into place, every line comes together to explain how, what, when and where, and it really worked from a mystery standpoint. It's so complicated a mystery. In fact, it's like {{wt|The Big Sleep}} in space. It's very complicated, yet if you take that script apart, nothing falls out of it. It ought to win an {{w|Edgar Award|Edgar Allen Poe Award}} for best mystery of the year. I've been involved in a lot of crime caper shows, but this was a very proud script turned out. I just didn't think it was great television.''" (''[[Captains' Logs: The Unauthorized Complete Trek Voyages]]'', p. 192)
  
* [[Michael Piller]] recalled that the episode was "''probably the hardest story to break. It was a technical nightmare for the director. I was very, very, happy with the script and I thought the show was disappointing. I guess it didn't translate properly. It was very ambitious, but the casting was off. If you had put {{w|Lana Turner}} in the role of the woman in that show, you would have understood it all &ndash; but I don't think it played as it was intended. That's about the best murder mystery I've been involved in developing in my career, because every detail falls into place, every line comes together to explain how, what, when and where, and it really worked from a mystery standpoint. It's so complicated a mystery. In fact, it's like {{wt|The Big Sleep}} in space. It's very complicated, yet if you take that script apart, nothing falls out of it. It ought to win an {{w|Edgar Award|Edgar Allen Poe Award}} for best mystery of the year. I've been involved in a lot of crime caper shows, but this was a very proud script turned out. I just didn't think it was great television.''" (''[[Captains' Logs: The Unauthorized Complete Trek Voyages]]'', p. 192)
  +
* [[Ira Steven Behr]] and Ronald D. Moore were even more scathing in their opinions of the episode, with both naming it as the worst episode of the third season. Behr in particular called the episode "a disaster," and arguably even his least favorite of all the ''Star Trek'' episodes he ever worked on. ([[TNG Season 3 Blu-ray]], {{e|Yesterday's Enterprise}} commentary)
 
* Scientific consultant [[David Krieger]] recalled that this episode was one of the few times that he was invited in person to a story conference. According to Krieger, the main problem faced by the writing staff was how to threaten the ship, while still maintaining the proposition that holodecks should not of themselves create dangerous objects. Krieger noted, "''At the whiteboard in Michael Piller's office, I explained my idea of making the holodeck construct act merely as a reflector/concentrator for an outside radiation source. The reconstruction of the dead scientist's laboratory was not itself inherently "dangerous" (as per the series bible), but in combination with an external radiation source, its geometry made it as effective as the real concentrator in creating the destructive phenomenon the scientist had been studying.''" Pleased with this solution, the writers decided to temporarily call the radiation field [[Krieger wave]]s. Krieger was surprised when he discovered that the name was retained in the final episode. [http://www.davekrieger.net/Waves/]
  
* Scientific consultant [[David Krieger]] recalled that this episode was one of the few times that he was invited in person to a story conference. According to Krieger, the main problem faced by the writing staff was how to threaten the ship, while still maintaining the proposition that holodecks should not of themselves create dangerous objects. Krieger noted, "''At the whiteboard in Michael Piller's office, I explained my idea of making the holodeck construct act merely as a reflector/concentrator for an outside radiation source. The reconstruction of the dead scientist's laboratory was not itself inherently "dangerous" (as per the series bible), but in combination with an external radiation source, its geometry made it as effective as the real concentrator in creating the destructive phenomenon the scientist had been studying.''" Pleased with this solution, the writers decided to temporarily call the radiation field [[Krieger wave]]s. Krieger was surprised when he discovered that the name was retained in the final episode. [http://www.davekrieger.net/Waves/]
 
* The plot of this episode has been likened to the classic Japanese film, {{w|Rashomon (film)|Rashômon}}. (''[[The Unauthorized History of Trek]]'')
  
* The plot of this episode has been likened to the classic Japanese film, {{w|Rashomon (film)|Rashômon}}. (''[[The Unauthorized History of Trek]]'')
Line 188: Line 255:
 
* UK re-release (three-episode tapes, [[Paramount Home Entertainment]]): Volume 3.5, {{d|3|July|2000}}
  
* UK re-release (three-episode tapes, [[Paramount Home Entertainment]]): Volume 3.5, {{d|3|July|2000}}
 
* As part of the [[TNG Season 3 DVD]] collection
  
* As part of the [[TNG Season 3 DVD]] collection
  +
* As part of the [[TNG Season 3 Blu-ray]] collection
   
 
== Links and references ==
  
== Links and references ==
Line 195: Line 263:
   
 
=== Also starring ===
  
=== Also starring ===
−
* [[LeVar Burton]] as [[Lieutenant Commander|Lt. Cmdr.]] [[Geordi La Forge]]
 +
* [[LeVar Burton]] as [[Lieutenant commander|Lt. Cmdr.]] [[Geordi La Forge]]
 
* [[Michael Dorn]] as [[Lieutenant]] [[Worf]]
  
* [[Michael Dorn]] as [[Lieutenant]] [[Worf]]
 
* [[Gates McFadden]] as [[Doctor|Dr.]] [[Beverly Crusher]]
  
* [[Gates McFadden]] as [[Doctor|Dr.]] [[Beverly Crusher]]
 
* [[Marina Sirtis]] as [[Counselor]] [[Deanna Troi]]
  
* [[Marina Sirtis]] as [[Counselor]] [[Deanna Troi]]
−
* [[Brent Spiner]] as [[Lieutenant Commander|Lt. Commander]] [[Data]]
 +
* [[Brent Spiner]] as [[Lieutenant commander|Lt. Commander]] [[Data]]
 
* [[Wil Wheaton]] as [[Wesley Crusher]]
  
* [[Wil Wheaton]] as [[Wesley Crusher]]
   
Line 214: Line 282:
 
* [[Majel Barrett]] as {{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701-D|-D}} [[computer voice]]
  
* [[Majel Barrett]] as {{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701-D|-D}} [[computer voice]]
 
* [[Michael Braveheart]] as [[Martinez]]
  
* [[Michael Braveheart]] as [[Martinez]]
−
* [[Debbie Marsh]] as [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Female bridge command officer (2366)|command division officer]]
 +
* [[Debbie Marsh]] as [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) command division personnel#Female bridge command officer (2366)|command division officer]]
−
* [[Tim McCormack]] as [[Bennett (Ensign)|Bennett]]
 +
* [[Tim McCormack]] as {{dis|Bennett|Ensign}}
  ⚫
* [[Parker McPhinney]] as [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Art class model|art class model]]
 
* [[Keith Rayve]] as [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Command / Operations division ensign|command division ensign]]
 
* [[Keith Rayve]] as [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Command / Operations division ensign|command division ensign]]
−
* [[Dan Sachoff]] as [[Williams (Male Ensign)|Williams]]
 +
* [[Dan Sachoff]] as {{dis|Williams|Male Ensign}}
 
* [[Unknown performers]] as
  
* [[Unknown performers]] as
−
** [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Art class model|Art class model]]
 +
** [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) operations division personnel#Female relief ops ensign (2366)|Female operations ensign]]
  ⚫
** {{dis|Wright|Lieutenant}}
⚫
** [[Unnamed USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-D) personnel#Female relief ops ensign (2366)|Female operations ensign]]
  
⚫
** [[Wright (Lieutenant)|Wright]]
  
   
 
=== Stunt doubles ===
  
=== Stunt doubles ===
Line 236: Line 304:
   
 
===References===
  
===References===
−
[[2366]]; [[antimatter containment tank]]s; [[art]]; [[cargo bay]]; [[champagne]]; [[cubism]]; [[Dadaism]]; [[Deposition Program Riker One]]; [[dicosilium]]; [[duranium]]; [[Emila II]]; [[environmental control]]; [[Fauvism]]; [[Federation]]; [[Ferengi]]; [[geometric constructivism]]; [[hearsay evidence]]; [[holodeck]]; [[holodeck programs]]; [[hologram]]; [[Hypothetical Krag One]]; [[investigator|chief investigator]]; [[Krieger wave]]s; [[Krieger wave converter]]; [[La Forge One]]; [[Lambda field generator]]; [[leak]]; [[Fernand Léger|Léger, Fernand]]; [[Manua Simulation One]]; [[megawatt]]; [[navigational deflector]]; [[Pablo Picasso|Picasso, Pablo]]; [[proto-Vulcan]]; [[protostar cloud]]; [[radiation]]; [[rape]]; [[Rapunzel]]; [[reflective coil]]; [[Romulan]]s; [[sector]]; [[sickbay]]; [[Starfleet]]; [[Starfleet material supply command database]]; [[surrealism]]; [[Tanuga IV]]; [[Tanuga IV research station]]; [[Tanuga system]]; [[Tanugan]]; [[Tanugan security force]]; [[Tayna Simulation Three]]; [[Tayna Simulation Four]]; [[tricorder]]; [[warp core]]
+
[[2366]]; [[antimatter containment tank]]s; [[art]]; [[cargo bay]]; [[champagne]]; [[cubism]]; [[Dadaism]]; [[Deposition Program Riker One]]; [[dicosilium]]; [[duranium]]; [[Emila II]]; [[environmental control]]; [[Fauvism]]; [[Federation]]; [[Ferengi]]; [[geometric constructivism]]; [[hearsay evidence]]; [[holodeck]]; [[holodeck programs]]; [[hologram]]; [[Hypothetical Krag One]]; [[investigator|chief investigator]]; [[kilometer]]; [[Krieger wave]]s; [[Krieger wave converter]]; [[La Forge One]]; [[Lambda field generator]]; [[leak]]; [[Fernand Léger|Léger, Fernand]]; [[Manua Simulation One]]; [[megawatt]]; ''[[Much Ado About Nothing]]''; [[navigational deflector]]; [[number one]]; [[Pablo Picasso|Picasso, Pablo]]; [[proto-Vulcan]]; [[protostar cloud]]; [[radiation]]; [[rape]]; [[Rapunzel]]; [[reflective coil]]; [[Romulan]]s; [[sector]]; [[sickbay]]; [[Starfleet]]; [[Starfleet material supply command database]]; [[surrealism]]; [[Tanuga IV]]; [[Tanuga IV research station]]; [[Tanuga system]]; [[Tanugan]]; [[Tanugan security force]]; [[Tayna Simulation Three]]; [[Tayna Simulation Four]]; [[toast]]; [[tricorder]]; [[warp core]]
   
 
===Extra link===
  
===Extra link===
Line 242: Line 310:
   
 
{{TNG nav|season=3|last={{e|Deja Q}}|next={{e|Yesterday's Enterprise}}}}
  
{{TNG nav|season=3|last={{e|Deja Q}}|next={{e|Yesterday's Enterprise}}}}
  +
   
 
[[de:Riker unter Verdacht]]
  
[[de:Riker unter Verdacht]]
 
[[es:A Matter of Perspective]]
  
[[es:A Matter of Perspective]]
−
[[fr:A Matter of Perspective]]
 +
[[fr:A Matter of Perspective (épisode)]]
−
[[ja:TNG:疑惑のビーム]]
 +
[[ja:疑惑のビーム（エピソード）]]
 
[[nl:A Matter of Perspective]]
  
[[nl:A Matter of Perspective]]
 
[[pl:A Matter of Perspective]]
  
[[pl:A Matter of Perspective]]

Revision as of 23:02, 27 January 2015

Template:Realworld

When Riker is charged with the murder of a prominent scientist, each side uses the holodeck to show their side of the story.

Summary

Teaser

File:Picard paints.jpg

"...interesting."

Captain Picard is attending art class with two other crewmembers, and all three are painting canvasses of an unknown figure – later revealed to be a nude model. Lieutenant Commander Data enters and informs the captain that the Enterprise has arrived at Tanuga IV, and that the away team has completed its survey of Dr. Nel Apgar's research and is ready to return. Picard acknowledges Data while Data tries to subtly get a better look at the captain's painting.

Picard notices and makes a gesture allowing Data to examine his work and that of the other students. Data compliments the work of Ensign Williams and Lieutenant Wright, but he is much more critical of Picard's work, saying that it is disorganized, using too many disparate techniques. Picard grimaces while Data makes his assessment but "thanks" him when he feels that Data has said enough, and the android leaves.

"Captain's log, Stardate 43610.4. After completing a delivery of dicosilium to the Tanuga IV research station, our away team has received an update from Doctor Nel Apgar on his efforts to create Krieger waves, a potentially valuable new power source."

Picard enters the bridge, welcoming Lieutenant Commander La Forge back from the station. The captain asks where Commander Riker is. La Forge replies that he is still on the station where Dr. Apgar is working as Apgar wanted to speak to Riker. Although La Forge replies evenly, Picard notices some tension in his speech, and asks if there were any problems.

File:EnterprisePOV ApgarStationDestroyed.jpg

An unexpected explosion

The chief engineer seems unsure of how to reply but says that nothing went wrong with the scientific portion of the mission. Picard becomes even more curious about what happened on the station due to La Forge's explanation, but La Forge is spared when Riker's exasperated voice is heard through the communicator asking to leave immediately. La Forge tells the captain that Riker will explain when he returns.

Chief O'Brien engages the transporter to bring Riker back, but nothing happens, and when he reads the console, he immediately calls engineering, informing them of a power drain. Without warning, the station suddenly explodes, blowing up Dr. Apgar, to the horror of Picard and the bridge crew. O'Brien hasn't beamed Riker back yet as he is having trouble clearing the first officer's signal, but eventually Riker is brought aboard. Riker asks why O'Brien is so surprised that he brought him back; O'Brien informs him that the science station just exploded and Riker turns to the transporter, with a visibly shocked look.

Act One

"Captain's log, supplemental: Commander Riker has informed me that Doctor Apgar was the only one aboard the space station when it exploded. We remain in orbit investigating the accident..."
Riker questions O'Brien

"We weren't sure you left the space station in time!"

O'Brien tells the captain (over the com) that he has checked throughout the transporter system and hasn't found a malfunction or anything that could have caused an explosion like the one that just destroyed the station. He cannot explain the brief power drain just before the explosion, either. Picard tells O'Brien that he will want an explanation and he's sure the Tanugan government will want one as well. Data informs Picard that the radiation and debris are consistent with an overload of the station's reactor core but neither La Forge nor Riker saw any indications of problems with the reactor while they were on board the station.

Picard turns his attention to Riker and asks him about the mission not going quite so routinely. Riker is slightly dismissive and doubts that it had anything to do with the explosion. Worf informs the captain that Chief Investigator Krag of the Tanugan security force is requesting permission to beam aboard; Picard grants permission and asks Worf to escort him to the bridge. While Worf is escorting Krag, Picard wants Riker to explain everything that happened on board the station as best as he can.

Krag comes to arrest Riker

"Commander Riker, I am here to take you into custody."

Upon Krag's entry to the bridge Picard introduces himself and Riker. As soon as he hears Riker's name mentioned, Krag dismisses Picard and approaches Riker informing him that he is to take him into custody on suspicion of murder. Riker responds angrily, but Picard interrupts saying that he and the rest of the Enterprise crew are willing to co-operate. Krag, though, insists on extraditing the "prisoner" and Picard asks Krag to accompany him to the ready room, as the bridge is not the best place to discuss such a delicate topic. Riker walks to join them but Picard dismisses him, telling him that he has the bridge, and the bridge staff cannot help but look at Riker in surprise about the recent accusation against him.

In the ready room, Picard asks Krag what evidence there is against Commander Riker. Krag says that two witnesses have come forward to describe Riker's threats against Apgar. Picard is surprised, saying that there was only an altercation but Krag claims that it was much more than that. He says that Riker will be given the opportunity to prove his innocence – in the Tanugan jurisprudence, the accused is "guilty until proven innocent," while the Federation's own works on the opposite basis. Krag informs Picard that he has consulted Federation regulations and because the alleged incident happened within Tanugan space, they have jurisdiction, but Picard says that the regulations also state that the captain will decide if extradition of an officer is warranted and that if there is sufficient evidence is brought forward, he will release Riker into Krag's custody.

File:Krag&Picard.jpg

"He is guilty until he is proven innocent."

Krag asks about Picard's closeness to Riker but the captain refuses to answer, saying that it is irrelevant in this instance. Krag feels that it is relevant, though, as he would not expect an impartial decision from Picard, but Picard feels compelled to protect the rights of those who serve with him. Krag appreciates his situation but says that he will do it on the planet as the Enterprise can leave the Tanugan system at any moment; Picard gives his word that, as a Starfleet officer, he will not do so. Krag has little faith in Picard and demands that Riker be turned over for interrogation. Picard says that Krag can interrogate him on the Enterprise. Krag says that interrogation would be impossible on the ship, as great resources would be needed, from witness accounts to the ground computer data.

Picard considers a compromise and says that perhaps it won't be impossible, calling Data into the ready room. Upon entering the ready room, Picard introduces Data to Krag and asks if it would be possible to recreate the events that took place on the station based on testimony from both the away team and witnesses. Although it would require extensive resources including design specifications of the equipment used, Data replies that it would be possible to do so. Krag considers what Picard and Data have just said – because the captain has no intention of releasing Riker as of yet, Krag agrees and will make arrangements to provide all of the available information. He will also return with his witnesses and Data escorts Krag to Transporter Room Three.

Picard asks for holodeck reenactment

"We are going to recreate the research station here on the holodeck."

Picard leaves the ready room, telling La Forge and Wesley Crusher that they are going to recreate the station in the holodeck: both La Forge and Riker will give the computer depositions with detailed descriptions of what they witnessed on the station, and Counselor Troi will assist Picard during the inquiry. Picard then considers what he'll say next and firmly (although quietly) tells Riker (and the other staff) that his decision on whether or not to extradite him will be based on the evidence in the holodeck re-creations. Riker asks for a private word with Picard, but the captain refuses as it would be inappropriate under the circumstances and returns to the ready room.

Act Two

"Second officer's log, Stardate 43611.6. Programming of the holodeck has taken eighteen hours and eleven minutes and is now complete. All participants have entered their depositions. Technical schematics and complete records from the lab's ground computers, as well as Doctor Apgar's personal logs, have been included. The recreations will have a nominal eight-point-seven percent margin of error."
Riker's trial begins

"I'm not a murderer."

Picard, Riker, Krag and Troi enter the holodeck and take their seats in a holographic facsimile of the laboratory on board the space station. Before the inquiry begins, Riker makes a statement that he was not a murderer but a representative of Starfleet sent to make a progress report on Dr. Apgar's development of the Krieger wave converter, and that he acted accordingly throughout the mission.

Riker then runs a simulation recalling events as he remembers them. Holograms of Dr. Apgar and his assistant, Tayna, appear and the holograms of Riker and La Forge beam aboard the station. Throughout Riker's simulation, the hologram of Riker maintains a neutral, business-like demeanor while Apgar is somewhat impatient and far from pleased with Starfleet's arrival, although he makes an effort to be polite. A simulation of Apgar's wife, Manua, enters, apologizing for the doctor's less than accommodating behavior. Throughout the simulation she can't seem to take her eyes off of Riker and treats Apgar like an afterthought.

Tanuga Station simulation begins

Riker's simulation begins

La Forge accompanies Tayna to one of the stations, talking about the Lambda field generator while Manua escorts Riker (while Apgar follows) for a welcoming drink. The three share glasses of champagne, but Apgar has little interest in pleasantries and asks Riker why Starfleet came so soon, especially as Apgar wasn't due to update them on his progress for another three months. Riker felt that it was a good time as the Enterprise was in the sector on another mission studying a protostar and that Apgar had requested additional dicosilium for his research.

The Federation flagship would be returning the following day and Apgar was less than pleased with hearing this but Riker told him that he and La Forge had already arranged accommodations on the planet, below but Manua insisted that they stay to keep her company and further apologizes for her husband's shortcomings in spite of his scientific prowess. Krag interrupts asking if it was Riker's testimony that it was Manua's idea for Riker and La Forge to stay on the station; Riker confirms this and says that it is also the truth.

The simulation resumes now in the station's guest quarters with Riker and Manua present. Manua shows Riker around the quarters but does not leave and begins to proposition Riker, partially undressing. Riker insists that she leave but as he redresses her, Apgar walks in, catching the two in an extremely uncomfortable position. The scientist reacts furiously, hitting his wife and taking a swing at Riker but Riker moves out of the way of Apgar's punch and he falls.

File:RikerMisunderstanding.jpg

"Doctor, believe me. This has been a terrible mistake."

Riker insists that what just happened was a terrible misunderstanding but Apgar assures him that he will make a formal complaint to Starfleet. The first officer interrupts the simulation and says that he didn't see Dr. Apgar until the following morning, when Apgar asked to speak to him alone. La Forge later returned to the Enterprise.

The simulation resumes, returning to the laboratory, where Apgar asks if his complaint will result in Riker giving a less-than-favorable report on his work. Riker insists that the complaint will not affect the report in any way and asks that he call Manua in so they can all resolve the misunderstanding, but both she and Tayna have since returned to the planet. Apgar is frustrated with not knowing where he stands with Starfleet and asks Riker if he feels that there is no justification for the additional dicosilium that he ordered. He insists that he can explain why he needs it but Riker doesn't need any explanations – he will not grant Apgar's request. Apgar dismisses him and Riker calls the Enterprise, saying that he's ready to leave. Riker freezes the simulation and says that this was when he left the station.

File:Krag1-RikerMurderer.jpg

"I never fired a phaser on the science station!"

Krag asks if Riker has anything to add, such as firing a phaser. Riker denies having fired a phaser on the station at all and Krag is somewhat perplexed by Riker's denial because the lab ground computers indicated that a focused energy pulse was fired just as the Enterprise's transporters were engaged. Furthermore, analyses of the trajectory and angle of the pulse were traced back to Riker's exact position. Krag then runs a hypothetical simulation of what he believes Riker did. The simulation returns to the point just before Riker departs. Riker calls the Enterprise saying that he's ready to leave now and as the materialization effect of the transporter begins, he quickly draws his phaser and fires at the reactor – three seconds later, the station explodes.

Act Three

File:Deck39RadiationBurn.jpg

"What kind of radiation could do this?"

Data, La Forge and Wesley are all observing the monitors on the first science station on the bridge where there is a graph displaying the results of a composite radiation traceback analysis. There is an extremely large spike on the far right of the graph that indicates the explosion of the station but there is an anomalous smaller spike just before the larger one. Unfortunately, the energy signature is consistent with that of a phaser and there was nothing else on board the station that La Forge saw that could produce a similar energy signature.

Wesley openly says that it couldn't have been Riker who fired the phaser and thinks that there is something else that caused the discharge but, although La Forge agrees, he cannot explain why the discharge came from Riker's exact position. Worf then reports that there is a radiation burst on Deck 39, just outside of cargo bay 12. The computer cannot identify either the source or the type of radiation but it soon subsides.

La Forge and Wesley are now studying the recent burst of radiation with a tricorder which has melted a section of the wall, but both are baffled as they don't know of any type of radiation that could have done this. Not even the ship's deflector puts out this much radiation spillage, but what they do know about this radiation is that it is a serious threat to the ship as it can put a hole in duranium.

Manua's deposition

"I just know he did it. He killed my husband."

Returning to the holodeck, Krag escorts (the real) Manua Apgar into the room. She is much more modestly dressed and her demeanor is much less sensual than the hologram of her in Riker's simulation. Before the next simulation is shown, she makes no statement – she just "knows" that Commander Riker killed her husband. Krag runs Manua's recollection of events on board the space station. Holograms of Manua and Apgar appear in their quarters and Apgar is extremely anxious about Starfleet arriving and worries that they will stop sponsoring his research because he feels that he hasn't progressed as far as expected. Manua tries to assure him that just a bit of charm would be needed to persuade Starfleet to give him more time.

The simulation returns to the lab where Riker introduces himself and La Forge and Manua enter, but throughout this simulation Riker has a much more relaxed, charming, less formal attitude – in some respects much like the real Riker. In addition, Riker pays more attention to Manua than Apgar's progress and looks at her in a provocative way, making her feel uncomfortable. Tayna shows La Forge the station, describing the field generator while Manua takes Apgar (whom she takes company of this time) and Riker away for a drink.

During the drink, Riker again shows little interest in what Apgar has to say, continuously looking at Manua, and asks if he and La Forge can remain on the station; Apgar reluctantly agrees. Manua shows Riker the modestly-sized quarters but Riker says that it has her charm, making her feel more uncomfortable with each move he makes. He then closes the door on her and makes more, stronger advances on her. Since she is smaller and much weaker than Riker, Manua is almost powerless to stop him although she resists as much as she can, pleading for him to stop.

File:RikerwithRikerManuaSims.jpg

"I didn't proposition her, and I certainly didn't try to rape her!"

(The real) Riker interrupts with an angry outburst, leaving his chair, unable to take any more and Picard pauses the simulation. Riker is furious at Manua's accusations and categorically denies having propositioned her or trying to rape her, asking why Manua was doing this, but she said that this was exactly what happened. Deanna calls for Riker to return to his seat to prevent him from doing or saying something that he may regret; he returns to his seat and Krag resumes the simulation.

Apgar walks in seeing Manua in Riker's arms and is immediately enraged, taking a swing a Riker but Riker blocks Apgar's punch and lands two jabs in the scientist's stomach, causing Apgar to fall back onto the floor. Manua runs over to try to protect her husband and Apgar promises that this will be Riker's last mission, but Riker threatens him saying that he'll be making a terrible mistake if he lodges his complaint. Krag freezes the simulation and Manua says to Riker that his career in Starfleet was secure despite Apgar's promise – as a scientist, he would have been distracted by some technical trivia and would have forgotten all about his complaint to Starfleet. The memory of her dead husband has become too much for Manua and she leaves the holodeck crying.

Riker worried at trial

"Her version puts a noose around my neck."

Picard calls for a recess and reassuringly taps Riker's shoulder as he and Krag exit, knowing that the evidence against Riker is mounting. Riker turns to Deanna and asks why Manua would have lied about what happened but the counselor does not respond. He notices and asks if she thought that he could have done what Manua accused him of. Deanna reassures him that she knows that he couldn't even contemplate such an act, even though she sensed no kind of deception from Manua – they are both telling the truth as they remember it. Unfortunately, Manua's recollection of events would result in Riker's extradition and likely conviction.

Dr. Crusher and Martinez are treating a crewwoman in sickbay who has recently injured her arm. Crusher feels that the healing of her injury has advanced enough for her to start restoring the strength of her muscles but Worf (on the com) calls for Crusher and those present to evacuate immediately as a radiation burst has been detected in sickbay; part of the wall begins to burn away.

Act Four

La Forge and Wesley are studying the newly-melted spot in the wall. Data confirms that it is the same radiation that had previously penetrated the section of wall on Deck 39 – a highly-focused, powerful emission of radiation but it is of unknown origin. La Forge warns Captain Picard that if this radiation were to form in either the warp core or the antimatter storage pods, they'd be in serious trouble.

Investigating sickbay

"Very powerful, but of unknown origin."

Picard asks if either of the three have any theories; Data has noticed something that was too strange to be a coincidence – the radiation events aboard the Enterprise occurred five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds apart while the space station exploded at almost four times that interval the previous day – there is a 0.0014 second variance that none of them have been able to explain. Although there is no evidence at present to connect the events, it appears that they may be linked, but if they are correct, they would be able to predict the next radiation event occurring – just over five hours from now. Picard orders them to take the necessary precautions to protect the ship's most vital areas and if they cannot find the source of the radiation by the next interval, the Enterprise is to leave orbit of Tanuga IV.

In the holodeck, the hearing resumes with (the real) Tayna describing what Dr. Apgar told her about the alleged incident between himself, Commander Riker and Manua. She and Krag have made a reconstruction of what happened on the station in the guest quarters based on her deposition but Picard interrupts protesting that Tayna's accounts are nothing more than hearsay evidence but because Apgar is dead, Tayna's evidence is admissible under Tanugan law and Krag insists that Picard consider it; Picard reluctantly agrees to listen to the "evidence" and Tayna's simulation runs, beginning similarly to where Manua's simulation ended.

Apgar punchout

"I'm not the fool you take me for."

Apgar walks in catching Riker and Manua sharing a passionate kiss; Riker takes a swing at Apgar but the scientist ducks and strikes Riker, knocking him to the floor, assuring him that he will lodge a complaint to Starfleet but Riker threatens him calling him a "dead man." Tayna's next simulation (set in the lab) with Tayna and Apgar; he wants her to take his wife and return to the planet, but Tayna protests and says that he should come down too because Riker threatened him. Apgar, though, feels compelled to protect their work.

She agrees and decides to contact the authorities, but Apgar tells her not to – he will take care of Riker himself. The simulation stops and Tayna recalls hearing about the station exploding, also "knowing" that Riker killed Dr. Apgar, then leaves. Krag has now established motive, method and opportunity for to Riker to have murdered Apgar – in any court within the Federation, these are sufficient criteria to warrant the extradition of a suspect and Krag awaits Picard's decision.

Act Five

File:PicardmayloseWill.jpg

"The evidence warrants a trial... I'll have to allow extradition."

Picard and Troi are in the ready room and it seems all but certain that Picard will have little alternative other than to hand Riker over to the Tanugans, as the evidence gathered against Riker warrants a trial. Although both he and Troi know that Riker is innocent, they cannot yield to their feelings and unfortunately, there is little evidence to prove their friend's innocence. They are interrupted when Data calls them over the com, telling them that the source of the radiation has been discovered; they return to the bridge.

Data reports that he, La Forge and Wesley have been looking a phenomenon that occurs every five hours, twenty minutes and three seconds and one such phenomenon has been discovered on the planet's surface – the field generator that Apgar used in his research. When it is fully charged it emits an energy pulse then requires the same amount of time to recharge itself – it was left on after the station had exploded. Picard asks why the generator was affecting the Enterprise as it had been – it should not have done so as it was a harmless generator, but they knew that it was connected to the radiation bursts and they have now determined not only the cause of the radiation bursts and the cause of the explosion that destroyed the space station, but also who killed Dr. Apgar.

Picard, Riker, La Forge, Troi, Krag, Manua, and Tayna are all present in the holodeck and Picard says that despite all of the evidence and events shown on the station, they haven't seen all of what really happened. Krag does not understand and Picard enlists La Forge's assistance to prepare their arguments with a few excerpts from their previous recreations:

File:KriegerWaveConverter.jpg

"The energy from the field generator down on the planet simply reflects off of elements in the converter."

First, an excerpt from Manua's testimony, in which Apgar says that he has suffered several setbacks, and was upset at Starfleet's early arrival to check on his progress. Manua acknowledges her testimony, adding that her husband was under extreme pressure to make his breakthrough. Picard then posits that Apgar was lying to Starfleet, and had, in fact, already succeeded in creating Krieger waves. Geordi fills in Krag about the mysterious radiation bursts that have been hitting the Enterprise, which they've identified as Krieger waves. Baffled, Tayna says that is impossible – even if Apgar had succeeded in creating them, there is nothing to generate them after the station was destroyed.

Geordi says that the waves are being created by the holodeck's facsimile of Apgar's lab, which includes the Krieger wave converter that he falsely claimed didn't work. The field generator on the planet has been sending harmless energy pulses to the Enterprise, which were converted to Krieger waves by the facsimile of the converter. Riker is confused, since the holodeck cannot create anything dangerous unless the safety protocols are disabled. La Forge acknowledges this and says that technically, it didn't do so, since the converter is essentially little more than a complex series of mirrors and reflective coils. The energy pulses from the field generator were reflected off of elements in the converter that changed them into focused Krieger waves, which have been striking different areas of the ship as its angle to the generator changes.

File:Apgar reacts to Riker.jpg

"I'll take care of that!"

Krag asks why Apgar would lie about his progress. Picard runs extracts of two simulations, one in which Apgar promises Manua that his work will yield rich rewards, and another in which Manua references these same rewards as she, Apgar, and Riker are toasting her husband's anticipated breakthrough. Troi explains that Apgar would not have made substantial profits from selling a new power source to Starfleet, but he could have made a much greater profit selling a new weapon to the Romulans, the Ferengi, and other species. Dr. Apgar's orders for extra dicosilium were a good indicator that he was trying to create larger reflective coils, to build a more lethal version of his existing converter.

When the Enterprise arrived early, Picard theorizes, Apgar became worried that Starfleet had become suspicious of him. In all three simulations, Apgar claims that he needs more time for his research. Picard further theorizes that Apgar became convinced Riker was onto him, and decided to kill him to protect himself (finding Riker with his wife did not improve matters, Picard adds).

Manua finds Picard's submission ridiculous, but Picard replays Tayna's simulation from the lab, when Apgar assures Tayna that he would take care of Riker instead of taking the matter to the authorities. When Apgar sits at a console, Picard freezes the simulation and asks Tayna what Apgar is doing. She says he is activating the generator on the planet but she does not know why. Picard suggests that Apgar was thinking ahead to his next confrontation with Riker.

File:RikerDeflection.jpg

"Doctor Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker."

Picard replays Riker's simulation at the point where Riker and Apgar discuss what Riker would put in his report. After Riker says that he needs no explanation for Apgar's extra orders for dicosilium, Picard freezes the simulation and surmises that Apgar felt that Riker was confirming his worst fears and this was when he decided to kill Riker.

Krag reminds Picard that the energy pulse that blew up the reactor (causing the station's destruction) came from Commander Riker's position, not Dr. Apgar's. La Forge picks up the explanation, hypothesizing that at the moment Riker beamed out, Apgar energized the converter to fire an energy pulse at Riker, hoping to make his death look like a transporter accident, but Apgar's plan went awry – the pulse instead reflected off the transporter beam into the reactor, causing the explosion.

Krag finds the hypothesis interesting, but dismisses it as impossible to prove. La Forge disagrees, as they have already established that the generator has been discharging and recharging at regular intervals except for the 0.0014-second variance between the first discharge and the explosion of the station. The only logical explanation for this variance is the split-second it took for the energy pulse to bounce off the transporter beam back to the reactor.

Krag apologizes

"Commander... my apologies."

Picard and La Forge then deliver their final effect, running a new simulation that has been deliberately synchronized with the next discharge from the generator. The simulation resumes with Apgar returning to the console that he was working on (as seen also in Tayna's simulation) while Riker calls the Enterprise saying that he is ready to leave. As the transporter beam engages, a Krieger wave beam fires from the generator at Riker's position, but it reflects off of the transporter beam into the reactor, resulting in an explosion, destroying everything in the simulation.

Only the "real" people remain in an empty hologrid, where Picard summarizes that Dr. Apgar killed himself during his attempt to kill Commander Riker. After having seen this new evidence, Krag withdraws his request for Riker's extradition and offers Riker his apologies. After Krag, Manua and Tayna return to Tanuga IV, the Enterprise leaves the system on a course for Emila II.

Memorable quotes

"Riker to Enterprise, I'm ready to leave. Now."

- Riker, before beaming over from the station.


(Relieved)"Transporter room to bridge – he's aboard..."
"Why do you sound so surprised, Mr. O'Brien?"
"Well, for a moment we weren't sure you left the space station in time..."
"In time for what?"
"It just exploded, sir."

- O'Brien and Riker


"I must apologize for my husband's lack of social graces. He may be one of the great scientific minds in the galaxy... but he does come up a bit short in other areas."

- Manua, on Dr. Nel Apgar


"Damn it, I should have stayed with him!"

- La Forge, during Riker's murder investigation


"Investigator, in our system of jurisprudence a man is innocent until proved guilty."
"In ours, he is guilty until he is proved innocent and you are under our jurisdiction."

- Picard, arguing with Krag over Tanugan legal procedures


"I didn't proposition her and I certainly didn't try to rape her!"

- Riker, on Manua Apgar's accusation


"A man more interested in Krieger waves than a lovely woman, how is that possible?"

- Holographic Riker, to Manua


"She's lying! That never happened!"

- Riker


"We can't both be telling the truth."
"It is the truth... as you each remember it."
"Yes, but her version puts a noose around my neck."

- Riker and Troi


"I'm going to report this, Riker. You can count on that."
"You're a dead man, Apgar! A DEAD MAN!!!"

- Holographic Apgar and Holographic Riker


"I submit he decided to murder Commander Riker!"
"Ridiculous!"
"Is it?"

- Picard and Manua


"I never said that!"
"Nevertheless, it seems he felt the need to reward you with his work."

- Manua and Picard, suggesting a possible motivation for the events on the station


"Dr. Apgar killed himself - during his attempt to kill Commander Riker."

- Picard, revealing the truth

Background information

Doug Drexler adjusting the makeup on actress Juliana Donald

Make-up Artist Doug Drexler adjusting the make-up on actress Juliana Donald as Tayna

Matter of Perspective remastering

Re-editing the remastered episode in 2012

Story and production

  • According to Ronald D. Moore, the script of this episode received an uncredited "gang-bang" rewrite by the entire writing staff. This constituted Moore's first assignment after joining the team. (AOL chat, 1997)
  • According to David Krieger, he had included a pseudo-scientific explanation on what the waves actually were ("a field that suppressed the strong nuclear force, making any matter exposed to it fissionable"), but the line was cut from the final episode. As a result, the waves ended up as a MacGuffin. [1]
  • This episode is considered a bottle show. (Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion 2nd ed., p. 115)
  • First UK airdate: 22nd January 1992

Sets and props

Continuity

  • Picard is never seen painting again. A deleted scene had Picard throw red paint at his painting after Data's crushing criticism of his work.

Reception

  • Michael Piller recalled that the episode was "probably the hardest story to break. It was a technical nightmare for the director. I was very, very, happy with the script and I thought the show was disappointing. I guess it didn't translate properly. It was very ambitious, but the casting was off. If you had put Lana Turner in the role of the woman in that show, you would have understood it all – but I don't think it played as it was intended. That's about the best murder mystery I've been involved in developing in my career, because every detail falls into place, every line comes together to explain how, what, when and where, and it really worked from a mystery standpoint. It's so complicated a mystery. In fact, it's like The Big Sleep in space. It's very complicated, yet if you take that script apart, nothing falls out of it. It ought to win an Edgar Allen Poe Award for best mystery of the year. I've been involved in a lot of crime caper shows, but this was a very proud script turned out. I just didn't think it was great television." (Captains' Logs: The Unauthorized Complete Trek Voyages, p. 192)
  • Ira Steven Behr and Ronald D. Moore were even more scathing in their opinions of the episode, with both naming it as the worst episode of the third season. Behr in particular called the episode "a disaster," and arguably even his least favorite of all the Star Trek episodes he ever worked on. (TNG Season 3 Blu-ray, "Yesterday's Enterprise" commentary)
  • Scientific consultant David Krieger recalled that this episode was one of the few times that he was invited in person to a story conference. According to Krieger, the main problem faced by the writing staff was how to threaten the ship, while still maintaining the proposition that holodecks should not of themselves create dangerous objects. Krieger noted, "At the whiteboard in Michael Piller's office, I explained my idea of making the holodeck construct act merely as a reflector/concentrator for an outside radiation source. The reconstruction of the dead scientist's laboratory was not itself inherently "dangerous" (as per the series bible), but in combination with an external radiation source, its geometry made it as effective as the real concentrator in creating the destructive phenomenon the scientist had been studying." Pleased with this solution, the writers decided to temporarily call the radiation field Krieger waves. Krieger was surprised when he discovered that the name was retained in the final episode. [2]
  • The plot of this episode has been likened to the classic Japanese film, Rashômon. (The Unauthorized History of Trek)
  • The Star Trek: The Next Generation Companion (2nd ed., p. 115) also notes the similarity to the Star Trek: The Original Series episode "Wolf in the Fold".
  • Director Cliff Bole remarked that "A Matter of Perspective" was "one of the toughest shows I've ever shot from the standpoint of keeping continuity and having to shoot something three different ways." (Captains' Logs: The Unauthorized Complete Trek Voyages, p. 192) He further remembered, "It was a real challenge and, I thought, a very clever show. Keeping everybody aware was the big challenge in doing that show, because many people started getting confused. The tougher they are, the better I like them." (²Cliff Bole - Of Redemption & Unification", The Official Star Trek: The Next Generation Magazine Vol. 17, p. 31)
  • A mission report for this episode by Robert Greenberger was published in The Official Star Trek: The Next Generation Magazine Vol. 13, pp. 10-13.

Video and DVD releases

Links and references

Starring

Also starring

Guest stars

Co-star

Uncredited co-stars

Stunt doubles

Stand-ins

References

2366; antimatter containment tanks; art; cargo bay; champagne; cubism; Dadaism; Deposition Program Riker One; dicosilium; duranium; Emila II; environmental control; Fauvism; Federation; Ferengi; geometric constructivism; hearsay evidence; holodeck; holodeck programs; hologram; Hypothetical Krag One; chief investigator; kilometer; Krieger waves; Krieger wave converter; La Forge One; Lambda field generator; leak; Léger, Fernand; Manua Simulation One; megawatt; Much Ado About Nothing; navigational deflector; number one; Picasso, Pablo; proto-Vulcan; protostar cloud; radiation; rape; Rapunzel; reflective coil; Romulans; sector; sickbay; Starfleet; Starfleet material supply command database; surrealism; Tanuga IV; Tanuga IV research station; Tanuga system; Tanugan; Tanugan security force; Tayna Simulation Three; Tayna Simulation Four; toast; tricorder; warp core

Extra link

Previous episode:
"Deja Q" 		Star Trek: The Next Generation
Season 3 		Next episode:
"Yesterday's Enterprise"
Deutsch Español Français 日本語 Nederlands Polski
Community content is available under CC-BY-NC unless otherwise noted.
More Fandoms