Wikia

Memory Alpha

Changes: Memory Alpha:Point of view

edit this page

Back to page

m (+cat)
(just an idea; comments welcome)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{shortcut|[[MA:POV]]}}
+
'''The following is my proposed rewrite of [[MA:POV|the current POV policy]] to address concerns raised [[Memory Alpha talk:Point of view#Amendment... anew|here]]. Feedback should probably go on to that discussion page.'''
{{ma nav|Policies and guidelines}}
 
{{policy}}
 
   
Memory Alpha's '''point of view''' ('''POV''') is that of a character inside the fictional ''Star Trek'' universe – an archivist at [[Memory Alpha]], the Federation library planet.
+
Memory Alpha is written in several '''points of view''' ('''POV''').
   
Because ''Star Trek'' stories take place in many different eras, from the beginnings of life on [[Earth]] to the [[29th century]] and beyond, and because forthcoming stories may even expand beyond that, it is important to write all articles from a single perspective: i.e. that of someone looking back at the past. This helps to keep Memory Alpha consistent and understandable. If it helps, pretend that we're writing and viewing this data archive long after the ''Star Trek'' universe as we know it has ceased to exist.
+
==In-Universe==
  +
Memory Alpha's primary point of view is that of a character inside the fictional ''Star Trek'' universe – an archivist at [[Memory Alpha]], the Federation library planet.
   
 
''Star Trek'' universe articles should be written as if the described person, object, or event actually existed or occurred, exactly like in a normal encyclopedia, but with an omniscient writer. Think of Memory Alpha as an encyclopedia that exists in the ''Star Trek'' universe.
 
''Star Trek'' universe articles should be written as if the described person, object, or event actually existed or occurred, exactly like in a normal encyclopedia, but with an omniscient writer. Think of Memory Alpha as an encyclopedia that exists in the ''Star Trek'' universe.
   
The ''only'' exceptions to this rule are articles about the ''Star Trek'' franchise and production (eg. articles on books, comics, actors, staff, etc.), which naturally are not part of the ''Star Trek'' universe (see the template {{tl|realworld}} for further details).
+
Use
  +
:"...Spock was a half-Human, half-Vulcan, who served as science officer – and later first officer – aboard the USS ''Enterprise''..."
  +
Instead of
  +
:"...Spock is the famous half-Human, half-Vulcan of ''Star Trek: The Original Series'' (TOS)..."
   
==Tense==
+
===Tense===
The point of view that should be used in regular articles is that of someone living long after the ''Star Trek'' era, but in the same universe. This means using the ''past tense'' in all instances. For "eternal" concepts, such as ideas, they may be qualified with a time setting, thus placing them into context. For example, the idea of a "starship" is "eternal", but a specific starship is not.
+
Because ''Star Trek'' stories take place in many different eras, from the beginnings of life on [[Earth]] to the [[29th century]] and beyond, and because forthcoming stories may even expand beyond that, it is important to write all articles from a single perspective: i.e. that of someone looking back at the past. This helps to keep Memory Alpha consistent and understandable. If it helps, pretend that we're writing and viewing this data archive long after the ''Star Trek'' universe as we know it has ceased to exist.
   
Some examples of how tense should be used on Memory Alpha :
+
This means using the ''past tense'' in almost all instances.
:The ''Enterprise'' was a starship in the 24th century.
 
   
:Penguins were waterfowl indigenous to Earth until at least the 21st century.
+
====Special Cases====
  +
# For "eternal" concepts, such as ideas, they may be qualified with a time setting, thus placing them into context. For example, the idea of biology is "eternal", but a specific references to it are not.
  +
# Species articles should be written in past tense.
  +
# Articles about particular astronomical features (such as stars, star systems, planets, nebulae etc.) should be written in present tense.
   
:The ''Constitution''-class is a class of starship that was used by Starfleet in the 23rd century.
+
===Examples===
  +
Some examples of how tense should be used for in-universe articles:
  +
:"The ''Enterprise'' was a starship in the 24th century."
  +
  +
:"Penguins were waterfowl indigenous to Earth until at least the 21st century."
  +
  +
:"The ''Constitution''-class is a class of starship that was used by Starfleet in the 23rd century."
  +
  +
:"The Andorians were one of the founding members of the United Federation of Planets"
  +
  +
:"Pluto (or Sol IX) is a major planetary body in the Sol system"
   
 
The tense that should be used is simple past tense. Usage of the conditional is incorrect, such as:
 
The tense that should be used is simple past tense. Usage of the conditional is incorrect, such as:
   
:Later, ''Voyager'' would encounter an automated missile that had been reprogrammed by Torres while she was still in the Maquis.
+
:"Later, ''Voyager'' would encounter an automated missile that had been reprogrammed by Torres while she was still in the Maquis. "
   
 
The proper use of the conditional is with an if-then type syntax, such as:
 
The proper use of the conditional is with an if-then type syntax, such as:
   
:The new prototype that Torres had created would have allowed the Pralor robots to win their war against the Cravic robots.
+
:"The new prototype that Torres had created would have allowed the Pralor robots to win their war against the Cravic robots."
   
 
In that example, the robots "would" have been able to do something, if something else had happened – in this case, if Torres had allowed them to.
 
In that example, the robots "would" have been able to do something, if something else had happened – in this case, if Torres had allowed them to.
   
For articles with the {{tl|realworld}} flag, the tense should be the same as a standard encyclopedia in the present day.
+
===Citing sources and background information===
 
==Citing sources and background information==
 
 
Due to its nature, background information, apocrypha, and citations of the sources used naturally occurs outside the POV.
 
Due to its nature, background information, apocrypha, and citations of the sources used naturally occurs outside the POV.
   
Line 35: Line 35:
 
See [[Memory Alpha:Cite your sources#Episodes|Cite Your Sources]] for information on how to cite your sources in episodes.
 
See [[Memory Alpha:Cite your sources#Episodes|Cite Your Sources]] for information on how to cite your sources in episodes.
   
==Undisclosed information==
+
===Undisclosed information===
 
There are some cases in ''Star Trek'' stories in which it was made clear that certain information is highly classified, or entirely unknown due to memory wipes or similar plot twists. While in theory these things are not known to anyone within the ''Star Trek'' universe, Memory Alpha's POV is '''all-knowing''', just like the television viewer.
 
There are some cases in ''Star Trek'' stories in which it was made clear that certain information is highly classified, or entirely unknown due to memory wipes or similar plot twists. While in theory these things are not known to anyone within the ''Star Trek'' universe, Memory Alpha's POV is '''all-knowing''', just like the television viewer.
   
==Conflicts in valid resources==
+
===Conflicts in valid resources===
 
If there are subjects that have conflicting references in the stories, simply add all the given information, and optionally add a background note explaining that there is a conflict.
 
If there are subjects that have conflicting references in the stories, simply add all the given information, and optionally add a background note explaining that there is a conflict.
   
 
Similarly, if two subjects have very similar names, that conceivably could have been meant to be the same (eg [[trititanium]] vs. [[tritanium]]), create both articles and only hint at the similarity in background notes.
 
Similarly, if two subjects have very similar names, that conceivably could have been meant to be the same (eg [[trititanium]] vs. [[tritanium]]), create both articles and only hint at the similarity in background notes.
   
==Examples==
+
==Production Point of View==
  +
The '''Production''' or '''"Real World"''' point of view applies to articles about the ''Star Trek'' franchise and production (eg. articles on books, episodes, series, comics, actors, staff, etc.), which naturally are not part of the ''Star Trek'' universe.
  +
  +
All such articles should have the {{tl|realworld}} template at the top. Tense should be the same as a standard encyclopedia in the present day.
  +
  +
Some examples of how tense should be used for production articles:
  +
:Gene L. Coon was a writer and producer for ''Star Trek: The Original Series''.
  +
  +
:Star Trek is a science fiction franchise comprising six television series, ten films plus numerous books, comics, games and collectibles.
  +
  +
===Episode Articles===
  +
Articles concerning ''Star Trek'' episodes and films are a special case. Although they are covered by the production point of view, it is preferred that summaries are written from an in-universe point of view. Summaries may be written in either present or past tense. Other sections (such as the sidebar and Background Information) should be written in a standard production point of view.
  +
 
Use
 
Use
:"...Spock was a half-Human, half-Vulcan, who served as science officer – and later first officer – aboard the USS ''Enterprise''..."
+
:"In her ready room, Captain Kathryn Janeway listens to Cadet Icheb's presentation."
 
Instead of
 
Instead of
:"...Spock is the famous half-Human, half-Vulcan of ''Star Trek: The Original Series'' (TOS)..."
+
:"The episode begins with Captain Kathryn Janeway sitting in her ready room listening to Cadet Icheb's presentation."
 
==Related pages==
 
* [[Memory Alpha:Cite your sources|Cite your sources]]
 
* [[Memory Alpha:Establish context|Establish context]]
 
* [[Memory Alpha:Guide to layout|Guide to Layout]]
 
* [[Memory Alpha:Manual of Style|Manual of Style]]
 
* {{tl|realworld}}, a template to tag articles written from the real world point of view
 
   
[[Category:Memory Alpha policies|Point of view]]
+
==Maintenance Pages==
[[de:Memory Alpha:Erzählperspektive]]
+
Articles concerning the functioning of Memory Alpha fall outside of either point of view. These include the Main Page, Pages for Deletion, User pages, and Talk pages.
[[pl:Memory Alpha:Punkt widzenia]]
 
[[pt-br:Memória Alfa:Ponto de vista]]
 

Revision as of 11:17, January 21, 2008

The following is my proposed rewrite of the current POV policy to address concerns raised here. Feedback should probably go on to that discussion page.

Memory Alpha is written in several points of view (POV).

In-Universe

Memory Alpha's primary point of view is that of a character inside the fictional Star Trek universe – an archivist at Memory Alpha, the Federation library planet.

Star Trek universe articles should be written as if the described person, object, or event actually existed or occurred, exactly like in a normal encyclopedia, but with an omniscient writer. Think of Memory Alpha as an encyclopedia that exists in the Star Trek universe.

Use

"...Spock was a half-Human, half-Vulcan, who served as science officer – and later first officer – aboard the USS Enterprise..."

Instead of

"...Spock is the famous half-Human, half-Vulcan of Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS)..."

Tense

Because Star Trek stories take place in many different eras, from the beginnings of life on Earth to the 29th century and beyond, and because forthcoming stories may even expand beyond that, it is important to write all articles from a single perspective: i.e. that of someone looking back at the past. This helps to keep Memory Alpha consistent and understandable. If it helps, pretend that we're writing and viewing this data archive long after the Star Trek universe as we know it has ceased to exist.

This means using the past tense in almost all instances.

Special Cases

  1. For "eternal" concepts, such as ideas, they may be qualified with a time setting, thus placing them into context. For example, the idea of biology is "eternal", but a specific references to it are not.
  2. Species articles should be written in past tense.
  3. Articles about particular astronomical features (such as stars, star systems, planets, nebulae etc.) should be written in present tense.

Examples

Some examples of how tense should be used for in-universe articles:

"The Enterprise was a starship in the 24th century."
"Penguins were waterfowl indigenous to Earth until at least the 21st century."
"The Constitution-class is a class of starship that was used by Starfleet in the 23rd century."
"The Andorians were one of the founding members of the United Federation of Planets"
"Pluto (or Sol IX) is a major planetary body in the Sol system"

The tense that should be used is simple past tense. Usage of the conditional is incorrect, such as:

"Later, Voyager would encounter an automated missile that had been reprogrammed by Torres while she was still in the Maquis. "

The proper use of the conditional is with an if-then type syntax, such as:

"The new prototype that Torres had created would have allowed the Pralor robots to win their war against the Cravic robots."

In that example, the robots "would" have been able to do something, if something else had happened – in this case, if Torres had allowed them to.

Citing sources and background information

Due to its nature, background information, apocrypha, and citations of the sources used naturally occurs outside the POV.

Background information and apocrypha is considered to fall under the "real world" POV and, as such, should be restricted to the appropriate sections. See the Manual of Style for more information.

See Cite Your Sources for information on how to cite your sources in episodes.

Undisclosed information

There are some cases in Star Trek stories in which it was made clear that certain information is highly classified, or entirely unknown due to memory wipes or similar plot twists. While in theory these things are not known to anyone within the Star Trek universe, Memory Alpha's POV is all-knowing, just like the television viewer.

Conflicts in valid resources

If there are subjects that have conflicting references in the stories, simply add all the given information, and optionally add a background note explaining that there is a conflict.

Similarly, if two subjects have very similar names, that conceivably could have been meant to be the same (eg trititanium vs. tritanium), create both articles and only hint at the similarity in background notes.

Production Point of View

The Production or "Real World" point of view applies to articles about the Star Trek franchise and production (eg. articles on books, episodes, series, comics, actors, staff, etc.), which naturally are not part of the Star Trek universe.

All such articles should have the {{realworld}} template at the top. Tense should be the same as a standard encyclopedia in the present day.

Some examples of how tense should be used for production articles:

Gene L. Coon was a writer and producer for Star Trek: The Original Series.
Star Trek is a science fiction franchise comprising six television series, ten films plus numerous books, comics, games and collectibles.

Episode Articles

Articles concerning Star Trek episodes and films are a special case. Although they are covered by the production point of view, it is preferred that summaries are written from an in-universe point of view. Summaries may be written in either present or past tense. Other sections (such as the sidebar and Background Information) should be written in a standard production point of view.

Use

"In her ready room, Captain Kathryn Janeway listens to Cadet Icheb's presentation."

Instead of

"The episode begins with Captain Kathryn Janeway sitting in her ready room listening to Cadet Icheb's presentation."

Maintenance Pages

Articles concerning the functioning of Memory Alpha fall outside of either point of view. These include the Main Page, Pages for Deletion, User pages, and Talk pages.

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki