(260 intermediate revisions by more than 100 users not shown)
Line 1:
Line 1:
−
{{fac}}
+
{{at|xx}}
−
A '''cloaking device'''isaform of [[stealth]] technologythatusesselectivebending of lightto render a [[starship]] or other object completely invisible to the electromagnetic spectrum and most [[sensor]]s. It has been encountered in varying forms over the centuries.
+
[[File:Cloaking device distortion.jpg|thumb|[[JamesT.Kirk|Kirk]] pointsouttheblurrydistortion of acloaked [[Klingon Bird-of-Prey|Bird-of-Prey]]]]
+
{{disambiguate|the TOS novel|Cloak (novel)|Cloak}}
+
A '''cloaking device''' is a form of [[stealth]] [[technology]] that uses selective bending of light (and other forms of energy) to render a [[starship]] or other object completely invisible to the electromagnetic spectrum and most [[sensor]]s. It has been encountered in varying forms over the centuries.
−
==History==
+
==History==
−
===Early cloaking technology===
+
===Early cloaking technology===
−
One of the earliest encounters with cloaking technology was in May [[2151]], when it was utilized by some agents of the [[Suliban Cabal]]to covertly approach the [[Enterprise (NX-01)|''Enterprise'']] and thus kidnap [[Klaang]] the [[Klingon]] from the ship's sickbay. The Suliban used cloaking devices on many of their ships, including the [[Suliban cell ship|cell ships]] and the [[Suliban stealth-cruiser|stealth-cruiser]].It is likely that the use of cloaks by the Suliban was temporally anachronistic, and the technology had been given to them by [[Future Guy|their mysterious benefactor]] from the [[29th century]]. ([[ENT]]: "[[Broken Bow]]")
[[Human]]ity's earliest-known encounter with cloaking technology came in the year [[1986]] in [[San Francisco]]. [[Admiral]] [[James T. Kirk]] decloaked the [[Klingon Bird-of-Prey]] he was commanding to waylay and frighten some whale hunters from killing two [[humpback whale]]s. ({{film|4}})
−
Duringabattleneara[[SulibanHelix]] in a classseven [[gas giant]], ''Enterprise''managedtocaptureacellship.Chief engineer [[CharlesTucker III]] studiedthedeviceinhissparetime, and in [[2152]] the ship was used tomountarescuemission.Unfortunately, Tucker'sexperiencewithcloakingtechnologywassomewhatlimited and heaccidentallydosedhishandwiththeparticlestheshipused to generatethecloakingeffect,temporarilyrenderingitinvisible.([[ENT]]:"[[Broken Bow]]","[[The Communicator]]")
+
Oneofhumanity'searliestexposurestocloaking technology was in Aprilof [[2151]], whenagentsofthe[[SulibanCabal]]approachedthestarship [[Enterprise(NX-01)|''Enterprise'']] undetectedandkidnappedaKlingonnationalnamed [[Klaang]] from the ship'ssickbay. The Suliban used cloakingdevicesonmanyoftheirships, includingthe[[Sulibancellship(spherical)|cell]][[Sulibancell ship (cylindrical)|ships]], [[Suliban stealth-cruiser|stealth-cruisers]] and [[Sulibansalvageship|salvageships]].TheSuliban'scloakingtechnologyhadbeengiven to themby[[HumanoidFigure|theirmysteriousbenefactor]]fromthe [[29th century]].({{ENT|Broken Bow|Shockwave|FutureTense}})
−
:''The Suliban cloaking devices seem to use a form of particle radiation to to alter the molecular structure of matter in order to allow light and sensor signals to pass through it. This explains why Mr. Tucker's hand was cloaked without any external power sourse or gravity field surrounding it. It would also explain why the quantum beacons could detect such cloaked vessels.''
−
''Enterprise'' learned how to penetrate a Sulibancloaking device in March2152, whenthe [[temporal agent]] [[Daniels(Crewman)|Daniels]]explainedhow to construct a [[quantumbeacon]]sothat ''Enterprise'' couldrevealthelocationof the cloakedstealth-cruiserresponsiblefor the destructionof[[ParaaganII]]. ([[ENT]]:"[[Shockwave,Part I]]")
+
During a battle near a [[Suliban helix]] in a class seven [[gas giant]], ''Enterprise'' managed to capture a cellship. Chief engineer [[Charles Tucker III]] studied the device in hisspare time, andin [[2152]] theshipwasused to mount a rescuemission.Unfortunately,Tucker'sexperiencewithcloakingtechnologywas somewhat limited and he accidentally doused his hand with the particlestheshipused to generate the cloakingeffect,temporarilyrendering it invisible. ({{ENT|BrokenBow|TheCommunicator}})
−
[[Image:RomulanBOPCloaks.jpg|thumb|Romulan bird-of-prey cloaking]] ''Enterprise'' wasalsoresponsbileforanencounterwithanotherorganizationthatusedstealth technology, the [[RomulanStar Empire]].InApril2152,the ship blundered into an entire cloaked minefieldprotecting a Romulan-claimed planet. The quantum beacons proved effective against the minefield, but when two [[RomulanBird-of-Prey (ENT)|birds-of-prey]] suddenlyarrived, ''Enterprise'' wasnotabletopentratetheirmoreadvancedcloaks.([[ENT]]:"[[Minefield]]")
+
''Enterprise'' learnedhowtopenetrateaSulibancloakingdeviceinMarch2152,when the [[temporalagent]] [[Daniels(Crewman)|Daniels]]explainedhowtoconstruct a [[quantumbeacon]] sothat ''Enterprise'' couldrevealthelocationofthecloakedstealth-cruiserresponsible for the destructionof [[Paraagan II]]. ({{ENT|Shockwave}})
−
===TheReturn of theCloak===
+
{{bginfo|Sulibancloaking devices seem to use a form of particle radiation to render objectsinvisible.}}
−
By the [[23rd century]], the very idea of practical invisibility was considered only theoretically possible as the amount of power required would be enormous. This was proven untrue in [[2266]] when the [[USS Enterprise (NCC-1701)|USS ''Enterprise'' (NCC-1701)]] encountered a Romulan [[Romulan Bird-of-Prey|bird-of-prey]] that used the device to cross the [[Romulan Neutral Zone]] and wipe out several [[Earth Outpost Station]]s. The ''Enterprise'' was able to defeat the bird-of-prey in battle, partially because the cloaked ship was still visible to tracking sensors, but there was no doubt the device itself had been a success. ([[TOS]]: "[[Balance of Terror]]")
−
Thecloakingdevice soon spread to the [[Klingon Empire]] aswell,''by virtue of an alliance between the two militaristicpowers''.OneofthefirstKlingonvesselstobeequippedwiththedevice was the [[IKSKlothos|IKS''Klothos'']],whoseCommander[[Kor]]usedittogreateffectattheBattleof[[CalebIV]]. Soon,thedevicewasstandardonalmost all Klingon vessels, suchasthe [[Klingon Bird-of-Prey|''B'rel''-class bird-of-prey]].(''[[StarTrekIII:TheSearchforSpock]]'',[[DS9]]:"[[OnceMoreUnto the Breach]]")
Ever since the ''Enterprise''<nowiki>'</nowiki>s encounter with the bird-of-prey in 2266, the [[United Federation of Planets]] has had a strong interest in cloaking technology.
−
In[[2268]],when the Federation learned that the Romulans had developed a new and improved cloaking device, that even tracking sensors could not pick up, that posed a threat to the security of the Federation. On [[stardate|stardate 5027.3]], [[Starfleet Intelligence]] sent the ''Enterprise'' on a covert mission across the [[Romulan Neutral Zone]] to acquire the new cloak. The mission was a success, and [[Starfleet]] was presumably able to develop a way to penetrate the new cloak. The Federation also presumably acquired a cloaking device from a captured Klingon bird-of-prey, dubbed the "[[HMS Bounty|HMS ''Bounty'']]", in [[2286]]. ([[TOS]]: "[[The Enterprise Incident]]"; ''[[Star Trek IV: The VoyageHome]]'')
+
===Thereturn of the cloak ===
+
By the [[23rd century]], the very idea of practical invisibility was considered only theoretically possible, due to the enormous amount of power required. This was proven untrue in [[2266]], when the {{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701}} encountered a Romulan [[Romulan Bird-of-Prey (23rd century)|Bird-of-Prey]] that used the device to cross the [[Romulan Neutral Zone]] and wipe out several [[Earth Outpost Station]]s. The ''Enterprise'' was able to defeat the Bird-of-Prey in battle, partially because the cloaked ship was still visible to tracking sensors, but there was no doubt the device itself had been a success. ({{TOS|Balance of Terror}})
−
However, dueitspeacefulnatureandhighlyprincipleddevotiontoexploration,Starfleet made verylittle of the cloakingdevice,soitwasnotmuchofaconcessionin [[2311]] whenthe Federation agreed to forgoanyfurther use of cloaking technology with the signing of the [[Treaty ofAlgeron]]. The [[BajoranProvisionalGovernment]]alsooutlawedcloakingdevices,statingthat the possession of such adeviceis highly illegal. ([[TNG]]:"[[The Pegasus]]"; [[DS9]]:"[[ProfitandLoss]]")
+
By [[2269]], thecloakingdevicehadspreadtothe[[KlingonEmpire]]aswell.One of the firstKlingonvesselstobeequippedwiththedevicewasthe {{IKS|Klothos}}, whose Commander, [[Kor]],usedit to greateffectat the Battle of [[CalebIV]]. The devicewassoonusedaboardmanyotherKlingonvessels, such asthe [[Klingon Bird-of-Prey|Bird-of-Prey]].({{TAS|The Time Trap}}; {{DS9|OnceMoreUntothe Breach}}; {{film|3}})
−
[[Image:QuarksCloakingDevice.jpg|thumb|left|Quark'scloakingdevice]]In[[2370]], [[Quark]] illegally acquired asmall cloaking device that was,ashe put it: 'not in the bestof condition', but it 'will work for about 15 minutes.'Initiallyintending to sellit, Quark instead installed in the central engine core of a [[Cardassianshuttle]],pilotedby[[NatimaLang]], to help the ship escape [[DeepSpace 9]] undetected. ([[DS9]]: "[[Profit and Loss]]")
+
{{bginfo|According to the [[Star Trek: TheNextGenerationTechnical Journal]], theRomulan cloaking device was acquiredby the Klingonsasanexchange to several{{Class|D7}} [[battlecruiser]]sfortheRomulansduring the [[Romulan-KlingonAlliance]].}}
−
Followingtheoutbreak of hostilities with the [[Dominion]] in late 2370, the Romulan Empire allowed the use of one of their own cloaks aboard the [[USS Defiant (NX-74205)|USS ''Defiant'']], although this was originally limited to usage within the [[Gamma Quadrant]]. [[Captain]] [[Benjamin Sisko]] chose to ignore this limitation on occasion. In order to ensure that the cloak was used correctly, Subcommander [[T'Rul]] was assigned to the ''Defiant'' initially, during the ship's first mission with the cloak. In exchange, Starfleet had to provide all the intelligence it received on the Dominion. ([[DS9]]: "[[The Search, Part I]] & [[The Search, Part II|PartII]]","[[Visionary]]")
+
===Federationencounters with cloakingtechnology===
In [[2268]], the Federation learned that the Romulans had developed a new and improved cloaking device; one that even tracking sensors could not pick up and that posed a threat to the security of the Federation. On [[stardate|stardate 5027.3]], [[Starfleet Intelligence]] sent the ''Enterprise'' on a covert mission across the [[Romulan Neutral Zone]] to acquire the new cloak. The mission was a success, and [[Starfleet]] was able to procure an intact, modern Romulan cloaking device for study. The Federation also acquired a cloaking device from a captured Klingon Bird-of-Prey, dubbed the "{{HMS|Bounty}}", in [[2286]]. ({{TOS|The Enterprise Incident}}; {{film|4}})
−
After the Cardassians joined the Dominion in [[2373]], and flushed the Klingons and [[Maquis]] out of their territory, the [[KlingonHighCouncil]] decided to aid the Maquisintheirfightagainst[[Cardassia]].TheyprovidedtheMaquiswith thirty [[class-4cloakingdevice]]swiththeKlingon'sunderstanding that theyweretobeusedonMaquisships. ''([[DS9]]:"[[BlazeofGlory]]")''
+
In [[2311]], with the signing of the [[TreatyofAlgeron]], the Federationexplicitlyagreednottodeveloporusecloakingtechnology.The [[BajoranProvisionalGovernment]] alsooutlawedcloakingdevices, stating that thepossessionofsucha deviceishighlyillegal. ({{TNG|The Pegasus}}; {{DS9|ProfitandLoss}})
+
{{bginfo|[[Gene Roddenberry]] indicated in various interviews that "our heroes don't sneak around", indicating that the Federation made a conscious decision to ''not'' develop cloaking technology.}}
−
[[MilesO'Brien]], [[Jadzia Dax]] and [[Rom]] alsoemployed cloaking technologytohide the [[self-replicatingmine|minefield]]blocking the [[Bajoranwormhole]].([[DS9]]:"[[CalltoArms]]")
+
[[File:Quark'scloaking device.jpg|thumb|left|Quark's cloaking device]] In [[2370]], [[Quark]] illegallyacquired a small cloaking devicethatwas, as he put it: 'not in the bestof condition', but it 'will work for about 15 minutes.' Initially intending to sell it, Quark instead installed itin the central engine core of a [[Cardassianshuttle]], piloted by [[Natima Lang]], to help the ship escape [[DeepSpace9]] undetected. ({{DS9|Profit and Loss}})
Followingtheoutbreakofhostilitieswiththe[[Dominion]]inlate2370,the Romulan Empireallowed the use of one of their own cloaks aboard the {{USS|Defiant|2370}}. Although this was originally limited to usage within the [[Gamma Quadrant]], [[Captain]][[BenjaminSisko]]chose to ignore this limitation on occasion. In order to ensure that the cloak was used correctly, Subcommander [[T'Rul]] was assigned to the ''Defiant'' initially, during the ship's first mission with the cloak. In exchange, Starfleet had to provide all the intelligence it received on the Dominion. ({{DS9|The Search, Part I|The Search, Part II|Visionary}})
−
==Mechanicsof a cloak==
+
{{bginfo|[[RonaldD. Moore]] commented: "''We wanted to throw in a line somewhere explaining that there was a follow-on agreement with the Roms that allowed us greater freedom with the cloak, but never found a comfortable place to put it.''" {{AOLchat|Ronald D. Moore|ron072|1997}}}}
−
===Components===
+
+
Prior to the Cardassians joining the Dominion in [[2373]], and flushing the Klingons and [[Maquis]] out of their territory, the [[Klingon High Council]] decided to aid the Maquis in their fight against [[Cardassia]]. They provided the Maquis with thirty [[class-4 cloaking device]]s with the Klingons' understanding that they were to be used on Maquis ships. ({{DS9|Blaze of Glory}})
+
+
In [[2373]], [[Miles O'Brien]], [[Jadzia Dax]] and [[Rom]] employed cloaking technology to hide the [[self-replicating mine|self-replicating minefield]] blocking the [[Bajoran wormhole]]. Also, the Federation equipped one of their [[Federation holoship|holoships]] with a cloak in [[2375]]. ({{DS9|Call to Arms}}; {{film|9}})
+
{{bginfo|The use of a cloaking device on the holoship would seem to be a violation of the Treaty of Algeron.}}
Although quite heavy, according to Rom, Klingon cloaking devices weigh less than Romulan cloaking devices. ({{DS9|The Emperor's New Cloak}})
+
+
It was even possible for an entire planetary body to be rendered invisible. The [[planet]] [[Aldea]] was equipped with a powerful cloaking device that allowed itself to fully cloak. ({{TNG|When The Bough Breaks}})
+
+
== Mechanics of a cloak ==
+
In order to function, a cloaking device needs to be tied into a ship's [[deflector shield]] grid. ({{TOS|The Enterprise Incident}})
+
+
{{bginfo|Along with high power consumption, this would explain why a cloaking device and a ship's shields cannot be raised at the same time. Chang's Bird of Prey, for example, did not have its shields up while cloaked in ''The Undiscovered Country''. Also, the shields on the Duras Sisters' Bird of Prey failed when the cloaking device was activated in ''Generations.}}
+
+
;Components:
*[[projection matrix]]
*[[projection matrix]]
*[[tetryon compositor]]
*[[tetryon compositor]]
−
===Penetrating the cloak===
+
===Penetrating the cloak===
−
Ever since the originalencounterwith the cloaking device, there has been an ongoing technological race between the galacticpowers; as organizations like the Federation try to develop new waysofpenetrating the cloak,thosewho use the cloak continuallydevisewaystorenderitimpenetrable.
+
Ever since the initialintroductionof the cloaking device, there has been an ongoing race between the developmentof new cloakingtechnologiesand the developmentofnewdetectionsystemsthatcandefeatthem.
−
[[Image:QuantumBeacon.jpg|thumb|Quantum beacon deployed]]The first method of penetrating a cloak was developed in 2152, when Daniels provided ''Enterprise'' with [[31st century]] [[quantum beacon]]s so they could locate a Suliban stealth-cruiser. These devices also proved effective against some Romulan cloaking devices. ([[ENT]]: "[[Shockwave, Part I]]", [[ENT]]: "[[Minefield]]")
Starfleet's earliest method of penetrating cloaks was developed in 2152, when Daniels provided ''Enterprise'' with [[31st century]] [[quantum beacon]]s so they could locate a Suliban stealth-cruiser. These devices also proved effective against the Romulan cloaking devices used on mines but were ineffective against the Bird-of-Prey cloaking devices. ({{ENT|Shockwave|Minefield}})
−
The cloak used by the Romulan bird-of-prey that crossed the Neutral Zone in 2266 was less than perfect, allowing a starship to pick up a blip on its tracking [[sensor]]s. This blip was not accurate enough for targeting of weapons and only appeared when the vessel moved, but it was enough to help the ''Enterprise'' locate the enemy vessel. By 2268, advances in Romulan technology had removed the problem, forcing Starfleet to steal a model of the new cloak. ([[TOS]]: "[[Balance of Terror]]", [[TOS]]: "[[The Enterprise Incident]]")
+
The cloak used by the Romulan Bird-of-Prey that crossed the Neutral Zone in 2266 was less than perfect, allowing a starship to pick up a blip on its motion tracking [[sensor]]s. This blip was not accurate enough for targeting of weapons and only appeared when the vessel moved, but it was enough to help the ''Enterprise'' locate the enemy vessel. By 2268, advances in Romulan technology had removed the problem, forcing Starfleet to steal a model of the new cloak. ({{TOS|Balance of Terror|The Enterprise Incident}})
−
Versions of the cloak used by the Klingons in the late [[23rd century]] also had their small flaws. Small energy distortions were detectable prior to decloaking,andin [[2293]], the [[USSEnterprise (NCC-1701-A)|''Enterprise''-A]] developed a method of using a torpedo to track the [[plasma exhaust]] of a cloaked ship. (''[[Star Trek III: The Search for Spock]]'', ''[[Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country]]'')
+
Versions of the cloak used by the Klingons in the late [[23rd century]] also had their flaws. Cloaked {{Class|D7}} [[battle cruiser]]s could be detected using a [[metaphasic sweep]]. ({{VOY|Prophecy}})Visible energy distortions were detectable while cloaked and prior to decloaking.({{film|3}})In [[2293]], the {{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701-A|-A}} developed a method of using a [[photon torpedo]] to track the [[plasma exhaust]] of a cloaked ship. ({{film|6}})
−
In the [[24th century]], the Federation protected its borders from cloaked Romulan incursion by a [[gravitic sensor net]]. In [[2368]], [[Geordi La Forge]] developed a technique called the [[tachyon detection grid]] that used tachyon beams transmitted between different points to expose cloaked objects. Soon, this had been implemented on the Federation's border outposts as well as in Klingon space. ([[TNG]]: "[[Redemption, Part II]]", "[[Face of the Enemy]]"; [[DS9]]: "[[Apocalypse Rising]]")
+
In the [[24th century]], the Federation protected its borders from cloaked Romulan incursion by a [[gravitic sensor net]]. In [[2368]], [[Geordi La Forge]] developed a technique called the [[tachyon detection grid]] that used tachyon beams transmitted between different points to expose cloaked objects. Soon, this had been implemented on the Federation's border outposts as well as in Klingon space. ({{TNG|Redemption II|Face of the Enemy}}; {{DS9|Apocalypse Rising}})
−
Whatis not commonly known,is that cloaked ships radiate a slight subspace variance at warp speeds. These variances are typically eliminated once the vessel drops out of warp. ''([[DS9]]: "[[The Search, Part I]]")'' If a cloaked ship exceeds it's maximum speed by pushing it maximum poweroutput, it will not be able to fully cloak, and will appear on navigational sensors as a sensor echo. ([[TNG]]: "[[Tin Man]]")
+
In[[2371]] it was not commonly understood by Starfleetpersonnel that cloaked ships radiate a slight subspace variance at warp speeds. These variances typically vanished once the vessel drops out of warp. ({{DS9|The Search, Part I}}) If a cloaked ship exceeds its maximum propulsioncapacity, it will not be able to fully cloak, and will appear on navigational sensors as a sensor echo. ({{TNG|Tin Man}})
−
Using modified cloaks, a combined fleet of Romulan and [[Cardassian]] warships attempted to conduct a sneak attack on [[Founders' homeworld]] in 2371. They determined that as long as their fleet travelled under the speed of [[warp factor|warp 6]] their [[warp signature]]s would remain undetected, even while under cloak. This modification, however, did not prevent the fleet from being detected by the sensors aboard [[Deep Space 9]]. In this case, the cloaked fleet appeared as high concentrations of [[tetryon particle]]s. ([[DS9]]: "[[The Die is Cast]]")
+
Using modified cloaks, a combined fleet of Romulan and [[Cardassian]] warships attempted to conduct a sneak attack on [[Founders' homeworld]] in 2371. They determined that as long as their fleet traveled under the speed of [[warp factor|warp 6]] their [[warp signature]]s would remain undetected, even while under cloak. This modification, however, did not prevent the fleet from being detected by the sensors aboard [[Deep Space 9]]. In this case, the cloaked fleet appeared as high concentrations of [[tetryon]] particles. ({{DS9|The Die is Cast}})
−
The[[Dominion]],aswellasthe Cardassians, also possessedmanymethodsofbreakingthroughcloakingfields,includinga[[long-rangetachyonscanner]]andan [[antiproton beam]]. ([[DS9]]: "[[TheSearch,PartI]]","[[OnceMore Unto the Breach]]") However, these methods were not always effective as [[ThomasRiker]] was able to partiallycounteracttheantiprotonbeamscanningmethod by adjusting the cloak's resonancefrequency. ([[DS9]]:"[[Defiant(episode)|''Defiant'']]")
+
SensorsaboardDeepSpace9were also abletodetectanentirenearbyfleetofcloakedKlingonvesselsjumpingtowarpas "ahugedistortionwaveinsubspace", and [[MilesO'Brien]] was able to deducetheirheadingfromthevectorof the subspacedisturbance. ({{DS9|TheWayof the Warrior}})
−
==Improvementsin cloaking technology==
+
The[[Dominion]], as well as the Cardassians, also possessed many methods of breaking through cloaking fields, including a [[long-range tachyon scanner]] and an [[antiproton beam]]. ({{DS9|The Search, Part I|Once More Unto the Breach}}) However, these methods were not always effective as [[Thomas Riker]] was able to partially counteract the antiproton beam scanning method by adjusting the cloak's resonance frequency. ({{DS9|Defiant}})
−
===Firing when cloaked===
−
Due to the enormous amount of power required to generate a cloaking field, there is by and large not enough power available to also power the weapons and shields. However, there have been several times when advances in cloaking technology have rendered this untrue.
−
The mirror universe [[ISS Enterprise (NX-01)]] appears able to fire weapons while cloaked using a [[Suliban]] cloaking device. ([[ENT]]: ''[[In a Mirror, Darkly]]'')
−
[[Image:ChangsShip.jpg|thumb|right|IKS''Kronos One'', firing while cloaked]] For example, in 2293, the Klingons developed a [[prototype]] bird-of-prey capable of firing when cloaked. This ship, commaned by [[Chang (General)|General Chang]] was used to secretly attack the [[IKS Kronos One|IKS ''Kronos One'']] in such a way that it appeared the USS ''Enterprise''-A was responsible, implicating ''Enterprise'' commanding officer [[James T. Kirk]] in an attempted assassination of [[Chancellor of the Klingon High Council|Chancellor]] [[Gorkon]]. Fortunately for galactic peace, the ''Enterprise''-A was able to deduce the existence of Chang's ship and devise a way to penetrate its cloak by tracking its plasma exhaust with new sensors for analyzing gaseous anomalies. The prototype ship was destroyed by the ''Enterprise''-A and the [[USS Excelsior|''Excelsior'']] over [[Khitomer]]. (''[[Star Trek VI: TheUndiscoveredCountry]]'')
+
==Improvements in cloakingtechnology==
+
=== Firing when cloaked ===
+
Due to the enormous amount of power required to generate a cloaking field, there is by and large not enough power available to also power the weapons and shields. ({{TOS|Balance of Terror}}) When the Romulan cloaking device was first installed on the {{USS|Defiant|2370}}, the ship even had to decloak to use the [[transporter]]. ({{DS9|The Search, Part I}}) However, there have been several times when advances in cloaking technology have rendered these tactical inefficiencies untrue.
−
Another advanced cloak was encountered in [[2379]]. The [[Reman]] warbird ''[[Scimitar]]'' employed a new type of cloaking device that allowed the ship to fire weapons and use shields while cloaked. Not only this, but the device didn't give off any [[tachyon]] emissions or residual [[antiproton]]s, making the ''Scimitar'' completely undetectable while cloaked. The effectiveness of this technology was demonstrated at the [[Battle of the Bassen Rift]], where the Scimitar engaged the [[USS Enterprise (NCC-1701-E)|USS''Enterprise''-E]], the [[IRW Valdore|IRW ''Valdore'']] and another warbird, and was able to destroy one of the warbirds and cripple the other without suffering any significant damage. Only through repeated blind targeting and barrages of phasers and torpedoes was the ''Enterprise''-Eabletodisable the ''Scimitar''<nowiki>'</nowiki>s cloak. (''[[Star Trek: Nemesis]]'')
For example, in [[2293]], the Klingons developed a [[prototype]] Bird-of-Prey capable of firing [[photon torpedo]]es when cloaked. This ship, commanded by [[Chang (General)|General Chang]] was used to secretly attack ''[[Kronos One]]'' in such a way that it appeared the USS ''Enterprise''-A was responsible, implicating ''Enterprise'' commanding officer [[James T. Kirk]] in an attempted assassination of [[Chancellor of the Klingon High Council|Chancellor]] [[Gorkon]]. Fortunately for galactic peace, the ''Enterprise''-A was able to deduce the existence of Chang's ship and devise a way to penetrate its cloak by tracking its plasma exhaust with new sensors for analyzing gaseous anomalies. The prototype ship was destroyed by the ''Enterprise''-A and the {{USS|Excelsior}} over [[Khitomer]]. ({{film|6}})
−
===Theinterphasecloak===
+
{{bginfo|Inthescript for ''Star Trek VI'', the development of this cloaking device is said to have cost "millions".}}
−
[[Image:Federation cloaking device.jpg|thumb|Interphase cloaking device]]The Treaty of Algeron did not stop [[Starfleet Intelligence]] from secretly and illegally developing the [[interphase cloaking device]], a device which not only rendered a starship invisible, but also allowed it to pass through solid matter unimpeded. The device was lost in [[2358]] when the testbed vessel, the [[USS Pegasus|USS ''Pegasus'']] was destroyed in a mutiny by members of the crew concerned about the legality of the test. In [[2370]], the existence of the illegal device was made public to the Romulans. ([[TNG]]: "[[The Pegasus]]")
−
In[[2368]]theRomulansalsounsuccessfully experimented with phased cloaking technology, developing a [[interphase generator|prototype]]. The [[USSEnterprise (NCC-1701-D)|USS ''Enterprise''-D]]had received a distresssignalfromthe[[Romulansciencevessel|testbedvessel]],and [[Captain]] [[Jean-LucPicard]]ordered an [[away team]] sentovertoassist.Duringthemission,dueto a malfunction in the device,[[Ensign]][[RoLaren]] and [[LieutenantCommander]][[GeordiLa Forge]] were phase-cloaked during beam-out, andrematerializedondifferent parts of the ''Enterprise''. After several attempts to bring them back, the crewgaveup,believingthemdead.Soon,RoandLaForgeencounteredasimilarlyphase-cloakedRomulanofficerthathadfollowedthemto the Enterpriseinanattempt to keep the newcloakingdeviceasecret.Theyfought off the Romulan, who was trying to killthem,andthrewhimthroughabulkheadandoutofthe''Enterprise''completely. Eventually,RoandLaForgesucceededinrevealingwhathadhappenedtothemtothecrew, andLieutenant Commander [[Data]] managedtoreversetheeffectsof the cloak, bringing them back into phase. ([[TNG]]: "[[The Next Phase]]")
+
Anotheradvancedcloakwasencounteredin [[2379]]. The [[Reman]]warbird ''[[Scimitar]]'' employed a newtypeof"perfect"cloakingdevicethatdidnot give off any [[tachyon]] emissionsorresidual [[antiproton]]s,makingthe''Scimitar''completelyundetectablewhilecloaked.Itallowed the shiptofireweapons and useshieldswhile cloaked, aswellasallow the ship to drop the cloakprotectingcertainquadrantsoftheshipwithoutde-cloakingtheentireshipatonce.Theeffectivenessofthistechnologywasdemonstratedwhen the ''Scimitar''engagedthe{{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701-E|-E}}, the [[IRWValdore|IRW''Valdore'']],andanotherwarbirdin the [[Bassen Rift]], and was able to destroyoneofthewarbirdsandcrippletheotherwithoutsufferinganysignificantdamage. Onlythroughrepeatedblindtargeting,barragesofphasersandtorpedoes,andtheuseoftelepathictriangulationby Commander [[Deanna Troi]] wasthe''Enterprise''-Eabletoovercome the ''Scimitar''{{'}}s cloak. ({{film|10}})
−
==Shipsutilizing cloaking devices==
+
Inaddition, the [[mirror universe]] {{ISS|Enterprise|NX-01}} was able to fire weapons while cloaked using a [[Suliban]] cloaking device. However, the cloak did appear to ''momentarily'' fail a few seconds after ''Enterprise'' launched torpedoes, perhaps indicating that the Imperial ship had insufficient power for simultaneous use of weapons and cloak. ({{ENT|In a Mirror, Darkly}})
''Inan [[anti-time future|alternate future]], [[Klingon attack cruiser]]s apparently have the ability to fire while cloaked, as they are able to damage the {{USS|Pasteur}} before decloaking. ({{TNG|All Good Things...}})''
[[File:Enterpriseinterphase decloaking.jpg|thumb|TheEnterprise-Ddecloaking in front of aRomulanwarbird.]]
+
The Treaty of Algeron did not stop [[Starfleet Intelligence]] from secretly and illegally developing the [[phasing cloak]], a device which not only rendered a starship invisible, but also allowed it to pass through solid matter unimpeded. The device was lost in [[2358]] when the testbed vessel, the {{USS|Pegasus}} was presumed destroyed by a [[warp core breach]] in a mutiny by members of the crew concerned about the legality of the test. In [[2370]], the ''Pegasus'' was found not to have been destroyed and the existence of the illegal device was made public to the Romulans. ({{TNG|The Pegasus}})
+
+
In the early [[2360s]], the Klingon Empire experimented with interphase cloaking technology but the research was abandoned due to several accidents.
+
+
In [[2368]] the Romulans also unsuccessfully experimented with interphase cloaking technology, developing a [[interphase generator|prototype]]. The {{USS|Enterprise|NCC-1701-D|-D}} had received a distress signal from the [[Romulan science vessel|testbed vessel]] and [[Captain]] [[Jean-Luc Picard|Picard]] ordered an [[away team]] sent over to assist. During the mission, due to a malfunction in the device, [[Ensign]] [[Ro Laren]] and [[Lieutenant Commander]] [[Geordi La Forge]] were phase-cloaked during beam-out and rematerialized on different parts of the ''Enterprise''. After attempting to bring them back, the crew gave up, believing them dead. Eventually, Ro and La Forge succeeded in revealing what had happened to them to the crew and Lieutenant Commander [[Data]] managed to reverse the effects of the cloak, bringing them back into phase. ({{TNG|The Next Phase}})
+
+
== Other cloaking device effects ==
+
The use of cloaking devices has occasionally led to unintended effects. The cloaking device of [[Aldea]] caused significant damage to the [[planet]]'s [[ionosphere]] and [[ozone layer]], leading to increased [[radiation]] on the surface and sterility amongst the [[Aldean]]s. ({{TNG|When The Bough Breaks}})
+
+
In [[2371]], [[chroniton]] particles generated by the Romulan cloaking device aboard the USS ''Defiant'' became lodged in the ship's [[ablative armor]] matrix. These particles interacted with the ship's [[transporter]] systems, resulting in the accidental transport of several officers backwards through time to early [[21st century]] [[Earth]]. ({{DS9|Past Tense, Part I}})
+
+
In [[2372]], a computer character manifesting itself as fear was offered a cloaking device as a means of keeping its program hidden from future intrusion. To the request, it replied: "I already have a cloaking device, thank you anyway." The character's "cloaking device" immediately wrapped the character in a wool cloak. ({{VOY|The Thaw}})
+
+
=== The temporal cloak ===
+
This form of cloak has only been seen in use by one of the many species that inhabit the delta quadrant. The [[Krenim]] were known to use this technology. It pushed the user out of space-time preventing detection through normal means. This was a side effect of the temporal core of the [[Krenim weapon ship]]. {{Incite}}
+
+
== Ships utilizing cloaking devices ==
+
=== Classes ===
+
* {{Class|B'rel}} ([[Klingon Defense Force]])
+
* [[Romulan Bird-of-Prey (22nd century)|Bird-of-Prey (22nd century)]] ([[Romulan Star Empire]])
+
* [[Romulan Bird-of-Prey (23rd century)|Bird-of-Prey (23rd century)]] ([[Romulan Star Empire]])
There has been some controversy over the appearance of the cloaking device in ''[[Star Trek: Enterprise]]''. {{TOS|Balance of Terror}} makes it reasonably clear that this is the first time such a device has been encountered, and early ''Enterprise'' episodes skirted very close to violating this by referring to the invisibility technology seen in {{ENT|Broken Bow|Unexpected}} as stealth technology; presumably this was intended to be a primitive precursor to cloaking, utilizing some method other than the selective bending of light.
+
+
Unfortunately, the episode {{e|Shockwave}} featured several explicit references to the Suliban stealth technology as cloaking. {{e|Minefield}} further complicated the problem by showing that the Romulans had cloaking technology in the [[22nd century]], making some possible justifications no longer workable. Unfortunately, there is no obvious way to reconcile the discrepancies, except to force an interpretation of Spock's words ("''Invisibility is theoretically possible, Captain– selectively bending light. But the power cost is enormous. They may have solved that''.") to mean that the Federation thought invisibility was impossible because all previous forms of cloaking had been penetrated. Then again, Spock's notions regarding this particular matter may not represent the totality of Starfleet's expertise, as even he admits that he is not as qualified as Mr. Scott is when it comes to engineering. ({{TOS|The Devil in the Dark}})
+
+
Several staff writers on ''Star Trek: Enterprise'' – among them Producer [[Mike Sussman]] – believed it was a mistake to give cloaking technology to 22nd Century Romulans. Season Four showrunner and Co-Executive Producer [[Manny Coto]] decided that Romulan ships would not have cloaks in any subsequent encounters. (''Information provided by Mike Sussman'')
+
+
In apocrypha the discrepancy is explained in the novel ''[[The Good That Men Do]]''. The 22nd century Bird-of-Prey class ships were only used as testbeds for early prototype cloaking devices. After an antimatter-containment failure in one test systems, their use was abandoned and it took decades for the Romulans to develop a successful cloaking system.
−
==BackgroundInformation==
+
There is also a running discrepancy as to whether or not the Mirror Universe has cloaking devices. Whilst they have been seen in early mirror episodes of DS9, the last "mirror" episode featured a plot revolving around the "fact" that the technology doesn't exist in the mirror universe.
−
There has been some controversy over the appearance of the cloaking device in ''[[Star Trek: Enterprise]]''. [[TOS]]: "[[Balance of Terror]]" makes it reasonably clear that this is the first time such a device has been encountered, and early ''Enterprise'' episodes skirted very close to violating this by referring to the invisibility technology seen in [[ENT]]: "[[Broken Bow]]" and "[[Unexpected]]" as stealth technology; presumably this was intended to be a primitve precursor to cloaking utilizing some method other than the selective bending of light.
−
Unfortunately,theepisode "[[Shockwave,Part I]]"featuredseveralexplicit references to the Suliban stealth technology as cloaking. "[[Minefield]]"furthercomplicated the problem by showingthe Romulans had cloaks back in the [[22nd century]], makingsomepossiblejustificationsnolongerworkable. Unfortunately, there is no obvious way to reconcile the discrepancies, except to force an interpretation of Spock's words ("Invisibility is theoretically possible, Captain-- selectively bending light. Butthepowercostisenormous.Theymayhavesolvedthat.")tomean that the Federationthoughtinvisiblity was impossible because all previous forms of cloaking had beenpenetrated.
+
Ina [[deletedscene]] from{{film|11}},after the ''[[Narada]]''isdisabled by {{USS|Kelvin}}'sattack in [[2233]], ten[[Klingon]][[Klingonwarbird|warbirds]]decloakandsurround[[Nero]]'s ship. ThiswouldindicateKlingonshadsomeformofstealthtechnologyinuseby2233in the primeuniverseaswell.
−
Analternativetheoryis that history as presented in ''Enterprise'' has been distorted by the [[Temporal Cold War]]. This can certainly explain the early encountering of Suliban cloaking technology. As for the Romulans it is possible that they have been given cloaks earlier than originally by agents from the future.
Cloak redirects here. For the TOS novel, please see Cloak (novel).
A cloaking device is a form of stealthtechnology that uses selective bending of light (and other forms of energy) to render a starship or other object completely invisible to the electromagnetic spectrum and most sensors. It has been encountered in varying forms over the centuries.
During a battle near a Suliban helix in a class seven gas giant, Enterprise managed to capture a cell ship. Chief engineer Charles Tucker III studied the device in his spare time, and in 2152 the ship was used to mount a rescue mission. Unfortunately, Tucker's experience with cloaking technology was somewhat limited and he accidentally doused his hand with the particles the ship used to generate the cloaking effect, temporarily rendering it invisible. (ENT: "Broken Bow", "The Communicator")
Enterprise learned how to penetrate a Suliban cloaking device in March 2152, when the temporal agentDaniels explained how to construct a quantum beacon so that Enterprise could reveal the location of the cloaked stealth-cruiser responsible for the destruction of Paraagan II. (ENT: "Shockwave")
Suliban cloaking devices seem to use a form of particle radiation to render objects invisible.
RomulanBird-of-Prey cloakingEnterprise was also responsible for an encounter with another organization that used stealth technology, the Romulan Star Empire. In April 2152, the ship accidentally entered a cloaked minefield protecting a Romulan-claimed planet. The quantum beacons proved effective against the minefield, but when two Birds-of-Prey suddenly arrived, Enterprise was not able to penetrate their more advanced cloaks. (ENT: "Minefield")
By the 23rd century, the very idea of practical invisibility was considered only theoretically possible, due to the enormous amount of power required. This was proven untrue in 2266, when the USS Enterprise encountered a Romulan Bird-of-Prey that used the device to cross the Romulan Neutral Zone and wipe out several Earth Outpost Stations. The Enterprise was able to defeat the Bird-of-Prey in battle, partially because the cloaked ship was still visible to tracking sensors, but there was no doubt the device itself had been a success. (TOS: "Balance of Terror")
Federation encounters with cloaking technology Edit
The improved Romulan cloak
In 2268, the Federation learned that the Romulans had developed a new and improved cloaking device; one that even tracking sensors could not pick up and that posed a threat to the security of the Federation. On stardate 5027.3, Starfleet Intelligence sent the Enterprise on a covert mission across the Romulan Neutral Zone to acquire the new cloak. The mission was a success, and Starfleet was able to procure an intact, modern Romulan cloaking device for study. The Federation also acquired a cloaking device from a captured Klingon Bird-of-Prey, dubbed the "HMS Bounty", in 2286. (TOS: "The Enterprise Incident"; Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home)
Gene Roddenberry indicated in various interviews that "our heroes don't sneak around", indicating that the Federation made a conscious decision to not develop cloaking technology.
Quark's cloaking device In 2370, Quark illegally acquired a small cloaking device that was, as he put it: 'not in the best of condition', but it 'will work for about 15 minutes.' Initially intending to sell it, Quark instead installed it in the central engine core of a Cardassian shuttle, piloted by Natima Lang, to help the ship escape Deep Space 9 undetected. (DS9: "Profit and Loss")
Following the outbreak of hostilities with the Dominion in late 2370, the Romulan Empire allowed the use of one of their own cloaks aboard the USS Defiant. Although this was originally limited to usage within the Gamma Quadrant, CaptainBenjamin Sisko chose to ignore this limitation on occasion. In order to ensure that the cloak was used correctly, Subcommander T'Rul was assigned to the Defiant initially, during the ship's first mission with the cloak. In exchange, Starfleet had to provide all the intelligence it received on the Dominion. (DS9: "The Search, Part I", "The Search, Part II", "Visionary")
Ronald D. Moore commented: "We wanted to throw in a line somewhere explaining that there was a follow-on agreement with the Roms that allowed us greater freedom with the cloak, but never found a comfortable place to put it." (AOL chat,1997)
Prior to the Cardassians joining the Dominion in 2373, and flushing the Klingons and Maquis out of their territory, the Klingon High Council decided to aid the Maquis in their fight against Cardassia. They provided the Maquis with thirty class-4 cloaking devices with the Klingons' understanding that they were to be used on Maquis ships. (DS9: "Blaze of Glory")
The use of a cloaking device on the holoship would seem to be a violation of the Treaty of Algeron.
A Klingon cloaking device.
Although quite heavy, according to Rom, Klingon cloaking devices weigh less than Romulan cloaking devices. (DS9: "The Emperor's New Cloak")
It was even possible for an entire planetary body to be rendered invisible. The planetAldea was equipped with a powerful cloaking device that allowed itself to fully cloak. (TNG: "When The Bough Breaks")
Along with high power consumption, this would explain why a cloaking device and a ship's shields cannot be raised at the same time. Chang's Bird of Prey, for example, did not have its shields up while cloaked in The Undiscovered Country. Also, the shields on the Duras Sisters' Bird of Prey failed when the cloaking device was activated in Generations.
Ever since the initial introduction of the cloaking device, there has been an ongoing race between the development of new cloaking technologies and the development of new detection systems that can defeat them.
Quantum beacon deployed
Starfleet's earliest method of penetrating cloaks was developed in 2152, when Daniels provided Enterprise with 31st centuryquantum beacons so they could locate a Suliban stealth-cruiser. These devices also proved effective against the Romulan cloaking devices used on mines but were ineffective against the Bird-of-Prey cloaking devices. (ENT: "Shockwave", "Minefield")
The cloak used by the Romulan Bird-of-Prey that crossed the Neutral Zone in 2266 was less than perfect, allowing a starship to pick up a blip on its motion tracking sensors. This blip was not accurate enough for targeting of weapons and only appeared when the vessel moved, but it was enough to help the Enterprise locate the enemy vessel. By 2268, advances in Romulan technology had removed the problem, forcing Starfleet to steal a model of the new cloak. (TOS: "Balance of Terror", "The Enterprise Incident")
In 2371 it was not commonly understood by Starfleet personnel that cloaked ships radiate a slight subspace variance at warp speeds. These variances typically vanished once the vessel drops out of warp. (DS9: "The Search, Part I") If a cloaked ship exceeds its maximum propulsion capacity, it will not be able to fully cloak, and will appear on navigational sensors as a sensor echo. (TNG: "Tin Man")
Using modified cloaks, a combined fleet of Romulan and Cardassian warships attempted to conduct a sneak attack on Founders' homeworld in 2371. They determined that as long as their fleet traveled under the speed of warp 6 their warp signatures would remain undetected, even while under cloak. This modification, however, did not prevent the fleet from being detected by the sensors aboard Deep Space 9. In this case, the cloaked fleet appeared as high concentrations of tetryon particles. (DS9: "The Die is Cast")
Sensors aboard Deep Space 9 were also able to detect an entire nearby fleet of cloaked Klingon vessels jumping to warp as "a huge distortion wave in subspace", and Miles O'Brien was able to deduce their heading from the vector of the subspace disturbance. (DS9: "The Way of the Warrior")
Due to the enormous amount of power required to generate a cloaking field, there is by and large not enough power available to also power the weapons and shields. (TOS: "Balance of Terror") When the Romulan cloaking device was first installed on the USS Defiant, the ship even had to decloak to use the transporter. (DS9: "The Search, Part I") However, there have been several times when advances in cloaking technology have rendered these tactical inefficiencies untrue.
Prototype Bird-of-Prey, firing while cloaked
For example, in 2293, the Klingons developed a prototype Bird-of-Prey capable of firing photon torpedoes when cloaked. This ship, commanded by General Chang was used to secretly attack Kronos One in such a way that it appeared the USS Enterprise-A was responsible, implicating Enterprise commanding officer James T. Kirk in an attempted assassination of ChancellorGorkon. Fortunately for galactic peace, the Enterprise-A was able to deduce the existence of Chang's ship and devise a way to penetrate its cloak by tracking its plasma exhaust with new sensors for analyzing gaseous anomalies. The prototype ship was destroyed by the Enterprise-A and the USS Excelsior over Khitomer. (Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country)
In the script for Star Trek VI, the development of this cloaking device is said to have cost "millions".
Another advanced cloak was encountered in 2379. The Reman warbird Scimitar employed a new type of "perfect" cloaking device that did not give off any tachyon emissions or residual antiprotons, making the Scimitar completely undetectable while cloaked. It allowed the ship to fire weapons and use shields while cloaked, as well as allow the ship to drop the cloak protecting certain quadrants of the ship without de-cloaking the entire ship at once. The effectiveness of this technology was demonstrated when the Scimitar engaged the USS Enterprise-E, the IRW Valdore, and another warbird in the Bassen Rift, and was able to destroy one of the warbirds and cripple the other without suffering any significant damage. Only through repeated blind targeting, barrages of phasers and torpedoes, and the use of telepathic triangulation by Commander Deanna Troi was the Enterprise-E able to overcome the Scimitar's cloak. (Star Trek Nemesis)
In addition, the mirror universeISS Enterprise was able to fire weapons while cloaked using a Suliban cloaking device. However, the cloak did appear to momentarily fail a few seconds after Enterprise launched torpedoes, perhaps indicating that the Imperial ship had insufficient power for simultaneous use of weapons and cloak. (ENT: "In a Mirror, Darkly")
Phasing cloak deviceThe Enterprise-D decloaking in front of a Romulan warbird.
The Treaty of Algeron did not stop Starfleet Intelligence from secretly and illegally developing the phasing cloak, a device which not only rendered a starship invisible, but also allowed it to pass through solid matter unimpeded. The device was lost in 2358 when the testbed vessel, the USS Pegasus was presumed destroyed by a warp core breach in a mutiny by members of the crew concerned about the legality of the test. In 2370, the Pegasus was found not to have been destroyed and the existence of the illegal device was made public to the Romulans. (TNG: "The Pegasus")
In the early 2360s, the Klingon Empire experimented with interphase cloaking technology but the research was abandoned due to several accidents.
In 2368 the Romulans also unsuccessfully experimented with interphase cloaking technology, developing a prototype. The USS Enterprise-D had received a distress signal from the testbed vessel and CaptainPicard ordered an away team sent over to assist. During the mission, due to a malfunction in the device, EnsignRo Laren and Lieutenant CommanderGeordi La Forge were phase-cloaked during beam-out and rematerialized on different parts of the Enterprise. After attempting to bring them back, the crew gave up, believing them dead. Eventually, Ro and La Forge succeeded in revealing what had happened to them to the crew and Lieutenant Commander Data managed to reverse the effects of the cloak, bringing them back into phase. (TNG: "The Next Phase")
In 2371, chroniton particles generated by the Romulan cloaking device aboard the USS Defiant became lodged in the ship's ablative armor matrix. These particles interacted with the ship's transporter systems, resulting in the accidental transport of several officers backwards through time to early 21st centuryEarth. (DS9: "Past Tense, Part I")
In 2372, a computer character manifesting itself as fear was offered a cloaking device as a means of keeping its program hidden from future intrusion. To the request, it replied: "I already have a cloaking device, thank you anyway." The character's "cloaking device" immediately wrapped the character in a wool cloak. (VOY: "The Thaw")
This form of cloak has only been seen in use by one of the many species that inhabit the delta quadrant. The Krenim were known to use this technology. It pushed the user out of space-time preventing detection through normal means. This was a side effect of the temporal core of the Krenim weapon ship. (citation needed • edit)
There has been some controversy over the appearance of the cloaking device in Star Trek: Enterprise. TOS: "Balance of Terror" makes it reasonably clear that this is the first time such a device has been encountered, and early Enterprise episodes skirted very close to violating this by referring to the invisibility technology seen in ENT: "Broken Bow", "Unexpected" as stealth technology; presumably this was intended to be a primitive precursor to cloaking, utilizing some method other than the selective bending of light.
Unfortunately, the episode "Shockwave" featured several explicit references to the Suliban stealth technology as cloaking. "Minefield" further complicated the problem by showing that the Romulans had cloaking technology in the 22nd century, making some possible justifications no longer workable. Unfortunately, there is no obvious way to reconcile the discrepancies, except to force an interpretation of Spock's words ("Invisibility is theoretically possible, Captain– selectively bending light. But the power cost is enormous. They may have solved that.") to mean that the Federation thought invisibility was impossible because all previous forms of cloaking had been penetrated. Then again, Spock's notions regarding this particular matter may not represent the totality of Starfleet's expertise, as even he admits that he is not as qualified as Mr. Scott is when it comes to engineering. (TOS: "The Devil in the Dark")
Several staff writers on Star Trek: Enterprise – among them Producer Mike Sussman – believed it was a mistake to give cloaking technology to 22nd Century Romulans. Season Four showrunner and Co-Executive Producer Manny Coto decided that Romulan ships would not have cloaks in any subsequent encounters. (Information provided by Mike Sussman)
In apocrypha the discrepancy is explained in the novel The Good That Men Do. The 22nd century Bird-of-Prey class ships were only used as testbeds for early prototype cloaking devices. After an antimatter-containment failure in one test systems, their use was abandoned and it took decades for the Romulans to develop a successful cloaking system.
There is also a running discrepancy as to whether or not the Mirror Universe has cloaking devices. Whilst they have been seen in early mirror episodes of DS9, the last "mirror" episode featured a plot revolving around the "fact" that the technology doesn't exist in the mirror universe.
In a deleted scene from Star Trek, after the Narada is disabled by USS Kelvin's attack in 2233, ten Klingonwarbirds decloak and surround Nero's ship. This would indicate Klingons had some form of stealth technology in use by 2233 in the prime universe as well.
This is a featured article. At the time it was featured (May 2005) it was considered one of the best examples of the Memory Alpha community's work. Even so, if you see a way this page can be improved even further, we invite you to contribute. Please also check the links below to see how the article has changed since it was featured more than two years ago.Featured revision (95631) • Diff to current • Blurb